4 ms·
So, it's nice to think of civics and arts. I think these should be more heavily stressed in k-12. The great majority will go beyond secondary education, so we
by mc32 11y ago
So, it's nice to think of civics and arts. I think these should be more heavily stressed in k-12. The great majority will go beyond secondary education, so we can "waste" more time on civics, art and morality.
On the other hand, people first and foremost want survival, they want to find a modicum of success in this new world economy. Liberal arts students know all too well how their prospects compare to those of others who chose CS, finance, statistics, etc. Just listen to the bitter kids on npr who rag on the new economy. They feel left out, and they are right, they are falling behind. Their professions of choice are not as prestigious any more.
She can make these claims being an exception at the top. Most people following her would probably feel disappointed at their achievement, if they were to follow.
Higher ed is not like it was 100 - 200 years ago where the idle children of the rich could explore their fancy ideas about civilization and humanity. Most people just want to be employable, that is all.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoFolks today have it easier, not harder, than folks 100-200 years ago. There's something very wrong if we cannot afford more arts and civics today. Also, I'm not ready to consign the bulk of the country to a life of labor. Instead of, for instance, exploring what makes us human. Are there no workhouses? Are there no prisons?
- soneca 11y agoNot to contradict your conclusion, but I believe "folks" in general have it easier now. But the "folks that went to university" 200 years ago had it easier than "folks that go to university" now. 200 years ago the privileges of the elite were much more permanent and resilient than they are now. And even if this is false, the university was much more exclusive back then. Meaning it was a much more elite elite.
- cstross 11y ago200 years ago, we're talking about 1815. Universities were largely training schools for clergymen; surgeons were jumped-up barbers: medical doctors were a trade guild taught by apprenticeship -- only in 1815 in England with the passing of the Apothecaries Act was a requirement introduced for those practicing as doctors without a university degree to be examined for a license. Women were excluded not only from higher education but from education in general (with the exception of a governess or tutor for the daughters of well-to-do families), and the really privileged didn't bother with university at all -- that was for younger sons, the eldest (inheriting) sons went to Eton or Harrow then into the House of Lords. The great flowering of universities as colleges of liberal arts -- and of scientific research in general -- happened a lot later, generally in the 1870-1970 period. History is another planet, populated by fascinating aliens.
- mc32 11y agoAnd so you see how easily this novelist fell for a romantic vision of liberal arts which enrich us all and free us of mental shackles and deliver us to the "promise" land of enlightened beings.
- cstross 11y agoSpeaking as a novelist myself, I think she's exactly right. (And yes, I have a CS degree. Oddly, it didn't teach me anything useful about participation in civic life or how to understand the ethical implications of a proposed course of action.)
- mc32 11y agoThat is great. It's nice that people can be successful in a liberal arts career. I applaud it, but I don't think we should try to emphasize it when people are simply looking for a way to make a living. Sure, emphasize it in K-12, but don't structure it as a career path. Rather something which supplements a path to career.
- ska 11y agoThere is a difference between a "liberal arts career" and a "liberal arts education". Arguably the latter is exactly what you describe (supplementing).
- soneca 11y agoThanks, nice comment. I used the "200 years" loosely, and I was thinking more about my country (Brazil). Here the first college was founded in 1827 (a law school) and was completely top-elite focused; basically a politician/ruling class training school. History is a lot of planets, populated by diverse aliens.
- domfletcher 11y agoI think the point OP is making is that the people who went to University 100-200 years ago didn't have to worry about employability because they were usually from wealthy families. What has happened in the intervening time is that higher education has extended down the income scale and as such more students need jobs at the end of their degrees.
- Thriptic 11y agoThe costs have also dramatically risen, so people view their education as an investment as opposed to an interest.
- jacquesm 11y agoFolks definitely have it much easier today than folks 100 to 200 years ago, especially when it comes to health and luxury, in the developed world at least. Finance has something of a stranglehold on society, that is why there isn't more arts and civics. House prices, cost of living these all translate into either work really hard to support yourself and your family (this goes for both males and females, it's rare to see a family have kids where only one parent goes out on a daily basis for a paycheck) or end up on the fringes of society (either living on hand-outs or some way of living hand-to-mouth for as long as you're not generating income). Now personally I don't mind the hard work, but with all the productivity gains and the number of people that are simply rich you'd expect that the spoils would be more evenly distributed but that very much depends on which part of the planet you are looking at and which demographic for a specific location. Arts and civics are to some extent a huge luxury, in times long gone by the artists would have patrons, wealthy people directly supporting one or more of their favorite artists by commissioning works. Today such artists still exist but the 'big money' in the arts is in the media (and it has a much shorter shelf life than say a work by Michelangelo, otoh we all agree on that because his works made it to our time and are considered masterpieces, chances are there was plenty of mediocre work done in his time too). I highly doubt the majority of the population is interested in answering questions such as 'what makes us human', and I think that one of the bigger problems with blue collar jobs disappearing (and possibly being replaced by basic income or other forms of hand-outs) is that there is satisfaction in work, the knowledge that you don't depend on others for your bread and butter and the idea that you're a productive member of society. For me at least there is great value in that and I feel better because of it, much better than if I would receive some kind of stipend just because I exist. Probably that's because of how I was raised and maybe a generation that was not raised with that particular work ethic would have a smaller problem (or none at all) with receiving funds even though nothing of value was produced. Workhouses and prisons are now country wide, we call them 'the third world', and if and when we reach income parity I suspect production will shift back to 'local' because of reduced shipping costs.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoNot buying the argument that we have it harder now - that we have to 'work really hard' for a living. There may be local variations in the last couple of decades. But go back 200 years and boy howdy they had it hard. Infant mortality; general health and diet; violent death and vulnerability to weather and economic climate. They were orders of magnitude a bigger issue in the average life. And students aren't interested in 'what makes us human'? I know quite a few students, and its a very large part of their makeup. They are young and relatively ignorant and college can be a wonderland of discovery. Or it can be training, a boring trudge from High School to a job.
- sevensor 11y agoThose idle scions of wealth still exist. It's done neither them nor the rest of us any favors to pretend that a liberal education is the best thing for everyone. The liberal education has been eviscerated to make it approachable for the masses. Now we're failing both the rich kids whose moral growth it was supposed to encourage and everybody else --- it's far too easy to coast through university-level humanities classes without learning how to read, write, or think.
- mc32 11y agoReading first sources is great. A lot can get lost in translation, so you're right, in some aspects liberal arts have lost rigor by not analyzing the original Greek Latin or Sanskrit texts. Many are happy to simply quote levinas, Foucault, deleuze or badiou, etc.
- eropple 11y agoIt's not about the liberal arts degrees, it's about the liberal education. I have a CS degree. I also have a liberal education. I was exposed to a wide range of people, viewpoints, and concepts in the process. It has been more valuable to me than most of my actual CS education, and is as applicable as anything else in both daily life and in my job. And the self-styled "auto-didacts" who I know do not show the sort of breadth that my college education thrust upon me and for which I am better off.
- lfowles 11y agoExactly. The courses I keep returning to in my mind are the ones outside the scope of my degree. Everything else melded into some form of career preparation. On a side note, I think many fail to recognize what "liberal education" means. I've seen the concept attacked by some right/libertarian friends merely for having the word "liberal" in it!
- eropple 11y agoFor sure. Like, my microeconomics classes have been invaluable in being a good planner and manager. The friends I work with (most of whom I've known for a long time, and some of whom in college I got to take econ seriously) use that vocabulary, and those principles, every single day as software developers and product people. Sociology and political science--the studies of groups and the distribution of power and resources within them--are more valuable than my databases class ever was. Computers are easy. People are hard. A liberal education helps recognize and come to grips with this.