2 ms·
I'd be really surprised if that approach worked well for normal aircraft. Small propellors are less efficient than large ones, and you're putting virtually the
by mikeash 11y ago
I'd be really surprised if that approach worked well for normal aircraft. Small propellors are less efficient than large ones, and you're putting virtually the entire wing in prop wash, which is going to screw up the airflow. I'm sure the approach works, but I don't see it working well compared to the more typical solutions with one or two engines on small aircraft.
I also don't see how this design makes VTOL easy. That design involves rotating the entire wing by 90 degrees to transition between horizontal and vertical flight. That's a huge complication over conventional aircraft where the wing structure is fixed. I can see how it might be a better approach if you already need VTOL, but if you're content with using a runway then using this design is going to massively complicate everything.
Finally, none of this appears to address the question of catastrophic failures versus benign ones. This design will greatly improve safety in the case where a motor just stops producing power. But for failure modes where, say, the motor catches fire or the prop comes apart, you've greatly increased the chances of a major problem.
- trhway 11y ago> Small propellors are less efficient than large ones, not really - they are about of the same efficiency for the same power load. > and you're putting virtually the entire wing in prop wash, which is going to screw up the airflow. this is the idea here. Increased airflow for the wing means increased lift. Of course you need to make sure that it is good quality airflow. If you notice - the NASA uses kind of fans instead of props. >I also don't see how this design makes VTOL easy. That design involves rotating the entire wing by 90 degrees to transition between horizontal and vertical flight. rotating wing is just this NASA design and it isn't the best one. VTOL is a big theme. I'd just mention that [technically] successful VTOLs have been - CL-84, XV-15/V-22, X-22, XV-5 - and looking at them one can get an idea how a good number (4 minimum, 8 better) of well controlled prop+engine units would make for a good VTOL. >But for failure modes where, say, the motor catches fire or the prop comes apart, you've greatly increased the chances of a major problem. electric motor isn't an issue. A main generator unit - having at least 2 of them - can be easily immediately shutdown and flooded with fire-suppressor gas. Smaller props present less a danger and if in ducts that would be even less dangerous.