4 ms·
>not intended as an attack Don't worry. I knew I'd catch grief. I know HN is strong on CLI love and thin on actual accounting experience. ;) >This is a true d
by Havoc 11y ago
>not intended as an attack
Don't worry. I knew I'd catch grief. I know HN is strong on CLI love and thin on actual accounting experience. ;)
>This is a true double-entry accounting system that happens to have a CLI.
Double entry has existed in paper format since before the dawn of time. Its not particularly revolutionary (CLI or not) in fact its bare minimum for sanity. Hence my comment that this is barely a step above Excel.
>actual curiosity about what a professional SME accounting package
Copy paste from other questions:
Is it widely used? Can you get staff with a couple years experience using ledger? Will accounting staff be productive using the interface? Does it cope well with multiple simultaneous users? Is it compatible with other software? Can you get local support? Can you export/import to other packages? Are the fringe case glitches known?
All these things matter with finance software, even for fairly small operations.
>as far as open-source accounting packages go
To be honest I wouldn't go for an open source one (as much as I like FOSS etc). Accounting software is really an area where you want to follow the herd (unlike usual HN mindset). Straying from the herd has terrible risk/reward. e.g. Yes you might save $100 on the software by using FOSS, but when the auditors show they take twice as long to deal with the unfamiliar stuff and charge you an extra $2000. Or worse they find a glitch that is new. In the IT world you file a ticket for that. In the accounting world you end up with a massive bill to get outside help to salvage the accounting records. Followed by another massive bill from the auditors attempting to audit said salvaged records. But yeah...you totally saved that $100 on the initial purchase. (Exaggeration obviously, but you get my point).
>it can effectively be used in place of an SME accounting package.
I'd not attempt it, as per above. Seen way to many horror shows.
- zrail 11y agoMy philosophy on this is, if/when my business grows to the point where I can't handle the bookkeeping anymore, I'll switch to something that I can hire out. And if that means paying someone to hand-jam in a year of transactions from my ledger files, so be it, but likely I'll write some translation software to make it happen. Until that point, I'll keep doing my books myself with ledger :)
- mikekchar 11y agoOne small caveat as someone in the same boat. If you have to declare capital gains on transactions from multiple currencies, the "currency account" system that ledger uses is a bit strange for some accountants. I do my own book keeping, but I have an accountant who deals with the government ;-) He calculates capital gains in a way that I would say is arguably wrong. However, I trust that his way will be accepted by the government, which is all that matters ;-)
- inopinatus 11y agoI have actual accounting experience so by your first point I am qualified to comment. I doubt CLI snobbery is a factor; that would be infantile. I suspect others downvoted you for taking the default position that the status quo is the best prospect - hardly a hacker's point of view and certainly not in keeping with the startup community. Had Rod Drury agreed with you, he might never have started Xero. My finding is that once one is trained in the basics of double-entry book-keeping, accounting standards, finance and taxation, then any package that keeps appropriate records and generates the right reports will do. To which end, Ledger seems a perfectly reasonable choice for a micro business or self-bootstrapped lean startup. Comparing it to an ERP platform is a non sequitur. A better discussion might be around the transition triggers. Moreover, Ledger could serve as the accounting module of a larger system that benefits from double-entry book-keeping, such as a trading platform or two-sided network business. I say that with confidence because I'm building one. By the way, a little historical research: double-entry was invented in the fifteenth century; hardly the dawn of time.
- Havoc 11y ago>I suspect others downvoted you for taking the default position that the status quo is the best prospect In my line of work I get to see a variety of approaches to accounting. This is not a game where the bleeding edge wins. In fact those do a lot of bleeding and zero winning. >Comparing it to an ERP platform is a non sequitur. Oh come one dude. I specifically said people should get a proper ERP if its need in my opening post. At no point did I compare this to an ERP. So please...chill with the latin, especially the false kind. As for your other points. You list the "trading platform" as an example of this being successful. Sure. You could use this to effectively run a kitchen pantry too. Its still no good as a commercially accounting package for day to day use though.
- aidenn0 11y ago> Is it widely used? Can you get staff with a couple years experience using ledger? Will accounting staff be productive using the interface? Does it cope well with multiple simultaneous users? Is it compatible with other software? Can you get local support? Can you export/import to other packages? Are the fringe case glitches known? I know that Accountants are conservative, but there will never be any new accounting software if all accounting software used needs to meet these requirements. Lastly, I think a lot of people thought "one man show" meant a business with only one employee, while it is clear after your response that you meant one book-keeper. Ledger will not be used at any company with "Accounting staff" (plural). The largest organization I'm aware of that uses it is a free software non-profit that has moral reasons for avoiding proprietary software.