3 ms·
This is what I've been saying for a while. The US government is all kinds of screwed up, but at the end of the day it's still reasonably representative. If We T
by mikeash 11y ago
This is what I've been saying for a while. The US government is all kinds of screwed up, but at the end of the day it's still reasonably representative. If We The People decided tomorrow that we wanted to put a stop to all of this surveillance, then it would stop. The screwed-upness does add some amount of bias, so if it was, say, 51% against and 49% in favor, it might well keep going. But if it was more like 75/25 against, it would stop pretty much immediately.
It's our choice. If you don't feel that "our choice" matches your own wishes (it certainly doesn't match mine) then that's just because you're in the minority, or at best you're in a majority with very slim margins.
- joesmo 11y agoTell that to the 2000 presidential election...
- nickff 11y agoCan everyone please stop bringing this up? The 2000 Presidential Election was the inevitable consequence of the electoral system; there is almost no way to recount the votes and get a different result.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_election_recount#Post-election_studies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_election_recount#Post-...
- dragonwriter 11y ago> there is almost no way to recount the votes and get a different result. How can you say that when the source you cite specifically points to a study that shows Gore winning by any criteria in a statewide recount in Florida; e.g., that its quite likely that not only did Gore have more votes cast for him than Bush, but also more votes in States that combined had a majority of electoral votes.
- nickff 11y agoIf you read the heading on the table you refer to, you would have seen that its title is "Candidate outcomes based on potential non-absentee recounts in Florida presidential election 2000". Absentee ballots do matter, and the court was never even asked to do a statewide recount (to the best of my knowledge). In addition to that, Gore would not have won on an full recount based on the conventional standards for a vote (two corners of the chad punched), as is made clear later in the article, by papers like the New York Times.
- joesmo 11y agoWhether Gore or Bush actually won the election is inconsequential at this point, save for the lasting damage. Almost 100% of the American people want fair elections which means that all votes are counted. If the American people can't even get fair elections, something almost 100% of them undoubtedly want, then they certainly can't get anything else passed. So no, we won't stop bringing this up as it's a very real issue that we're still suffering the consequences of and a great counterexample to the post I replied to.
- nickff 11y agoAll votes were counted. What Gore wanted was a recount of certain areas, but without uniform standards, it clearly viotlated Equal Protections, as well as not being possible to complete before the deadline. To be clear, that portion of the Supreme Court opinion was unanimous; the remedy was where the split was.
- joesmo 11y agoCounted, just incorrectly. Fine for US elections.
- mikeash 11y agoThe difference in the popular vote in the 2000 election was about 500,000, out of over 100 million votes cast, or about 0.5%. Did you see the part where I said, "The screwed-upness does add some amount of bias, so if it was, say, 51% against and 49% in favor, it might well keep going"? Or did you not even bother to read my comment, and just see an opportunity for a cheap shot?
- cgriswald 11y agoAs a voter, I am already in a minority. The public is largely apathetic. The reasons for this are many, but some are: First, that the voter is largely disenfranchised. He is presented with two options and repeatedly told that a vote for any other option is throwing his vote away. Because other voters largely heed this advice the evidence shows that it is correct, even though in other voting systems that would definitely not be the case. Second, even where the voter succeeds in getting his candidate elected, that candidate seldom fulfills the promises made. Or if those promises are fulfilled it is because they are largely unimportant in the grand scheme of things or are comprimised into oblivion. Meanwhile technical and often highly obfuscated decisions and laws are made behind the scenes and would have been made regardless of which of the two candidates was elected for office. Third, many extremely important decisions are made by fiat. That the decision-making body is ultimately elected is largely meaningless. The elected are beholden to special interests (often corporate) and repay those interests by appointing particular people to those decision-making bodies. The voter is often many-times-removed from some of the most important decisions being made and there are little to no consequences for going against the wishes of the voter in those cases. Fourth, an individual vote is statistically insignificant. The value I have gotten from individually voting is far outweighed by even the price of gasoline I've spent getting to a polling location. This is even more true if you tend to be a minority voter. So even if, by vote, it is 75/25 against (which will be fought against by both parties and the media), it won't stop immediately, because the population is largely apathetic as they've been told to be by a system that works against them.
- greggman 11y agoThe problem for me is candidates have multiple positions on multiple topics. So I can pick candidate X that agrees with me on A and B but not C. Or I can pick candidate Y that agrees with me in B and C but not A. So I have to pick, either which is less important to me A or C, or I have to pick by some other criteria and just accept that no candidate is going to fully represent me. I don't know what a solution would be.
- mikekchar 11y agoI think this is largely a meaningless claim. It is true that if you had some kind of consensus, you could elect anyone to office and enact any change of policy. However, your ability to create that consensus is hampered by the electoral system. How do you get consensus from the electorate? You need to advertise and get media coverage. But the media is owned and operated by powerful people with a stake in the status quo. Especially in the US every issue is instantly polarized by the media. That way they can maintain a 2 party system, where nobody else has a chance to get a foot in. It's "Us vs. Them" all the way down. This means that in order to get traction, you need to convince one of the 2 parties to back your idea. Otherwise the media is just going to portray you as some kind of tin foil hat wearing moron. Even if you have popular support for your ideas, for example if you won a presidential campaign by saying, "Yes we can!" -- words that echoed throughout the world and won you a nobel peace prize... You really can't [1]. This link is from yesterday. I'm not American. I'm not Republican or Democrat. I don't have a say in this or any other issue. But I think you are being very naive if you think that either of the parties will sit back and allow anyone to gather enough support to do what you suggest. And even if you were able to do so, by some miracle, the odds would be seriously stacked against you. It is true that the electorate chooses. It is also true that the people in power decide what the electorate will choose. [1] http://edition.cnn.com/2015/11/04/politics/guantanamo-bay-executive-action/index.html http://edition.cnn.com/2015/11/04/politics/guantanamo-bay-ex...
- mikeash 11y agoI agree with most of what you're saying, but I disagree that this makes my claim "meaningless." In discussions in the tech community, I almost always see overreaching surveillance portrayed as the government going rogue and acting against the will of the people. The problem is that they don't listen, and the solution is to force them to actually do what the people want them to do. This is vastly different from a situation where the people actually do want the government to do this stuff. That's true even if that desire is manipulated. The situation informs the solution. The opinions of the American public are often manipulated and artificial. Fighting that is worthy and useful. But if you skip over all that and simply try to get the government to stop doing its own thing and start listening to what people want, you'll accomplish nothing.
- natch 11y agoSadly, you are wholeheartedly buying into the FBI's point without at all seeing the huge gaping flaw in it. Tyranny of the majority is the problem, not "our" choice. The protection against tyranny of the majority is not, as you seem to think, getting the majority to change "our choice." The protection against tyranny of the majority is basic respect, among those in power in institutions like the FBI, for rights like those in the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.
- mikeash 11y agoI had this opinion long before, so I'm not "buying into" what they're saying, unless you're just using that phrase as a weird way of saying that we happen to agree. Tyranny of the majority is indeed a major problem here, but it's not how I see it discussed. The tech community seems to mostly believe that government surveillance is a case of the government acting against the wishes of the people. As far as I can tell, this is because the tech community believes that their opinions are representative, but they aren't really. The distinction is important, because it informs the solution. If you believe that most people don't want surveillance and you focus your efforts on getting the government to do what the people want, then you'll accomplish nothing if it turns out that most people want it. If the problem is a tyranny of the majority, then your approach will be different.