3 ms·
>Since you mentioned airplanes, making sure redundancy reduces rather than increasing risk is a big issue. For example, single-engine airplanes are prone to cra
by trhway 11y ago
>Since you mentioned airplanes, making sure redundancy reduces rather than increasing risk is a big issue. For example, single-engine airplanes are prone to crashes due to engine failure. The solution is to add a second engine and you're much safer, right?
that is the same thinking that has been in the aviation for the last 100 years. Why 2? Put 8 electrical ones driven from 2 generators from 2 ICE/turbines. In such approach no component have to be of an "air-worthy" level of reliability (and associated cost/price), just a regular "consumer auto" reliability level would easily do.
>But if it fails by, say, dumping all your blood into your chest cavity, then adding redundant hearts increases your chance of death, rather than decreasing it.
that is a good point. I'd say that abnormal flow can be detected, and with 2 hearts the option of shutting down the one where abnormal flow is detected is really a feasible option, while it is definitely not in the case of just one heart.
- mikeash 11y agoNow you have even more things that can go wrong. You can't just pile on extra equipment, declare it to achieve reliability through redundancy, and have it be so. Even if you do achieve reliability, what does it cost? Your solution would probably be unbelievably expensive and inefficient, since you've added a huge amount of weight and drag. The thinking from the last 100 years of aviation has resulted in by far the safest means of transportation ever devised, with a fatality rate so low that it can no longer be reliably measured. Calling something "the same thinking" as that is high praise! If you think you have a better way to do it, it's certainly possible, but you have an extremely high bar to clear.
- trhway 11y ago>Even if you do achieve reliability, what does it cost? Your solution would probably be unbelievably expensive and inefficient, since you've added a huge amount of weight and drag. well, i did these calculations some years ago when i was looking at the cost of heavy low powered, ages in technology behind, engines like Lycoming. Cost of "horizontally scaled" solution is lower. Efficiency and reliability is higher. Weight for equivalent power may be a little bit larger, yet it is well balanced by the efficiency, ie. the lesser fuel consumption. >The thinking from the last 100 years of aviation has resulted in by far the safest means of transportation ever devised at the high level - definitely. But we aren't talking reliability of one huge heart for 200 patients - the cost here would allow to engineer 10 nines reliability. We're talking small individual devices. To compare - small aviation (included in the "General Aviation" below) is completely different - the GA is ~10 times more dangerous than driving : http://www.meretrix.com/~harry/flying/notes/safetyvsdriving.html http://www.meretrix.com/~harry/flying/notes/safetyvsdriving.... " For GA, there were 11.2 fatal accidents and 19.7 fatalities per million hours of flying. For motor vehicles, there were 1.32 fatal accidents and 1.47 fatalities per 100M miles. " and that after much more pilot training, after much more technical attention to the hardware and no 70+ year old "grannies" pilots :) . The technological state of small aviation, i.e. lack of technological progress for the last half a century at least, is bordering a shame of our civilization
- mikeash 11y agoGA is a totally different world, to be sure. I don't see that it's shameful, though. It's just not that important overall, so there's not much money in it. Medevac helicopters and things like that are pretty nice, but stuff like small Cessnas have few practical uses. And I say this as a hobby pilot who flies things with absolutely zero practical use. I'm curious about your solution. How do you fit 8 electric motors to a GA aircraft? Where do they all go? Do they share props, or do they each have their own?
- trhway 11y agoin general each motor have their own prop. The 2 motors per prop is just an obvious way to increase redundancy in any other schema, and it works nice in the sense that electric motors are very easily share the same shaft. The most obvious way to place more props is the one which even NASA recently recognized benefits of (like increased lift) - http://www.nasa.gov/centers/armstrong/Features/leaptech.html http://www.nasa.gov/centers/armstrong/Features/leaptech.html . Yet that is just a start. Many props driven by smaller electric engines open a lot of other design possibilities - like easy tilting which easily brings us to VTOL - http://nextbigfuture.com/2014/08/nasa-research-shows-hybrid-electric.html http://nextbigfuture.com/2014/08/nasa-research-shows-hybrid-.... Again NASA is very simplistic and primitive in their approach. The multi-wing designs along the Scaled Composites' ones may be more suitable here especially if cross-bred with typical octo-copter. The smaller props also open the possibility of ducts where is a bigger duct for one big prop is subject to very high loads and as result is very heavy and expensive and pretty much non-starter as a result. Ducting improves trust at low speed and decrease noise - both are big advantages for smaller planes.
- mikeash 11y agoI'd be really surprised if that approach worked well for normal aircraft. Small propellors are less efficient than large ones, and you're putting virtually the entire wing in prop wash, which is going to screw up the airflow. I'm sure the approach works, but I don't see it working well compared to the more typical solutions with one or two engines on small aircraft. I also don't see how this design makes VTOL easy. That design involves rotating the entire wing by 90 degrees to transition between horizontal and vertical flight. That's a huge complication over conventional aircraft where the wing structure is fixed. I can see how it might be a better approach if you already need VTOL, but if you're content with using a runway then using this design is going to massively complicate everything. Finally, none of this appears to address the question of catastrophic failures versus benign ones. This design will greatly improve safety in the case where a motor just stops producing power. But for failure modes where, say, the motor catches fire or the prop comes apart, you've greatly increased the chances of a major problem.