4 ms·
Excerpts: "This doesn’t only take from your body, it takes from your mind, spirit, and soul," De La Cruz says. And: Perhaps the biggest moral conundrum, thou
by Mz 11y ago
Excerpts:
"This doesn’t only take from your body, it takes from your mind, spirit, and soul," De La Cruz says.
And:
Perhaps the biggest moral conundrum, though, has nothing to do with living with a mechanical heart, but dying with one. Unlike biological hearts, artificial ones can pump blood throughout the body and oxygen to the brain when the rest of the body breaks down. Death is dragged out — and may require the machine be shut off. "I’ve had patients where the liver and kidney failed, the skin turned yellow and died, and the only thing working normally was the brain," Arabia says.
I find stuff like this incredibly disturbing. I always find myself wondering why doctors don't spend more time on helping people keep their own organs functioning instead of on this kind of stuff. I find this very scary. "Resistance is futile. You will be assimilated."...because we are only going to offer you something Frankensteinian like this and not offer better options for healing the tissues you were born with.
I have a condition that accounts for a high percentage of lung transplants. So this stuff hits rather close to home for me.
- oldmanjay 11y ago> I always find myself wondering why doctors don't spend more time on helping people keep their own organs functioning instead of on this kind of stuff They almost certainly do. It's a pure anecdote, of course, but I've had doctors in many states throughout the US and to a one, they communicate information intended to help me maintain better health as a preventative measure. If you mean that doctors should spend effort on better treatments for failing organs, there are a number of projects working in those directions right now. Basically, I'm not sure what is disturbing you.
- Mz 11y agoBasically, I'm not sure what is disturbing you. I hesitated to reply to you at all. You kind of waved off my concerns and didn't really ask a question. So I am concerned that replying is a mistake. But I seem to be damned no matter what I do when it comes to topics like this. I mean, why did you reply? The manner in which you replied seems pretty dismissive, given that I closed with a statement that I have a condition where transplants are common. But assuming you answered in good faith and just honestly don't see how bad your reply could sound to me, here is what disturbs me: If you have certain conditions, doctors don't really try to help you maintain better health. They chalk up bad outcomes to your official diagnosis and kind of wash their hands of trying harder. Then heroic interventions, like transplants, get all kinds of glowing press. When you get listed for transplant, you basically sit around waiting for someone relatively young and healthy to die tragically in an accident so you can have a second shot at life. I can't imagine the toll that takes on your psyche. That isn't a criticism of patients who accept the only option they are really being offered. But I think we can do better than that, and real quality of life is being given short shrift as medical professionals zealously pursue the "Ooh, shiny!" options that will get them impressive headlines. I also understand the pressures on them which lead to that, but it is the patients who suffer horribly because of it. It just makes me think something is very, very broken. And no one cares to even discuss that, much less try to fix it.
- oldmanjay 11y agoI understand that my tone seemed dismissive, and I apologize. I was dashing off the comment and didn't give it much consideration after writing it, and I probably would have rewritten the last sentence. In any case, you answered my (assumed) question, so thank you!
- mikeash 11y agoWhy not work on both preserving existing organs and replacing them when they can't be kept going? Not everything can be fixed. A ton of medical research is put into preserving the function of the original organs, but people will still sometimes have them fail. When that happens, isn't it good that an artificial replacement is an option, rather than it just being a guaranteed death?
- Mz 11y agoYou are talking to someone who used to have a hole in one lung, with a condition where doctors wait for infection to eat your lungs up and then list you for transplant. At one time, I was on 8 or 9 presciption drugs and I spent 3.5 years in constant, excruciating, please-kill-me-now pain. I reached a point where the only thing I wanted was to hurt less and doctors were not offering me that. My pulmonologist told me "People like you don't get well. Symptom management is the name of the game." So I began pursuing alternative treatments because doctors had no hope to give me. I did whatever reduced my pain, during a time when I was routinely hallucinating conversations with The Grim Reaper. And when I hallucinated that he peered down into my face, saw something he had not seen before and turned his black steed to leave, I ran screaming after him "Take me with you!" I knew the death watch was over and I would live. I also knew I faced a long, hard, torturous recovery. It was a journey I had no desire to make. I think there are things worse than death. And I also very much fear two things: 1) That every minute put into researching heroics like artificial hearts is a minute taken away from researching something more humane and 2) the extremely high value we place on just making sure no one dies, and quality of life be damned, gives patients like me a very grim future, even if we get the best available care and do everything "right" (according to our doctors). That answer is not intended as dramatics or as anything screechy. It is just honest commentary on my actual experiences that my views grow out of. Your question is a very reasonable one. I think my concerns are equally reasonable. I am aware few people will side with me on this. (Perhaps none, in fact.)
- Gibbon1 11y agoI have a friend that worked as a pediatric nurse in a cardiac ward. One of the reasons she quit was the grim feeling that she was often just enabling suffering. One of her patients was an infant they should have just let die. But they cut him open and fixed things and he lived another 6 weeks in torment and it was her job to make it last. My grandmother when she was dying mentioned feeling annoyed that government would spend a few hundred a day on worthless treatments for old old lady on deaths door when kids were going hungry.
- kefka 11y agoI get what you're saying. My wife is an in home hospice care worker. She's seen people who have gone crazy from Alzheimers. They have these rare lucid moments where they understand what they're trapped in, and have begged her to kill them. She's also worked with people who have Parkinsons, where their mental faculties are fine, yet their bodily control dissolves. They die by losing the ability to send the muscular commands to breathe. Suffocation. So yes, when you talk about making durable organs to substitute failing ones, it sounds like a great idea. Until you hit end of life. At least ones where stuff fails isn't as bad, with all-mechanicals. The diseases that hit the brain and destroy cogent thought are the absolute worst. At least a family can potentially go to Oregon for physician assisted suicide. Another solution to this is a kill switch: you hold the key to the destruction/End of Life of the device, killing you in the process. That would allow you to use these devices, and when you decide, to have a good death.
- Mz 11y agoThank you.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> I always find myself wondering why doctors don't spend more time on helping people keep their own organs functioning instead of on this kind of stuff. AFAIK, most of medical research is about "helping people keep their own organs functioning", by improving therapies, supportive treatments, and surgical interventions. (Of course, artificial replacements for one organ can also be a supportive treatment for keeping other original organs functional.) > ...because we are only going to offer you something Frankensteinian like this and not offer better options for healing the tissues you were born with. Generally, artificial replacements aren't offered where there are good, or even remotely viable, options for healing the tissues you were born with.