10 ms·
This is exactly the same as saying that the reason women had little power in America before 1920 was because they couldn't vote. Which is true, but completely o
by peterwwillis 11y ago
This is exactly the same as saying that the reason women had little power in America before 1920 was because they couldn't vote. Which is true, but completely overlooks why women didn't have the right to vote.
Women didn't have power because they were oppressed by men for centuries. Black people don't have "as good an education" because they've been systematically abandoned by the most powerful parts of society for centuries.
You could spend 100 million on a program just in my city alone to try to give disadvantaged kids tech lessons. You know what would happen?
Nothing, because you haven't addressed the fact that they have to sell dope, hustle or work multiple jobs just to put food on their family's table; that they're watching their baby sibling while mom and dad go out to score junk; that their friends need them to join the local gang to protect their neighborhood; that they don't have access to transportation to get to the classes; that the rest of the city needs money and will steal from the education fund as it always does, because why try to teach the kids when they're not going to learn anyway; and of course, because their parents gave up on their future a long time ago and give zero shit about trying to help them make something of themselves.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- x3n0ph3n3 11y agoSo the fix is to lower hiring standards? What exactly are you promoting as a fix here?
- cmsj 11y ago"Lower hiring standards" is a myopic fallacy. You don't hire Jeff the amazing coder who likes to punch people in the face. Discounting the value of culture is a huge mistake. Humans work best when they are not treated as replaceable units of quantified productivity. Diverse cultures can attack problems with a broader perspective than homogenous cultures.
- sokoloff 11y agoIt's still not clear what you would have a hiring manager do today. I usually have several positions open at any given time; I don't even recall the last black applicant we've seen. I have talented co-workers of many different races (specifically including black), but even without visiting our office, you could guess the percentage breakdown and you wouldn't be far off. I can't hire applicants that don't exist and I can't hire applicants that aren't qualified.
- meric 11y agoWe hired some remote engineers from South Africa through stack overflow. Now we have a permanent office in Cape Town. Give that a go maybe. A lot more bang for the buck comparatively than hiring remote engineers from the U.S., and the programmers there (shouldn't even be surprise) are as good as from any country including the U.S.
- nzoschke 11y agoAwesome. I can think of a ton of reasons a hiring manager would say "I can't do that." Not about race, but about remote and time zones. So kudos to you for trying something that opened you up to far more candidates, finding them, making them successful, and sharing this example for others to learn from.
- nzoschke 11y agoYou can shift your notions of "qualified". You can hire junior engineers and mentor and train them to be successful. Then you can proactively advertise your positions to programs and organizations that have more minority participation. Of course this takes more work for you, the hiring manager, in sourcing and on boarding. But there should be a burden on every hiring manager to correct the systemic diversity problems. A success will be extremely impactful for the individuals you hire and for the overall health of the team.
- sokoloff 11y ago
- peterwwillis 11y agoA "fix"? This isn't a compile-time error. This is the total disenfranchisement of entire classes or groups of people. There is no patch. The "fix" involves lots of difficult work. First, we have to get people like you to understand what the problem is, which apparently is difficult to do. Then, we have to build empathy for the problems facing black people so you want to actually help them. Then we have to invest in developing social and economic equality within disadvantaged communities. And hiring more diversely will not lower hiring standards. Please try to understand that.
- x3n0ph3n3 11y agoI understand the problem to be way beyond hiring in tech, so I'm trying to understand why lack of diversity in tech is being blamed on the tech community.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoBecause, when we see a flower growing in the desolation, we should try not to step on it.
- peterwwillis 11y agoBecause the tech industry is dragging its feet. The explanation tech companies have for not having a more diverse workforce is that the applicants are just not out there to hire. Of course, any good tech worker could take an additional five minutes to think about the problem and discover that there are ways to create the applicants, by improving the communities that will grow the applicants. But that takes time, and money, it's hands-on and it's not easy. And overseas workers are cheap.