4 ms·
Which sector of the economy do you work in? Apply your statement to that and see if you still agree.
by protomyth 11y ago
Which sector of the economy do you work in? Apply your statement to that and see if you still agree.
- mschuster91 11y agoIT, and well, the governments up to now have done a relatively well job in the sector by providing a framework where small-scale startups can compete on fair terms with big monopolies (just look how big Cloudflare grew). Then again, the tide seems to turn a bit, I'm not exactly sure.
- protomyth 11y agoCalling BNSF a monopoly would be pretty hard. The shipping options are multiple. Google is closer to a monopoly than BNSF is ever likely to be.
- mschuster91 11y agoI'm not an American, but aren't the railways in the US split up in dozens of small-ish companies (forming local monopolies), each with own regulations etc.?
- protomyth 11y agoEach company owns tracks which sometimes gets used by other companies. Cars are handed off and often owned by non-railroads. Its a complex system but each company acts pretty much the same way so for example "bills of lading" act the same. They don't have their own regulations. Calling them monopolies if far from the truth, and they do an efficient job of hauling cargo like they were designed to do. People are not meant to be hauled by the modern US railroad. They made different decisions in Europe. To give a technology analogy: Stop trying to use COBOL to write Fortran programs.
- jcranmer 11y agoIn the US and Canada, there are 7 major railroads: BNSF, Union Pacific, CSX, Norfolk Southern, Canadian National, Canadian Pacific, and Kansas City Southern (there's also Via Rail and Amtrak, the passenger trains of Canada and the US, but they are generally excluded). In effect, there are basically three separate market duopolies: in the west, you have a choice between UP and BNSF; in the east, NS and CSX; and in the north, CN and CP. On top of this, there's a few hundred smaller railroads that are much more local in scope.
- pstuart 11y agoIt's a monopoly on transport via rail. The other alternative is via truck on those, you know, nationalized roadways.
- protomyth 11y agoI would love to know how BNSF constitutes a monopoly in the US?
- mulmen 11y agoFor a route from city A to city B that can be served by BNSF do consumers have a choice of a second railroad? If the answer to that is mostly no doesn't BNSF have some form of monopoly on rail transport?
- protomyth 11y agoDepends on how big the city is, but you have choice - here is a map of MN for example http://www.dot.state.mn.us/ofrw/maps/MNRailMap.pdf http://www.dot.state.mn.us/ofrw/maps/MNRailMap.pdf [edit: also remember track sharing and common transport agreements]
- mulmen 11y agoThanks for the map. I see that many of these routes are only served by one railroad. For example, how does BNSF not have a monopoly on the route from Moorhead to Brainerd? How common are track sharing and common transport agreements? AnimalMuppet did a great job answering the monopoly question elsewhere in the comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10510522 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10510522
- protomyth 11y ago"Moorhead to Brainerd" - I hire a truck (for that short of distance no one on this planet would use a railroad) or my cars go from railroad to railroad. Yes, for little stretches monopolies exist but no railroad company is an island they do route stuff across rail. Saying BNSF is a monopoly because of small patches like that is saying you have a monopoly on parking in your driveway. Heck, many non-rail companies own a lot of rail cars. Rail competes and works with truck, barge, and air. The US is blessed with a lot of competitive options for transporting goods. My only beef with BNSF is their continuing attempts to lobby for no more pipelines because of all the money they are making from oil in ND. BNSF needs to review its safety policies but the two ND Senators (one from each party) are keeping up the pressure on that front.
- ant6n 11y agoLet's privatize the system of roads - but in such a way that trucking companies are encouraged to build their own road system, and access to infrastructure is largely given only in exchange for access to other infrastructure.