6 ms·
Hmm how about nationalizing the infrastructure, mandate safety technologies and allow private companies to compete on common grounds to prevent a race to the bo
by mschuster91 11y ago
Hmm how about nationalizing the infrastructure, mandate safety technologies and allow private companies to compete on common grounds to prevent a race to the bottom?
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoYou're advocating nationalizing private companies, and claiming a boost to competition? That seems... ironic.
- mschuster91 11y agoNot the entire companies, just the part that could boost competition and innovation by nationalizing and opening it up. Aren't Amtrak trains regularly prioritized far beyond freight trains, resulting in a massive problem for passenger train service?
- 13thLetter 11y agoNot sure what you're saying here? Amtrak service is notoriously terrible and technologically backwards, which does not strike me as a good argument for having the US government nationalize an industry.
- mulmen 11y agoI don't think he advocated nationalizing the railroads, just the infrastructure.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoIf you take away the infrastructure from a railroad, there isn't much left...
- mschuster91 11y agoThere's a shitload of stuff to compete on when you don't own the railroads. Pricing (hello Deutsche Bahn, 10x more expensive than buses LOL), service (thumbs up to Austria's Westbahn here), quality of the carriages (again, thumbs up to Westbahn, displacing even the DB ICE trains), WiFi...
- mulmen 11y agoI don't see how this would be any different than trucking companies competing on public roads. There is certainly competition in that industry. Are there regions where two railroad (companies) have built competing infrastructure?
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoIt wouldn't be different than trucking companies competing on public roads. But a "trucking on rails" company would be very different from a railroad, for the same reason that a trucking company is different from a toll road. (I know, the analogy isn't perfect. Still, I would guess that 90% of a railroad's capital is tied up in track, right of way, signaling, and similar stuff, and only 10% in engines and cars. Saying "let's nationalize the infrasturcture" means nationalizing almost all of the railroad company. Hence my comment that "there's not much left". Your distinction between nationalizing all the company and nationalizing "just the infrastructure" is not much of a difference.)
- mulmen 11y agoDisclaimer: I am not an accountant. According to http://www.bnsf.com/about-bnsf/financial-information/form-10-k-filings/pdf/10k-llc-a-2014.pdf#page=18&zoom=auto,-266,539 http://www.bnsf.com/about-bnsf/financial-information/form-10... BNSF has about 85% of their revenue in the tracks and 15% in the trains so your guess isn't far off. Can you comment on competition for a given route in the current railroad model? I assume railroads control who uses their tracks so they can prevent competitors from serving those routes, is that the case and how does that not constitute some form of monopoly? Edit: Thank you for the clarification, I had no idea how much railroads had tied up in the infrastructure. It seems that much of the value of a railroad is on the ability to serve certain routes without competition which in hindsight is pretty obvious.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoPart of the reason Amtrak trains are always late is because they're getting stuck waiting for freight trains to clear a track.
- 13thLetter 11y agoThing is, freight trains are a far better use of the track than passenger trains: the system is ideal for slow-moving bulk cargo that doesn't care if it has to sit on a siding for a week, not to mention that it's a much less damaging way of moving heavy material around than trucks. Passengers, meanwhile, want to go specific places at specific times, and that just does not coexist well with freight. Better for passengers to travel by air, private car, dedicated high-speed rail, and other systems focused on the job.
- oasisbob 11y agoThis argument neglects the fact that the railroads have no problem moving high-priority Z trains just fine. If UPS can ship Amazon prime packages overnight via rail, I have a hard time buying the argument that I should be taking a flight from Portland to Vancouver because the system can't handle it.
- 13thLetter 11y ago"High priority Z trains" still take three to six days to get to their destination. Freight schedules are unpredictable, and that's fine, because freight doesn't care. Passengers do care. > I have a hard time buying the argument that I should be taking a flight from Portland to Vancouver because the system can't handle it. Do you really want to sit overnight from Portland to Vancouver on a train as opposed to flying there in an hour and twenty minutes? Most people don't.
- chrisBob 11y agoThis could come from the fact that the freight lines own much of the track that Amtrak runs on. If I owned and managed a rail line and had to chose which train got the priority: mine, or Amtrak...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- protomyth 11y agoWhich sector of the economy do you work in? Apply your statement to that and see if you still agree.
- mschuster91 11y agoIT, and well, the governments up to now have done a relatively well job in the sector by providing a framework where small-scale startups can compete on fair terms with big monopolies (just look how big Cloudflare grew). Then again, the tide seems to turn a bit, I'm not exactly sure.
- protomyth 11y agoCalling BNSF a monopoly would be pretty hard. The shipping options are multiple. Google is closer to a monopoly than BNSF is ever likely to be.
- mschuster91 11y agoI'm not an American, but aren't the railways in the US split up in dozens of small-ish companies (forming local monopolies), each with own regulations etc.?
- protomyth 11y agoEach company owns tracks which sometimes gets used by other companies. Cars are handed off and often owned by non-railroads. Its a complex system but each company acts pretty much the same way so for example "bills of lading" act the same. They don't have their own regulations. Calling them monopolies if far from the truth, and they do an efficient job of hauling cargo like they were designed to do. People are not meant to be hauled by the modern US railroad. They made different decisions in Europe. To give a technology analogy: Stop trying to use COBOL to write Fortran programs.
- jcranmer 11y agoIn the US and Canada, there are 7 major railroads: BNSF, Union Pacific, CSX, Norfolk Southern, Canadian National, Canadian Pacific, and Kansas City Southern (there's also Via Rail and Amtrak, the passenger trains of Canada and the US, but they are generally excluded). In effect, there are basically three separate market duopolies: in the west, you have a choice between UP and BNSF; in the east, NS and CSX; and in the north, CN and CP. On top of this, there's a few hundred smaller railroads that are much more local in scope.
- mulmen 11y agoSo if I understand you correctly the railroads would basically be the same as the Interstate highway system? I don't know enough about how the railroads work to comment on how feasible such an arrangement would be. Does the government currently subsidize railroad maintenance and/or construction? Edit: Is there a precedent anywhere else in the world for nationalized railways?
- mschuster91 11y agoIn Germany, it does - DB Netz, a subsidiary of Deutsche Bahn, gets huge amounts of funds for infrastructure maintenance and construction, and the competition building on said rail infrastructure slowly begins to manifest.
- AnimalMuppet 11y ago> Does the government currently subsidize railroad maintenance and/or construction? Not in the US, except to the degree that government transportation agencies use the tracks of private railroads (not the norm, but it happens) or own them (Amtrak owns the Northeast Corridor, very little anywhere else.
- jcranmer 11y agoNationalized railways are the norm rather than the exception in much of the world. Interestingly enough, the US has a much higher fraction of freight traffic move by rail than most of those with nationalized railways.
- ant6n 11y agoI think this is largely due to the greater shipping distances (rail gets cheaper relative to trucking as the distances gets greater), and maybe a bit the lack of interference from passenger rail. Btw, in Europe many networks are state owned, some are privately owned. By open-access regulation forces every track-owner to open their tracks for a fee to other operators. There's also a distinction between track-owners and track-operators, even if a single company may be both.