Its a fair point, but there is something to be said for looking at what the PRC wants. In particular, they want/need western business. If google can show the

Its a fair point, but there is something to be said for looking at what the PRC wants. In particular, they want/need western business. If google can show the Chinese government that their practices will prevent western business, then the confrontation can be useful. Its not to say that a direct confrontation is the right move, but there is a balance point between direct accusation and giving the PRC a face saving way to make a small change. The real question (in my mind) is: is google at the right balance point.