5 ms·
Before we blame Murdoch, I think it's worth remembering that NatGeo was in a bad position when it was sold off to Murdoch...that's why it was sold off in the fi
by danso 11y ago
Before we blame Murdoch, I think it's worth remembering that NatGeo was in a bad position when it was sold off to Murdoch...that's why it was sold off in the first place:
> The magazine’s domestic circulation peaked at about 12 million copies in the late 1980s; today, the publication reaches about 3.5 million subscribers in the United States and an additional 3 million subscribers abroad through non-English-language editions. Advertising has been in steady decline.
Just because the layoffs are happening as NatGeo becomes part of Murdoch's empire doesn't mean that this was a greedy, self-serving move, and not one that was a long-time due and for which Murdoch gets the recognition/blame for, likely in exchange for a purchase price he was willing to accept. Would these layoffs not happened if NatGeo hadn't managed to be sold off as it was in decline?
- celticninja 11y agowould the fact-checking department have been the first casualties if the buyer wasn't Murdoch?
- igetspam 11y agoappears to affect almost every department of the nonprofit organization, including the magazine, which the society has published since just after its founding in 1888. The reduction also will affect people who work for the National Geographic Channel, the most profitable part of the organization. Several people in the channel’s fact-checking department, for example, were terminated on Tuesday, employees said. The department that obviously didn't help you craft your question...
- celticninja 11y agoI don't understand your point. Perhaps you could make it more clear rather than hide behind sarcasm. The article uses the word 'will' indicating a future tense to the layoffs i.e. they have not yet occurred. It then goes on to mention that the fact-checking department had employees terminated on tuesday, past-tense. Thus indicating they had already been laid off and others would follow. No other department is mentioned with regard to having already been terminated. If I have misunderstood your point please clarify. Edit: so igetspam has not responded but I immediately went to - 1 which indicates to me that igetspam is using multiple accounts to down vote commenter that disagree with him. I'm. Not sure if this is against the rules but it indicates the type of person that igetspam is. The score has changed now but my point stands that igetspam is a vote manipulator.
- spikels 11y agoI'm pretty sure you are getting downvotes because your original comment was needless political snark. Now you are making baseless accusations of "vote manipulation". Please don't do this here.
- celticninja 11y agoSo political snark is synonymous with making an observation now is it. I mention vote manipulation because it was very apparent that is what igotspam had done. I care not for meaningless points but when people use multiple accounts to further their own point it is disingenuous and serves the community to highlight this sort of behaviour so others do not waste time interacting with him.
- zeveb 11y ago> So political snark is synonymous with making an observation now is it. [sic] a) you didn't make an observation, you asked a question b) it was a snarky question c) they're laying off folks from, according to the article, 'almost every department of the nonprofit organization' > I mention vote manipulation because it was very apparent that is what igotspam had done. Or, y'know, thousands of people read HN and some large number of them think that you're off-base.
- DanBC 11y agoAccusing people of vote manipulation probably violates the guidelines. If you actually think someone is manipulating the votes (eg with dual accounts) you should email the mods and let them know. They seem receptive to that kind of thing. In this case it seems unlikely that you've been downvoted by one person with two accounts. Downvotes are sometimes accidental; and incorrect or unfair downvotes are often corrected. But accusing people of bad faith downvotes is a sure way to attract more downvotes.
- arbitrage 11y agoHN is not reddit. People downvote when you write useless comments. Get over it.
- boie0025 11y agoSeeing that the fact-checking department was called out specifically gave me a good hearty laugh.
- digdigdag 11y agoIt became a greedy, self-serving move the moment they decided it would be a good idea to associate the good name of National Geographic with Murdoch et al.
- a3n 11y ago> Before we blame Murdoch, I think it's worth remembering that NatGeo was in a bad position when it was sold off to Murdoch...that's why it was sold off in the first place Fair point. But I wonder why it was bought.
- Shivetya 11y agoeither for nostalgic purposes or simply because they determined the name still has value and with some corrections could again be valuable?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- acveilleux 11y agoThe TV channel.
- protomyth 11y agoand the accumulated library of pictures, video, etc.
- mattzito 11y agoIt's a largely unknowable question, since it's just in the eye of the beholder. It could be purely a "let's wring whatever value we can get out of the brand until it's a dried-up husk and throw it aside". Or it could be a, "Look, this isn't a very well-run business, there's a lot of redundancy, and a lot of investment in prestige initiatives that don't bring in a lot of revenue, so let's trim things down and focus on higher-margin operations, and then see how we can leverage the brand across the rest of the organization". I mean, both of my scenarios are effectively very similar, one just assumes malice, the other good corporate stewardship. It's hard to know.
- mason240 11y agoHopefully it is because they identified all things t2015_08_25 did in the top post, and they see it a currently under preforming and make a killing by implementing those changes.
- jnevill 11y agoNatGeo tried to spin the sale to Murdoch by saying that Murdoch's cash would bring stability to the troubled magazine. It looks like cash is being taken, not given. This is a strange form of stability...
- forgetsusername 11y ago>"This is a strange form of stability..." How so? Maybe it's "stability" in the sense that NatGeo will continue to be a going concern for the foreseeable future? What sense would it make to buy a struggling business and make no changes?
- alwaysAttending 11y agoseems unsustainable to hope for better numbers. 3 million subscribers is a lot. The New Yorker is profitable at 1 million. Sure the National Geographic Society does more and its stories might cost more to get written, but it needs to go digital and expand the way other publications are if it wants better numbers.
- smacktoward 11y agoI love the New Yorker, but its forte is not sending photographers to the bottom of the sea or the heart of the Amazon.