4 ms·
I can't name sources, but I have it in good confidence that this man ("Sonny" White) was forced to rewrite his dissertation by his PhD committee (mind you not h
by selimthegrim 11y ago
I can't name sources, but I have it in good confidence that this man ("Sonny" White) was forced to rewrite his dissertation by his PhD committee (mind you not his advisor, who was old and about to retire and had to be cajoled into line by the rest of them) because his first try was apparently all about this EMDrive stuff. This is a pathology.
- ryanwaggoner 11y agoWon't they look pretty stupid if this turns out to be real :) I know, I know, it's not real, it's not how science should be done, blah blah. I'm sure you're right.
- selimthegrim 11y agoSo, I'm being down voted for stating a relevant fact? I was asked not to reveal this by my source.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoFor disagreement, probably with the final line.
- mikeash 11y agoFor stating irrelevant hearsay, perhaps.
- selimthegrim 11y agoWhat, and if I break confidence and name names from the Rice faculty that would somehow be better? Being forced to rewrite entirely at a defense by the rest of one's committee is a BFD, it absolutely impacts his credibility.
- mikeash 11y agoWithout knowing the details of what happened, we have no idea how it affects this person's credibility. You have no credibility, so your unverifiable story conveys zero information. All it does is stir things up. Substantiating the story would be good, and failing that, saying nothing would be better than essentially spreading a rumor.
- selimthegrim 11y agoI'm a physics grad student at a university not too far from Rice. How am I supposed to substantiate this short of producing the first draft of his PhD thesis? Do you think academia keeps these things around?
- ryanwaggoner 11y agoI was sworn to secrecy on how I found this out, but a very reliable source that I can't name told me that selimthegrim murdered 17 homeless people over the last few years. Note: this is satire, just for anyone who missed it.
- mikeash 11y agoIt doesn't sound like you can substantiate it. But that has no influence on your credibility, or on the believability or relevance of what you're saying. From the outside, a true story that inherently can't be substantiated is indistinguishable from a made-up story that can't be substantiated. And it doesn't even have to be you who made it up, it could be the person you got it from, or wherever they got it, or all the way up the chain. Or maybe it's true! I have no idea, which is why I called it "hearsay" instead of "lies."
- foldr 11y agoIt's not the first time with this user: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10176671 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10176671