8 ms·
There is nothing that can guarantee that this ride is real, but here are a few things: 1. However big is MMM, it's probably too small for the size of the bitco
by csomar 11y ago
There is nothing that can guarantee that this ride is real, but here are a few things:
1. However big is MMM, it's probably too small for the size of the bitcoin economy right now. Remember that if you are transacting in bitcoin, there is one party buying and the other one selling. So you are not rising the price to the moon.
2. The number of transactions has been growing again as of late. It's heating at the blockchain right now ( https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions ). With 1MB, bitcoin can support less than 300k transactions a day.
3. The total output volume is jumping to crazy levels ( https://blockchain.info/charts/output-volume?timespan=all&showDataPoints=false&daysAverageString=1&show_header=true&scale=0&address= https://blockchain.info/charts/output-volume?timespan=all&sh... ) only seen in bubbles.
4. I have a localbitcoins post. I usually get 1-2 requests per week. In the last few days, well, I really lost count.
5. Google trends is spiking: https://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=bitcoin https://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=bitcoin But maybe this is happening because bitcoin price is rising, not the other way around?
6. If the price is rising fast, the supply will dry because nobody wants to sell an appreciating asset. If an asset is appreciating, it'll drive demand. Which will drive the price higher.
7. Media will start talking about it. It'll drive more people. It'll drive the price more.
8. We'll see if the new fancy infrastructure that bitcoin got is rock-solid.
9. If you don't own the keys, you don't own the bitcoins.
10. It's nice, but only if you bought the dip and sold before the crash.
- jcfrei 11y ago> However big is MMM, it's probably too small for the size of the bitcoin economy right now [...] That's very hard to quantify, but there might well be a feedback loop involving the media which leads to a price increase caused by MMM Global. The following Google Trends data for South Africa and the Philippines shows a nice correlation between searches for bitcoin and MMM Global: http://www.google.com/trends/explore?hl=en-US&geo=ZA&cmpt=q&q=bitcoin,+MMM+Global&tz=Etc/GMT-1&content=1 http://www.google.com/trends/explore?hl=en-US&geo=ZA&cmpt=q&...
- csomar 11y agoThat's why I used "probably". The thing is, transacting with bitcoin will not raise the price exponentially. BTC is already being exchanged in many millions of dollars a day. So unless MMM turns out to be a billion-dollar ponzi scheme I don't really think it'll affect the BTC price much.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> So unless MMM turns out to be a billion-dollar ponzi scheme I don't really think it'll affect the BTC price much. The actual transaction volume of bitcoin is not even that large. The total market cap is 6.5 billion and only because of the recent price surge.
- rsynnott 11y ago> So unless MMM turns out to be a billion-dollar ponzi scheme While I don't know much about this incarnation of MMM, the original MMM ponzi scheme in the early 90s is thought to have taken in about $10bn (not adjusted for inflation).
- nosuchthing 11y agoNever heard of MMM before, Looks like Sergei is persistant with these pyramid schemes; In January 2011, Mavrodi launched another pyramid scheme called MMM-2011, asking investors to buy so-called Mavro currency units. He frankly described it as a pyramid, adding "It is a naked scheme, nothing more ... People interact with each other and give each other money. For no reason!"[13] Mavrodi said that his goal with MMM-2011 is to destroy the current financial system, which he considers unfair, which would allow something new to take its place. MMM-2011 was able to function openly as Ponzi schemes and financial pyramids are not illegal under Russian law.[14] In May 2012 he froze the operation and announced that there would be no more payouts.[15] In 2011 he launched a similar scheme in India, called MMM India, again stating clearly that the vehicle is a pyramid.[16] He has also launched MMM in China.[17] He was reported to be trying to expand his operations into Western Europe, Canada, and Latin America.[14] As of September 2015 it had spread rapidly in South Africa with a claimed 1% per day or 30% per month interest rate scheme and warnings from both the South African and Russian Communist Parties for people not to participate in it.[18] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MMM-2011 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MMM-2011 Active thread talking about Sergei's current scheme: https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3p4kuf/mmm_global_republic_of_bitcoin/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3p4kuf/mmm_global_...
- eterm 11y agoDon't discount how much nefarious actions can drive bitcoin prices. Much of the $1000 bubble is discussed in terms of mtgox and "willie", but the initial peak was triggered by another driver which was the first large wave of cryptolocker infections. It goes without saying I'd stay well clear of bitcoin still though.
- davedx 11y ago> Much of the $1000 bubble is discussed in terms of mtgox and "willie", but the initial peak was triggered by another driver which was the first large wave of cryptolocker infections. I've not read that before (and I was pretty active on bitcoinforums during the $1000 bubble). Got a link?
- eterm 11y agoHere's the google trends for cryptolocker: https://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=cryptolocker https://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=cryptolocker Looks remarkably like the bitcoin price graph doesn't it?
- pmorici 11y agoYou are working with a limited view of Bitcoin price history if you think there have only been two prior bubbles or peaks. There have been something like 6 Bitcoin 'bubbles' and busts since 2011. The very first major bubble is attributed to Senator Chuck Schumer in June 2011 advertising to the world that you could buy drugs with Bitcoin on silk road. That took the price from $1 to $32 before crashing. http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/06/08/us-financial-bitcoins-idUSTRE7573T320110608#y6ffPlSzVU9XKRxc.97 http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/06/08/us-financial-bitco... http://www.forbes.com/sites/timothylee/2013/04/11/an-illustrated-history-of-bitcoin-crashes/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/timothylee/2013/04/11/an-illustr...
- tedks 11y agoI remember that summer. Such a beautiful and simple time for bitcoin. I frantically unloaded the bitcoins I bought at $8 when the price crashed from $30 at around $15/coin, withdrawing my entire initial investment and feeling bummed about not getting out when the getting was good. Then in a few months the 2 coins I kept were worth hundreds apiece.
- Natanael_L 11y ago> 9. If you don't own the keys, you don't own the bitcoins. Always the most important point. You need to hold your keys, and be the only person to do so (unencrypted). As for the rest, they can be summarized into this simple advice: If you're getting in, DO NOT spend more than you can afford to lose. You'll regret going into debt more than you'll regret not making a twice as big profit.
- kxr 11y agoInteresting point. I have some BTC at Coinbase. Not sure how I proceed to own the keys?
- usmannk 11y agoGet another wallet (such as hive) and send the BTC from Coinbase to that.
- bennyg 11y agoI recommend https://electrum.org https://electrum.org, even though the website doesn't look super awesome. You'll get a "seed" that generates your keys that is 12 words long. It looks something like this: "help staple correct horse ..." From there, just store that seed somewhere secure and you can use that to generate your keys whenever you want, on any machine you want. Personally I keep my seed in two different safe-deposit boxes and one on (shameless plug) my own encrypted text app I made called Onions - http://onionsapp.github.io http://onionsapp.github.io.
- StavrosK 11y agoElectrum is great, but not very easy to use (since it's desktop). Get Electrum, Mycelium or Breadwallet, depending on your platform. I've heard good things about GreenAddress, and I recommend a ledger hardware wallet. You can use the ledger with Electrum and Mycelium, so you can spend coins from desktop or mobile. I've also imported my Mycelium wallet onto my second ledger, just so I can move coins from the desktop.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- VMG 11y ago> 4. I have a localbitcoins post. I usually get 1-2 requests per week. In the last few days, well, I really lost count. Did you see a change in the type of customer?
- csomar 11y agoYes. People were usually asking in the $500-1000 range. Now, it's mostly $100. (it's my limit though).
- kingmanaz 11y ago11. The "halving" that is anticipated to take place sometime in 2016 is suddenly not so far off in the future.
- fitzwatermellow 11y agoChatter in BTC trading forums puts a $3000 price target as "doable" ;) A couple other points: mining is exploding as well with the global GHash rate / Difficulty accelerating. I have not calculated an exact correlation between price and compute but it could be an indicator of "real" moves in the currency. The truest indicator is of course price-action. During last summer and into the fall, before Beijing implemented capital controls, when you observed the depth of book on orders on BW, you'd notice that the vast majority of orders were for even lots of ~0.0100BTC. This was indicative of algorithmic market making. Very few orders were above 100BTC. Now it's the exact opposite. Large orders with fast fills are common. I wish I had some real data and actual stats on the order book during the run-up ;( as I believe it would make a good indicator as to whether the current move is sustainable...
- LandoCalrissian 11y agoSo what numbers do you have to pump it to until you get your money back?
- kordless 11y agoThis is a blaming statement. Trust comes in all shapes and sizes, and includes information from individuals who don't trust each other sharing what they know about a given object or system. Trusting someone else's information is done on an individual basis, unless there is a decent consensus mechanism in place (Rai Stones for example). If you don't trust what csomar is saying, then you should just say that instead of saying they are lying AND doing it for X reasons. Otherwise, you are just coming across as illogical in your arguments. I would also point out that blockchain technologies implement a particular type of trust. Bitcoin's blockchain trust delivers an identity mechanism (note I did not say it doesn't allow pseudo anonymous identity), a way to track a value for exchange between identities, and a means to deliver a standard format of information exchange comprised of contract via script, transaction with identities and op_return codes. That you are here doubting a known trust mechanism through a biased statement, and based on its momentary exchange value to a fiat currency, makes me not trust you as well.
- statoshi 11y agoI thought it was well known that you can't trust Lando Calrissian!
- josu 11y agoOn top of that, remember that bitcoin has many prices, the most important ones being US dollar, Euro and Chinese Yuan. Right now bitcoin is around 500USD, but it's sitting on 450EUR. People buying in euros will be confident that the price will go up to 500EUR and they'll keep pushing up the price. Wich will push CNY price to 3450CNY, a very ugly price, so it will probably move to 3500CNY.
- theseatoms 11y agoWith all due respect, I don't think that's how markets work. I know that people tend to psychologically anchor to round figures, but I don't see this situation playing out as you've described.
- clay_to_n 11y agoIn earlier days of remember I think I do remember this happening. Once the price got to a certain point (~980?) it very quickly would get up to 1000, and then hover there for a while. Part of this is because people will put sell requests at that round number.
- dlsx 11y agoHe doesn't understand Chinese. When you said "ugly number" this is very important to the Chinse. They will push the price based on what number they are attached to. If the price is 314.44 they will push it to 316.88 because that is the number they like, and if they dictate that price it is like they have created their own luck. At least this is my philosophy dealing with Chinese and watching their buy patterns.
- elif 11y agoThere are very real 'sell walls' on most of the markets, hovering around rounded increments. Once those "barriers" get broken through, there is usually a spike in price afterward. I could totally see a spike on one market driving buys in another market, so it is a reasonable point to consider the effect cascading.
- dperfect 11y ago> There is nothing that can guarantee that this ride is real I'm not sure what you mean by "real" here. Even if demand is created from questionable/fraudulent sources, the transactions are just as real as any others. That's not to say it's sustainable or even driven by rational behavior (it never really is). Any trend, bubble or not, is just that - a trend. There may be numerous factors driving it, and it's almost never a good idea to make trading decisions based on the trend itself (the few exceptions of traders should be very aware of the limitations and risks involved in such a strategy). > We'll see if the new fancy infrastructure that bitcoin got is rock-solid. Are you referring to Bitcoin XT / BIP 101? As far as I'm aware[1], the support for this is still represented by a minority, so we're not really going to see any "new fancy infrastructure" tested, at least not for a while. [1] http://xtnodes.com/ http://xtnodes.com/
- gwern 11y agoYou misunderstand his point. The MMM ponzi schemers presumably don't want to hold bitcoins forever, and would be selling them for local currencies; if each bitcoin bought by a MMM victim is being immediately sold by a MMM con artist, then the net effect is zero and the effect on the price is much less than however much is being laundered and the price is boosted only by the float (however much bitcoins are being held at any particular second by a victim/con artist until they can send it or sell it and complete the circle).
- dperfect 11y agoI understand that, but it still doesn't make the trend any less "real" than trends seen from other drivers of price movement. To explain a bit more: If a merchant receives fraudulent credit card transactions, he/she could reasonably refer to those as "not real" because once the banks discover the fraud, they have the power to move money and effectively nullify those transactions in many cases. In contrast, on the blockchain (and off the blockchain for most bitcoin exchanges), that kind of thing doesn't normally happen. Even in Mt Gox's case where they directly manipulated the price from the inside, the people who bought and sold on the exchange still experienced "real" price movement, and as long as they got their money/BTC out before Gox imploded (which is another matter), those transactions and price movements were every bit as real as any other. From the perspective of other exchanges at the time it didn't matter at all whether the driving force for the trend was fraud or completely legitimate behavior. Finally, if MMM's "net effect is zero" as you say, then we wouldn't be seeing the price movement that we're seeing (and a price "boosted only by the float" is no different from a price boosted by anything else), or perhaps MMM just isn't the primary driving force in the current trend.
- Mithaldu 11y agoMaybe it's related to this auction of the silkroad bitcoins: http://www.usmarshals.gov/assets/2015/dpr-bitcoins/ http://www.usmarshals.gov/assets/2015/dpr-bitcoins/ Note the correlation between the registration deadline date and the start of the rise.