4 ms·
In an interview the shareholder explained, “I did not sign the consent form. There was no statement saying that a failure to respond was tantamount to consent.
by AndrewKemendo 11y ago
In an interview the shareholder explained, “I did not sign the consent form. There was no statement saying that a failure to respond was tantamount to consent. How could it have passed by unanimous consent? I got emails from Theranos asking me to sign. I never did. Nor did I receive information about Theranos’s financial performance or prospects.”
These deals don't need 100% response or signature to get "unanimous consent" - only a majority. That this was highlighted is either sloppy on the part of Forbes or deliberately trying to stir the pot.
As much as we love down in flames stories (for some grotesque reason) I don't think there is much to see here.
- 467568985476 11y agoWould you mind clarifying what you mean about the definition of "unanimous" in this context? Even if it technically means "not actually unanimous" it still seems pretty misleading to me. Why would they explicitly say that every shareholder supports the decision when they mean that a majority of shareholders support it?
- fiatmoney 11y agoIn a parliamentary context, "unanimous consent" means "no dissenting voices" - ie, no "no" votes, not accounting for those silent or absent.
- wavefunction 11y agoIt doesn't sound like there was a mechanism to vote "no" or object. I'm with you.
- URSpider94 11y agoThere doesn't need to be. If you don't get a majority of shares voting yes, then the measure doesn't pass. If you do, then it does.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- philipov 11y agoAs you say, with the ability to respond "yes" and "abstain" the only possible outcomes are 'it passes' and 'it doesn't pass.' You can't have 'passes unanimously' because that would be a third outcome that can't be obtained with only two possible responses. To add that possibility to our outcome set, we have to introduce a third response called "no." The name of the "it passes" token may be arbitrary, but calling it "passes unanimously" is deceptive because it implies there were three ways to respond, not only two. If it is possible to pass unanimously, then to pass without qualification must mean something else. If there is a large group of people that regularly makes use of that usage, the simplest conclusion is that they're all trying to deceive someone.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoIn the times that we have sent shareholder consents it's the case that they sign a document that says "I agree to this change." It's not, "do you agree? check yes or no." If the majority sign, then you have unanimous consent. The ones who don't sign are basically abstaining, in practice usually cause they are too busy and just never get around to it, not because they express dissent. The language is confusing because it sounds more like a vote than it is.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoIf there's no consent that isn't unanimous, you're abusing the term. When the options are "consent" or "shut up, we don't want to hear from you", there's no justification for calling that "unanimous consent".
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoUnfortunately it's not the case. The alternative isn't "shut up, we don't want to hear from you" it's, "you were given the same amount of information as everyone else and didn't respond by the cutoff - and by the way the majority of respondents consented so any response is moot." Where it would matter is if there were abstentions for dissent, which I have never dealt with, so I can't say anything about it. My guess is that you wouldn't send something out in such a manner anyway if you expected resistance.
- in_cahoots 11y agoThat seems like a distinction without a difference to me. As I read your posts there's no way for a shareholder to voice dissent; you can either agree or abstain. Maybe this is some legal term I am not understanding, but I don't see how that's unanimous under the layman's definition of the word.
- URSpider94 11y agoIt's not a layman's definition. The word "unanimous" has a different meaning in corporate governance (and generally in Parliamentary procedure). It's also not at all uncommon to be presented with a proposal where the only options are "yes" and "abstain." There is no need for a no option, because you need a majority of yes votes for the measure to pass. Abstaining is the same as voting no.
- ics 11y agoThere is room for confusion. From Wikipedia "Unanimity": "Unanimity may be assumed explicitly after a unanimous vote or implicitly by a lack of objections." "Practice varies as to whether a vote can be considered unanimous if some voter abstains." Unanimous consent as stated by Theranos means (a) the majority / necessary number of shareholders gave a response and (b) none of those responses were of dissent. The quoted shareholder may still be surprised that the shareholders who did vote were a large enough group and in unanimous agreement; it's not necessarily wrong of the author to include this. Edit: The wording of the quote however does come across as though they misunderstood the consent part however.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoForbes of all outlets, especially Peter Cohan, should know the difference and that this isn't abnormal at all.
- molyss 11y agoand so should an investor in a privately owned company. the "shareholder" could be an employee with equity and no voting rights, in which case the article is just here to surf on the buzz surrounding theranos and adding to the bad press. Or it could be a meaningful investor, in which case he/she should be blaming noone but him/herself for not reading the fine prints/asking a lawyer
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- trhway 11y agosounds like something that Dell did while taking private the Dell - the abstentions were changed from default "no" to just not counted at all.
- Animats 11y agoThis is the kind of thing you have to be very careful about if you're an officer of a company. It's permitted under Delaware law to do such things by unanimous consent, and in some circumstances by majority written consent, but certain notices have to be given to the stockholders.[1] In addition, controlling stockholders have fiduciary obligations to non-controlling stockholders.[2] The authority of the majority is not unlimited. In particular, an attempt by the majority, especially when the majority is management, to dilute the rights of the minority while benefiting management usually leads to trouble. Claiming there was unanimous approval when there wasn't is a great way to get sued. [1] http://delcode.delaware.gov/title8/c001/sc07/ http://delcode.delaware.gov/title8/c001/sc07/ [2] https://www.akingump.com/images/content/2/2/v4/22475/Duties-of-Controlling-Stockholders-PLI-Article-June-2012.pdf https://www.akingump.com/images/content/2/2/v4/22475/Duties-...
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoGood clarification, and I should say that my comment was more intended to address the broader objection to having abstaining members, yet still calling quorum & unanimous consent - rather than evaluate the specific Theranos situation. IANAL and there isn't enough info in the article to even really do that.
- courtneypowell 11y agoShareholder agreements can define 'Unanimous' in any variety of ways. So long as the agreement is approved, it can supersede Deleware shareholder laws.
- bravo22 11y agoGenerally speaking laws supersede agreements, not the other way around. That's their whole purpose. Certain things can't be done and certain rights can't be forefit if specifically disallowed by laws
- rayiner 11y agoWhen it comes to corporate and contract law, many laws are "default rules" that agreements can explicitly override.