4 ms·
Yeah, there are a lot of alternate nuclear reactor designs that look great on paper but have never had the full scale engineering done to see if it is practical
by jandrese 11y ago
Yeah, there are a lot of alternate nuclear reactor designs that look great on paper but have never had the full scale engineering done to see if it is practical. And they look cheap because you don't even know half of the stuff you have to do that makes it expensive.
It's like rocket design where you go "just put a bunch of explosives in a tube and go into space, this shouldn't be too expensive or difficult..."
- madaxe_again 11y agoYup. Rocket science is dead easy. Tsiolkovsky, and... that's about it. Rocket engineering, on the other hand...
- berntb 11y agoI thought e.g. TerraPower was beyond that stage? Sources?
- 13thLetter 11y agoTrue; many of these dream reactors probably won't work, because that is the nature of things. But the full-scale engineering never gets done because of anti-nuclear propaganda playing on mass public ignorance, so at the rate we're going now we'll never know.
- beat 11y agoFull scale engineering, free of the liberal treehugging you decry, happens in China, India, Russia, and elsewhere. You'd think we'd be seeing better results than we are.
- witty_username 11y agoWell, at least Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant was being delayed due to protests by local people. Another reason why better results are not being obtained is because of the subsidy on CO2 emitting fuels by not taxing the externalities (which would make nuclear power significantly more profitable) and also difficulties in obtaining nuclear material (NSG, for example). Kudankulam power plant generates power at 4.29 rupees/kW.h which is barely profitable compared to other methods (mostly fossil fuels).
- andromeduck 11y agoChina literally just got started and betting pretty big too so hell yeah we're going to see results in the next 10 years.
- alfapla 11y agoIf there's positive buzz about molten salt reactors, the most likely source of that buzz is people who want to get rich selling molten salt reactors.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 11y agoThis is where John D Clark's book "Ignition!" really shines: it's the history of the science of rocket fuel as problem solving. Plenty of candidates on paper, need to be tested for detonation, hypergolicity, ease of ignition, handling, effect on plumbing etc. Red fuming nitric acid is a good example: great oxidiser, doesn't need cryogenics but is liquid even in arctic temperatures. Only problem is it eats through the tanks, until they discovered that adding a small quantity of HF made it OK to store in stainless steel. I suspect that he would have taken one look at handling radioactive corrosive liquid at 600C and asked to go back to the nice safe rocket lab with only a few explosions.
- mey 11y agoI've seen Ignition! referenced quite a few times on this site. Is there a reasonable place to get a reprint?
- bumbledraven 11y agoGoogling for [john clark ignition] yielded http://fringe.davesource.com/Fringe/Explosives/Ignition.An-Informal-History-of-Liquid-Rocket-Propellants.John-D-Clark.pdf http://fringe.davesource.com/Fringe/Explosives/Ignition.An-I... (also on archive.org)
- paol 11y agoIt's available online: http://library.sciencemadness.org/library/books/ignition.pdf http://library.sciencemadness.org/library/books/ignition.pdf
- mey 11y agoThank you, went to save it to my dropbox and found a copy already there...