7 ms·
I am not reflexively anti-nuclear. However, I have never heard a satisfactory answer to the simple question: "How do we store nuclear waste safely?"
by tomcam 11y ago
I am not reflexively anti-nuclear. However, I have never heard a satisfactory answer to the simple question: "How do we store nuclear waste safely?"
- voidlogic 11y agoBy not hiding it away, but using warehouses that are actively staffed just like the plant that made the waste. Of course these facilities should be secure installations. But the root of the problem is not wanted to actively take ownership responsibility for the waste. I imagine every major city having its secure storage installation. Consider the scale of waste generated as well. All the waste used to power a life of electrical usage creates was the size of a pea.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- theoh 11y agoThe complex "social" side of the problem (for example, the vast amount of waste produced by the manufacture of nuclear warheads during the Cold War) means that it is not easily solved. There's a documentary film coming out about this by Peter Galison and Rob Moss. http://containmentmovie.com/ http://containmentmovie.com/
- lojack 11y ago> All the waste used to power a life of electrical usage creates was the size of a pea. Source on this? Best I could find shows that 3 cubic meters of waste is generated per year for a "typical 1000 MWe light water reactor" after reprocessing and all (which isn't always done). [1] With 99 plants in the US (not counting the plants with multiple reactors) that leads to 297m^3 of waste. With a population of 318 million, that's about 9.3x10-7, or approximately 4-5 peas per year or 367 peas over the course of a lifetime. [1] http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/Nuclear-Fuel-Cycle/Nuclear-Wastes/Radioactive-Waste-Management/#ManageHLW http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/Nuclear-Fuel-Cycle/Nuclear... EDIT: Forgot that we only get about 20% of our power from nuclear energy, so it's actually closer to 1835 peas.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoEveryone brushes over that, the billions of dollars to build a plant, and the ~10 year construction time. Any nuclear power plant that has construction started today won't be cost competitive with renewables when it comes online. It would be like building a new coal plant in the US today. You simply can't compete with wind, solar, and natural gas (which is still superior to coal, and I don't mind it being a stranded asset for whomever invested in it as solar and wind ramp up).
- merpnderp 11y agoHow do wind and solar provide a solid baseline power. And China builds nuclear plants a lot faster and cheaper than we do, and no known accidents. Maybe we can learn something from them. Plus the whole 90% of a nuclear plant's cost is servicing the debt. Once completed the operational costs are a rounding error.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> How do wind and solar provide a solid baseline power. Properly built and managed distribution networks, along with utility scale battery storage. > And China builds nuclear plants a lot faster and cheaper than we do, and no known accidents. Yet. China still gets more power from wind than nuclear, and they're building out wind generation capacity far faster than nuclear: http://www.earth-policy.org/data_highlights/2015/highlights50 http://www.earth-policy.org/data_highlights/2015/highlights5... > Maybe we can learn something from them. Indeed. When you're an authoritarian regime, you can operate more fluidly "at scale" (fuck you, I do what I want). > Plus the whole 90% of a nuclear plant's cost is servicing the debt. And yet, someone has to pony up those billions of dollars. A kickstarter perhaps? > Once completed the operational costs are a rounding error. And when you fail hard, it costs billions of dollars to cleanup: http://www.psr.org/environment-and-health/environmental-health-policy-institute/responses/costs-and-consequences-of-fukushima.html http://www.psr.org/environment-and-health/environmental-heal... I'll take solar and wind, thanks.
- merpnderp 11y ago
- linschn 11y agoThe question is not about about "safely", the question is about "in a safer way than the alternatives". So, let's look at how we can safely store coal/oil waste. We can't, it goes straight in the air, or in the sea. So in this sense, I'd argue even simply dumping our nuclear waste in the Mariana Trench would be safer.
- brrt 11y agoWe burn it! That is, nuclear burn it, not chemically. And what can't be burned can be bombarded with neutrons into radiological inertia. And what can't be neutralized in that sense can be molten into a ceramic, more specifically, a glass, and stored underground. Which is of course where it came from, when you think of it. Seriously, nuclear waste storage is not a problem. This page gives an excellent eplanation: http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/chapter11.html http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/chapter11.html Nuclear energy has lots of problems, and I personally think this article is not worth this place on HN, but waste is not really one of them, especially compared to the scale of chemical wastes from fossil fuels.
- wycx 11y agospecifically, NOT a glass: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synroc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synroc
- ricardobeat 11y agoAnd still radioactive.
- anon1mous 11y agoDo you burn it? Why is it than that every reactor I know of, in US, WE, Japan, stores tones of extremely dangerous waste on site?
- ansible 11y agoI think brrt is talking about "burning" nuclear waste in a molten-salt reactor or similar. Some types of existing fission reactors can only utilize a small percentage of the uranium in their fuel rods, after which the rods must be removed. The rods must then be stored, and possibly reprocessed afterwards. MSR and other fission reactor types can utilize 100% of the fissionable material put into them, so this sort of leftover "waste" is not such a problem.
- anon1mous 11y ago
- yongjik 11y agoBury it deep enough? Somehow everybody freaks out about nuclear waste and says stuff like "But after 20,000 years it will still retain half of its radiation!" Well, our industrial waste also contain mercury and other heavy metals. We usually just bury them. Somehow nobody freaks out and says "But after 20,000 years it will still retain ALL of its toxicity!" I can't fathom why.
- sjwright 11y agoAnd what they also don't appreciate is that nuclear material with a 20,000 year half-life has, by definition, very very low radioactivity. It's like any other fuel -- the faster it burns, the shorter it lives. And vice versa.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoYes, very much this. "Long half-life" = "not very radioactive" by definition. "Half-life of infinity" must sound really scary to these people, but that's the same as saying that it's not radiactive at all.
- anon1mous 11y agoVery simple - a few tones of Uranium or Plutonium, dispersed in air or water can kill the population of a continent.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoVery simply, you're wrong. Badly wrong. http://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/nuclear/nuclear-fuel-from-the-sea http://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/nuclear/nuclear-fuel-from-th... The ocean contains 4.5 billion tonnes of uranium already. 4.5. BILLION. TONNES. Dispersed in water. I haven't noticed any continents dying off because of this, have you?
- KingMob 11y agoBut it's well-known that dying continents leave the pack and slink off into the mantle to die alone, so you wouldn't necessarily have seen it.
- ThomPete 11y agoWe recycle it http://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2014/10/01/why-doesnt-u-s-recycle-nuclear-fuel/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2014/10/01/why-doesnt-u...
- Eeko 11y agoDumping it to the ocean is pretty safe. Seriously: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocean_disposal_of_radioactive_waste#Environmental_impact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocean_disposal_of_radioactive_... However, since people don't easily believe water's a very effective radiation shielding (even if there's an xkcd of it https://what-if.xkcd.com/29/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/29/) and that heavier than water metals kind of tend to stay put at the bottom of the ocean, other means of disposal might be more realistic. Recycling in breeder reactors, digging huge holes to the ground, buildings which last longer than pyramids etc. Of course, how one defines "safely" is tricky. Perfect safety is impossible, of course. One can't guarantee that our hole will stand to the heat death of the universe - but just ensuring that the disposal will cause less harm to earth and its living beings than any other energy production method is fairly easy to do. Even windmills kill some people, animals and fauna during normal operation, so if we set "less murderous than windmills" as an acceptable safety standard, we could settle for the ocean disposal, for example.
- kuschku 11y agoActually, Britain did that. They dumped most of their waste in the channel. Result, 20 years later: The waste did not dilute, the radiation in the channel is damaging the local animals.
- Eeko 11y agoIt's not supposed to dilute. It should stay put and not spread around. Most human activities tend to displace natural ecosystems. Waste dumps (nor windmills) are no exception. The question is, is the damage lesser than greater than in proposed alternatives? Though I do not understand why did they choose to dump the waste to the channel? If I would dispose the waste by sinking, I would use a kilometers deep trench to minimize risks for reacquirement and environmental damage. Do they plan to dig up the waste sometime in the future?
- kuschku 11y agoWell, they did it because it was easy. And cheap. If you want safe nuclear power, including demolishing the reactors safely, safely getting rid of all the materials, nine nines safety, etc, then it won’t be profitable. If you want for-profit nuclear power, then either the government has to subsidize it, or it has to be unsafe. Usually, it’s both unsafe (companies save money everywhere, including stuff like not securing the generator cough Fukushima cough) and barely profitable.
- sjwright 11y agoYou don't just store it, you repeatedly reprocess and reuse it to extract all of the valuable highly energetic material. The remainder can be stored in geologically stable underground facilities, where it is no more environmentally impactful than uranium ore was prior to being mined.
- x3n0ph3n3 11y agoThorium waste has a half-life at ~100 years. We can certainly build containers to safely store that waste until it is no longer harmful.
- DrScump 11y agoEven ignoring modern reactor designs that can use waste isotopes as fuel, we had a perfect storage solution in Nevada... until Harry Reid sabotaged it, costing taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars.
- PolLambert 11y agoBeing very familiar with nuclear waste, I can say that, from a technical pov, it's a solved problem: just put it deep enough to comply with whatever safety level is required. The problem with nuclear waste is political not technical and not economical. Reprocessing or transmutation are alternatives to handle nuclear waste but they have in common that they're more expensive and even less acceptable to society.
- 13thLetter 11y agoa) How is "put it in Yucca Mountain" not satisfactory? b) Do you demand similar levels of safe storage for all of the hazardous materials, many of which are far more dangerous than nuclear waste, produced by other industries, including those involved in renewables technologies?