4 ms·
The State Department is being a bit hypocritical here. If China must give an explanation for its alleged cyberattacks/hacking attempts on gmail, then the U.S. g
by ilamont 17y ago
The State Department is being a bit hypocritical here. If China must give an explanation for its alleged cyberattacks/hacking attempts on gmail, then the U.S. government should also give an explanation for its NSA-sponsored eavesdropping/hacking/snooping of other countries' citizens' email, phone conversations, and other communications.
- flatline 17y agoYes but righteous indignation is so much easier to muster. Honestly though, this is more about China's history of human rights violations than the hacking attempts themselves.
- jacquesm 17y agoThe time for google to make principled stances on that subject is long past, they already let the $ go before their principles. You can't turn around a couple of years later and sincerely say that you want to make the principle now your paramount reason for a move. The time for principled stances is when things happen, or when they come to light. The whole human rights thing is just so much window dressing and PR spin.
- alex_c 17y agoPrinciples aside, you have to admit, "Google threatening to pull out of China", or, if it comes to that, "Google pulls out of China", is a much stronger headline than "Google not going into China".
- jacquesm 17y agoI don't think so. If they had loudly and publicly stated that they were not going to do any business in China because of the human rights violations there I think it would have been a much stronger statement. Now it looks to me as though they figure the income they make in China isn't worth the continued PR headache, or, alternatively, they decided to leave anyway and they use the occasion to polish up their image. I'm very cynical when it comes to large companies doing things for the public good, but you could already tell that I guess. Shell, Yahoo, Microsoft, Google (and many others beside) they all have their skeletons in the cupboard in this respect.
- alex_c 17y agoI guess we'll have to disagree regarding the headlines. Still, if you apply the cynical view consistently, then Google refusing to do business in China can be seen as Google making a calculation, deciding they can't make enough money in China to justify the headache/bad PR, and claiming the decision is because of human rights issues. Same interpretation, 2 years earlier.
- jacquesm 17y agoI think there is a substantial difference between saying a loud and clear 'No!' to the largest growth market on the planet before entering or saying it after several years of mapping that market. For sure the calculation today is a lot more refined than it was several years ago, and probably the figures in the spreadsheets are smaller than they were back then.
- philwelch 17y agoAny statement Google makes in 2010 is much stronger than any statement Google could have made in 2006, when they first went into China.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- smokinjuan 17y ago>I think it would have been a much stronger statement. To who are they trying to make a statement? If to "the rest of the world" then your statement makes sense. However, if they're trying to make a statement to the Chinese population it's probably better that google demonstrates their services worth then pulls the plug.
- jacquesm 17y agoIf the Chinese population would figure very high in their book then they would have made the statement earlier, and that statement would have been in Chinese, not in English. It is clearly intended for consumption by the rest of the world.
- astine 17y agoI think that depends mostly on spin. For example: "After a thorough investigation of business opportunities in China, Google has decided not to touch the place with a ten-foot pole." Or: "Google on China: F!@# NO!"
- patio11 17y agoI should point out that the State Department does not wiretap Chinese citizens phones so that they know which little old lady to beat to death. That is China's job. Returning you now to your regularly scheduled moral relativism.
- sfk 17y agoAnd this is the job of the U.S.: http://www.cbc.ca/news/background/arar/ http://www.cbc.ca/news/background/arar/
- stanleydrew 17y agoHow do you know that's true?
- roc 17y agoBecause the CIA isn't part of the State Department?
- cakesy 17y agoActually you are wrong. It is quite common for countries to monitor other countries communications in the past (Australia for the US), becuase there are no rules in Australia against monitoring US citizens, only forbidding them from monitoring Australia Citizens without proper procedure.
- Quarrelsome 17y agoOr perhaps clear up that whole "Extraordinary rendition" debacle and press charges against those that set it in motion.