4 ms·
So it's not legal, but there's nothing you can do to stop them? That doesn't offer much in the way of reassurance to the people being tortured at the request of
by makomk 11y ago
So it's not legal, but there's nothing you can do to stop them? That doesn't offer much in the way of reassurance to the people being tortured at the request of the FBI.
- rayiner 11y agoIf you are being illegally detained, you can file for a writ of habeas corpus. In contrast, Bivens is about getting money damages if you suffered illegal detainment in the past. The scope of habeas corpus (which the Supreme Court has held does apply to U.S. citizens detained abroad) is broader than that of Bivens because the former is explicitly mentioned in the Constitution, and the latter is a relatively recent judge-made construct.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> If you are being illegally detained, you can file for a writ of habeas corpus. If you are being illegally detained, its not entirely unlikely you will also be illegally denied the opportunity to file for a writ of habeas corpus; if you are extremely lucky, someone who isn't being illegally deprived of their rights might figure out that you are being illegally detained and file for the writ on your behalf. But, you know, when the government's illegally detaining people, illegally denying them access to counsel, and illegally denying them access to the courts, they generally aren't also advertising the fact of that detention of those particular individuals so that other people can intervene to do something about it. The lack of effective after-the-fact accountability, both personal and institutional, for such violations is a serious problem which makes them more likely to be continued or repeated. The availability of the writ of habeas corpus to terminate the unlawful detention is obviously necessary, but nearly equally obviously insufficient.
- vox_mollis 11y agoYup. I'm consistently amazed at the law enforcement apologists who vociferously argue about one's legal options in circumstances where law enforcement is already conducting itself illegally. Meta: I understand that HN encompasses far, far more than classical hacker culture, but the pro-authoritarian drift of this community is really becoming apparent.
- rayiner 11y agoA few Bivens lawsuits isn't going to deter one whit an FBI that's already doing things that illegal. All it will do is get the judiciary to burn institutional capital on what is fundamentally a political issue. There is a big difference between saying that the courts are not the right way to fix the problem and saying that what the FBI is doing is not a problem at all. Getting the courts involved in these foreign national security issues undermines the institutional capital of the judiciary. It makes it more likely that the government will get used to ignoring court authority when it comes to core domestic functions.
- fweespeech 11y agoThe fact the Federal Government is wielding nonacquiescence so brazenly, to the point of clear violations of the rights of US citizens, is pretty much a sign that the institutional capital has run out and they have no fear of repercussions from the court system.
- mindslight 11y ago> Getting the courts involved in these foreign national security issues undermines the institutional capital of the judiciary. The courts shirking justice when LEOs transgress undermines their institutional capital with the only group that should actually matter - the people. When "law enforcement" can routinely violate the law yet not be charged and the victims not made whole, equal protection has gone out the window. Why should anyone respect a "court" that simply functions as a rubber stamp for government activities?
- rayiner 11y agoIf "the people" cared about LEOs violating the rights of accused criminals and terrorists, they'd stop voting for hard-line authoritarians that promise to be tough on crime/terrorism. Instead, they vote for them at all levels of government. Even Obama gained a lot of popularity in his second campaign for being the guy who put a bullet in the head of Osama bin Laden.