4 ms·
What are the C919's selling point versus the Boeing 737 and Airbus A320?
by GordonS 11y ago
What are the C919's selling point versus the Boeing 737 and Airbus A320?
- blumkvist 11y ago"Keeping those western imperialists out of our country!"
- GordonS 11y agoHeh, I meant from a technical perspective :)
- ucaetano 11y ago"Keeping those western imperialist technologies out of our country!"
- lujim 11y ago20% more lead in the construction offset by the decreased weight of no safety equipment. Actually it was advertised to have better fuel economy than some variants of the 737, but it doesn't really appear to be much of an improvement. Just China's answer to the 737 and A320 as far as I can see.
- iSnow 11y agoObviously price. And it's a first, Airbus didn't sell that many A-300 in the first years. Only with the A-320 did they have a winner and subsequently developed a whole family of jets. China isn't just looking at the next couple of business quarters, they want to get a foothold in the commercial jet market in the next decades.
- Someone1234 11y agoThey're trying to be the "Kia of aircraft" meaning they offer a lot of value for a relatively low price. They're primarily targeting budget airlines. It is a little speculatory but supposedly their average aircraft will cost $68 million Vs. $71.9m or $78.3m for a A320 and 737 respectively. So they will be the cheapest in that line, and are trying to match or better the other two in fuel economy, supposedly 15% more fuel efficient than the A320 [0] (but the A320neo is meant to be more comparable). That being said few analysts think that Comac's first attempt at commercial success will be successful. They have a lot of obstacles to overcome. However assuming the money doesn't dry up their second or third aircraft might be fairly competitive. So watch this space for the mid to late 2020s, might see Comac on the tarmac somewhere nearby. [0] http://leehamnews.com/2012/01/05/c919-gains-but-loses-advantages/ http://leehamnews.com/2012/01/05/c919-gains-but-loses-advant...
- noja 11y ago$4 million cheaper, on a $68 million price tag? Is that a typo?
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoNo. $4 million is a lot of money. Now imagine that you're buying 100 of them.
- noja 11y agoIt's less than a 6% discount for something new and untested. Saving money it is not.
- notahacker 11y agoIt's an insignificant amount of money for an airline because (i) anyone buying 100 of them negotiates deep discounts from the manufacturer anyway, with Airbus and Boeing probably having more scope to offer them (ii) they borrow the money to buy the aircraft, and cost of finance on an aircraft of unknown provenance will be higher [unless a very favourable export credit arrangement underwritten by the Chinese govt] (iii) capital costs of acquiring an aircraft are a fraction of the cost of ownership, and there's a lot more uncertainty about the cost of operations and maintenance on these, as well as whether there will be an liquidity in the aftermarket when the airline wants to move them on.
- hugh4 11y agoThen I'm still only saving a few percent on the large amount of money I'm spending. And in return I not only have to deal with the risk of buying a hundred aircraft designed and built by people who were pushing plows a couple of years ago based on some photocopies smuggled out of Toulouse, I also have to have the airline that people say "Oh hell no I'm not flying on that".
- ant6n 11y agoHow does that compare to the Bombardier C-Series?
- coin 11y agohttp://english.comac.cc/products/ca/pi/ http://english.comac.cc/products/ca/pi/ "Chinese Characteristics. We should set our footing on the practical situations in China, leverage on the whole nation's strengths andwisdem, and bring into full play the political superiority of the socialist system which is capable of concentrating all of its resources in achieving great things."
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoYeah, that's a sales pitch that will resonate with the rest of the world... </sarcasm>
- notahacker 11y agoReminds me of the nascent Frigate Ecojet project. An ex-colleague met some of the team behind it and described them as keen to shake off the image of it being a solely Russian venture. This is their website: http://www.frigate-ecojet.ru/ http://www.frigate-ecojet.ru/