5 ms·
People's happiness depends more on the relative quality of their lives compared to others, not absolute quality. It's a basic property of humanity.
by fulafel 11y ago
People's happiness depends more on the relative quality of their lives compared to others, not absolute quality. It's a basic property of humanity.
- danbruc 11y agoThis doesn't sound true or only insofar that it makes you unhappy if you do a comparable amount of work but don't receive a comparable compensation. So I would say that not receiving your fair share makes you unhappy but not only having less then others.
- fulafel 11y agoPeople still experience diminished happiness if they feel their relatively low quality of life or social status is because of their perceived own shortcomings. This is often how depressed people feel.
- SolaceQuantum 11y agoDepressed people feel depressed because of a chemical imbalance in the brain, not because of the ready they think. Having a chemical imbalance allows all sorts of thoughts, but they should be considered in context of someone who may already be incapable of feeling happy for other reasons.
- fulafel 11y agoI agree, the reference to depression was just to reference an emotional state that is part of our emotional vocabulary.
- logicchains 11y ago>People's happiness depends more on the relative quality of their lives compared to others. It's a basic property of humanity. This used to be called "envy", and seen as a vice to be avoided. Interestingly, the description of it as a "basic property" of humanity is in a way similar to symbolic interpretations of the Christian notion of "original sin" (Christians/theologians please correct me if I'm wrong).
- littletimmy 11y agoEnvy was also always related to greed. You seem to want a society where envy is absent, but greed drives economic growth. That won't happen.
- logicchains 11y ago>Envy was also always related to greed. They're related in that they're both pejorative terms for the act of wanting something, but their meanings differ. Envy means wanting something 'cos other people have it, greed means wanting something for some intrinsic property of the thing. E.g. if I want to get rich so I can afford a hundred hookers, coke and pizza a day, I want that for the intrinsic satisfaction those things bring, not because I care about having more hookers/coke/pizza than anyone else.
- littletimmy 11y agoI am not sure that the psychology of the hairless chimp makes this fine point when it is thinking about those two things. I think it goes "I see. I want. That thing shiny. That guy have - why I don't have?" But I get your point. It is another trick of the rich to use religion to solidify their wealth. You want what I have? Sin! I want to enclosure more land? Not sin.
- fulafel 11y agoWell, labeling it a vice to be avoided is just application of social pressure to suppress or shun this feature of the human psyche. "Inequality is just fine, feeling unhappy about inequality is a character flaw."
- logicchains 11y agoI'd argue that social pressure to shun this feature of the psyche is ultimately more productive for human happiness. Some people are always going to be luckier/smarter/harder working/more ruthless than others and they'll end up with more in pretty much any social system, so people who accept this inevitability are gonna be a lot happier than people who aren't happy as long as anyone else has more than them.
- ancap 11y agoIf this is reasonable justification to forcibly distribute people's capital, than why not to force everyone into a wheelchair to give the disabled more happiness? Or force everyone to shave their head to make the bald more happy? Or force everyone to lob off a limb for the "benefit" of the maimed? EDIT: to the silent down-voters might I suggest you more equally distribute your down-votes to increase HN happiness.
- asgard1024 11y agoI think the above explanation I made with ultimatum game may provide some insight. People have a notion of fairness, which is more subtle; they don't just want to force everyone on the same level.
- pron 11y agoI'd like to challenge your assumptions a little (although I agree with the other commenter that the reality is more nuanced): why do you think that distributing capital is forceful while it fairly belongs to some people to begin with? You seem to assume that private property is the natural state of affairs, while in reality it is a social construct that started with the agricultural revolution, when people could start accumulating wealth. It is society (which preceded property) which allowed people to own property to begin with. Private property (as a value) is a social invention. Hence, it could just as well be argued that society forcefully de-distributes property and entrusts it in the hands of a few individuals.
- ancap 11y agoIf private property is nothing more than a "social construct" surely the concept of "society" is nothing more. What is society other than a collection of individuals? And if the individuals cannot own property then what gives society that right?
- pron 11y agoSociety is not an invention. It is the name we give the emergent dynamics among a group of interacting individuals. It can be said to exist objectively (and is not present when describing a collection of individuals that do not interact). Also, note that I didn't say that private property is "nothing more" than a social construct. I said it is a social construct, and as a social construct it's a lot, because that's all there is for most if not all our values, and that's plenty. But, being a social construct, it cannot apriori take precedence over other social constructs (like the value of fairness). Now, in general, the question of "rights" is a hard one, because obviously there is nothing to give anything a right. A right is a common (perhaps universal) shared value, sometimes with extrinsic justifications but most of the time without (in the end, it's hard to ascribe a truly objective value to anything in the universe, as you quickly get to circular dependencies of values). But, it is not a bad starting point to assume that all rights originate in social convention, and those conventions, in turn, are based on human psychology and circumstance. This too is an incomplete description, because we haven't established the boundaries of the fixed/universal portion of human psychology, and much of it is well known to be a product (through a feedback loop) of social convention...
- pron 11y agoThe issue that is of more concern is not happiness but the distribution of power. When power is distributed unequally, the lives of those with less power are overly controlled by those with more power.