4 ms·
Key quote: Dieters tend to adhere strictly to their diet in the beginning, but quickly begin to revert to old habits, says Hall. By about six months, dieters h
by adrianN 11y ago
Key quote:
Dieters tend to adhere strictly to their diet in the beginning, but quickly begin to revert to old habits, says Hall. By about six months, dieters have often reached their lowest weight but are back to consuming nearly as many calories as they did before they started dieting. From there, they start putting the weight back on
So the dieting works, as long as people stay on the diet. Eating less is still a reliable way to weigh less. The hard part is keeping it up.
- stdbrouw 11y agoIf something is reliable but almost impossible to keep up, I wouldn't exactly say that it "works". That's like saying to a student that they'll pass a course if only they study hard enough, without giving any further study or motivational advice. It's true but it's pointless.
- adrianN 11y agoI just wonder how many research dollars we're going to spend if the advice basically stays: "Eat plenty of fruits and vegetables, don't eat more calories than you expend and do moderate exercise a couple of times a week. If you're overweight you shorten your life."
- greggyb 11y agoProbably until it gets driven home to the type of people who read and comment on studies like this that education alone is one of the worst interventions for behavioral change. Edit: proper emphasis - "that education is" => "that education alone"
- jimrandomh 11y agoNo. The error is more subtle; it's wrong to equate "weight" with "health". Humans are well adapted to protect their health, and if put on a diet which will kill them, they'll usually stop following it. You see that they stopped following their diet, and regained weight. What you don't see is the counterfactual, where if they kept following the diet, they would've developed non-weight-related health problems and possibly died.
- lkiernan 11y agoHumans _were_ well adapted to protect their health. Now they're adapted to eat when it's available and conserve energy if possible. If not on a "diet", are prone to overeating, weight gain and subsequent health problems. And possibly died.
- frankc 11y agoI have a big problem with this line of thinking. It's like saying the key to not having a fever is to keep your temperature down. Maybe you have a high temperature because you just don't have the willpower stop from shaking when you get the chills? Obviously we know that is not the case, but why do we assume that obesity is strictly a willpower issue?
- chrisdbaldwin 11y agoBecause we are being manipulated by multi-billion dollar industries to believe it is a willpower issue. Carbohydrates are broken down into sugar during digestion. Sugar causes a hormone called insulin to be released by the pancreas. Insulin causes the body to store energy as fat. Therefore, carbohydrates cause your body to store fat. It's that simple. Americans are obese because of carbohydrates, not willpower. As someone who never got to know his grandfather because of obesity, I have very little patience for the "calories-in, calories-out" myth. Eat fat.
- kiba 11y agoHumans had largely remained thin rather than fat for most of human history. It's not like we wake up one day and suddenly decided we want to be fat and eat a lot more calories.
- logfromblammo 11y agoOne of the problems we have when talking about diets is that most of the participants assume that people want to lose weight. They don't. They want to feel healthier and lose body fat. I would quite happily be 150 kg if I were a towering slab of raw meat. That likely feels quite a bit better than being even a 130 kg jiggly lump of suet. Never mind that in order to maintain that weight as a meatwall, I'd have to wolf down six whole fried chickens a day and knock down hardwood trees with bare-knuckle punches. Maintaining that weight as a fatblob is as easy as eating some candy and drinking a liter or two of soda pop in front of the TV. As a result, the conversation is too often how to turn a 150kg fatty into a 100kg fatty, rather than turning a 150kg fatty into a 150kg liftbro, and then letting the adiposity problem take care of itself. I don't have a problem with the number on my bathroom scale. My problem is that I don't have action-hero movie-star abs. And maybe also some fear of adiposity-correlated diseases, like diabetes or atherosclerosis. I would rather rearrange my life in such a way that becoming more unhealthy is the thing that requires the constant upkeep of unyielding willpower, rather than the other way around. That's why diets fail. The biochemical feedback loops between gut and brain make it progressively more difficult to lose more fat and not replenish it at the very first opportunity--which is always, because western society is saturated with cheap, calorie-dense foods. The hard part shouldn't be keeping it up; it should be harder to go back. And that requires changing the brain, particularly in the limbic system. Calorie restriction is, to the primitive parts of the brain back behind the prefrontal cortex, a punishment to be avoided. Perhaps exercise equipment that dispenses gratis cocaine whenever you break a previous personal workout record? What could go wrong?~