4 ms·
Thats an opinion you are entitled to have but which I do not share. Politics is the art the possible and sometimes it takes several years for something to gain
by ThomPete 11y ago
Thats an opinion you are entitled to have but which I do not share.
Politics is the art the possible and sometimes it takes several years for something to gain momentum, something that often starts in futile attempts and yes often ends with not succeeding. But once in a blue moon it does and that is the important part.
You keep arguing as if there is a right way to think about these things. If that is your claim then I do not share that belief.
Doing is the only way of discovering.
That there are plenty of people that do obvious stupid things which end bad in hindsight does not cancel out that there are plenty of people who do obvious stupid things and in hindsight succeed.
We have plenty of critical thinkers in this world, it's the constructive thinkers we lack.
- tptacek 11y agoNo. Stop. I'm not telling you to agree with me about Lessig. I'm saying that you can't suppress my critique of Lessig by arguing that criticisms is easy, and starting a doomed Presidential campaign is hard. You know what else is hard? Perpetual motion. I get to criticize people for trying that too.
- ThomPete 11y agoWho is suppressing anything here? Michael_nielsen simply referenced a quote because there was a lot of critique from people who have no stake in lessigs attempt and so I guess Michael felt the urge to point that it's easy to critique and even if people fails, even obviously it's quite a lot more impressive that they even try than the million of reviewers out there. The comment I was referring to, took issue with that quote and as far as I can see TR. And have nothing to do with Lessig. So if you want to stop anything then please stop that strawman. No one is suppressing yours or anyones critique of lessig, but just like you are entitled to have an opinion about him I am entitled to have one about the critique of TRs quote.
- tptacek 11y agoThat's the intent behind the quote upthread you're defending. This part of the thread is getting pretty boring, though.
- ThomPete 11y agoNo it's not an attempt at that. Its simply putting a welcome perspective on things since everyone was busy second guessing without having any stakes. He simply tried to enrich the discussion and IMO did. Claiming someone is trying to suppress your critique, when no one is, now IS the "Peak HN" though :)