4 ms·
A single person can take one action for two different contradictory reasons. How much more so a company of thousands. This neither negates the good reasons nor
by jerf 17y ago
A single person can take one action for two different contradictory reasons. How much more so a company of thousands. This neither negates the good reasons nor washes away the bad ones, but nevertheless, we applaud because we approve of the action.
Besides, look around. How many companies would even pretend to do this for moral reasons? We've legally mandated moral cowardice in our corporations (by mandating that they must increase shareholder value above all else), and to see a company even pay lip service as a reason to something else is refreshing.
(Though if they don't follow through and either provide an uncensored feed or truly leave soon, it will just be lip service.)
Those who still say that Google's hardly an angel here, I refer you to my previous statement about how we've mandated moral cowardice; is it really a surprise that this step could only be taken in addition to other "ulterior motives"? It would be illegal for Google to just pull out of a market because they were offended, and they could face shareholder lawsuits. In the end they must still believe this is a profitable move. (If only to contain losses caused by espionage...) But they have other options, "suck it up" being among them, so there is still at least a smidgen of courage here.