4 ms·
I'm disappointed with the people who are down-voting this comment, as it's, in my opinion, informative and provides a reasonable summation of the differences be
by EdwardDiego 11y ago
I'm disappointed with the people who are down-voting this comment, as it's, in my opinion, informative and provides a reasonable summation of the differences between Kotlin and Scala.
I'd ask people who disagree to put their disagreement into words.
- justthistime_ 11y agoHe has been told by both Scala _AND_ Ceylon language developers that his large walls-of-texts are wrong and are largely made-up stuff which sounds plausible to him. Somehow he feels like he still needs to recycle his nonsense in every thread regardless of how remotely related it is to the topic.
- EdwardDiego 11y agoSo what, in the above "wall of text", is wrong about Scala or Kotlin? You're not telling what was incorrect, just that the author is _always_ incorrect, which strikes me as hyperbole.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- justthistime_ 11y agoSo what, in the above "wall of text", is wrong about Scala or Kotlin? Maybe just check the responses from the last fifteen dozen times? It's not that hard. You're not telling what was incorrect, just that the author is _always_ incorrect, which strikes me as hyperbole. I'm not telling anything. The Scala and Ceylon designers did. They probably know better than me, or him.
- EdwardDiego 11y ago> Maybe just check the responses from the last fifteen dozen times? It's not that hard. So you have no valid criticism of the present statement then? Good to know.
- justthistime_ 11y agoWhat is your problem? No need to be so passive-aggressive. :-) If you don't want to hear it right from the people who should know it best, I can't help you.
- EdwardDiego 11y agoYou're strongly objecting to what he's saying now, but you can't tell me what is incorrect in what he said? Which strongly suggests that you're objecting to the person saying it, not the said.
- justthistime_ 11y agoPlease, take everything he says as a gospel if you can't be bothered to read up on the replies he received the last dozen times. Hint: There is one in this thread.
- dang 11y agoYou've posted dozens of flamewar-style comments about this over the last few days, including many that are bannable offenses, like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10472985 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10472985. This is unacceptable here and we've banned your account. If you don't want it to stay banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com. We're always happy to unban people when they give us reason to believe they'll follow the rules in the future.
- pron 11y agoYou may have accidentally confused the characters. It wasn't me who was told by Scala's designer my facts were wrong (that never happened; well, I'm sure I've got many facts wrong in my lifetime, but Martin Odersky has never called me out on any), but you, and only 3 days ago. Not only did he find you wrong but also rude, and as someone who actually tries to correct a true inaccuracy, he pointed out quite specifically (though very politely) what you got wrong[1] rather than just yelling FUD as some other people do whenever someone voices an opinion they don't like to hear. BTW, I can attest to modersky's statement, as I personally witnessed him and Andrey Breslav talking and exchanging ideas on more than one occasion. As to gavinking, well, he and I have rarely seen eye to eye, but he, too, hasn't pointed to a factual error on my part. Now, you can make an original contribution to this discussion or not, but you should stop with the personal attacks. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10480284 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10480284
- justthistime__ 11y agoAs the Scala tech lead, I'm glad to learn we've finally adopted "almost every new PL concept!" I guess by now everyone will recognize your username and adjust for bias accordingly, but still, how about sticking to the facts?
- pron 11y agoSigh. No wrong facts. He (not the language's designer, BTW) just didn't like my use of (obvious) hyperbole. In any case, I really suggest you drop this. I am not an enemy of Scala. Unlike adriaanm's assertion (and that is a false statement of fact), I am not even biased against it. I was an early enthusiast, I gave it a very serious try, and I just really didn't like it. Yes, I think it is not a good language for use by the industry. I am not uninformed, I am not wrong, I have just reached different conclusions from you. So what? I, like many others, just don't like the language, and we all have very valid reasons to, just as those who do like it have their own equally valid reasons. Do you know how many people don't like the languages I like? You know how many of them find those languages unfit for use by the industry? And many of them are much more hostile in their objections than I've ever been. However, they, too, have very good reasons not to like them, while I have very good reasons of my own. If you go on a personal attack against anyone who doesn't like the things you like, it won't serve your goals in the least. In any case, I don't mind arguing over language design (politely!) with you or anyone else, and I realize full well (as should you) that it can sometimes be a very personal preference with no wrong or right answers -- just many opinions, many of them valid -- but please keep to the subject and be original.
- karl_shareef 11y agoIt's just the regular Scala brigade that stalks and attacks anyone who dares criticize Scala, regardless of the content of the criticism. They seem to have become extra sensitive with the recent momentum that Kotlin has been gaining. If you were wondering why the Scala community has such a bad reputation, it's because of people like them. Just ignore them. Fortunately, not all Scala users are like them.
- justthistime_ 11y agoYes, it's aaaaaaalways the other people! :-) Oh, wait, it isn't: By the way, pron, as more general complaint, your comments about Ceylon are always very uninformed, but you state them as fact. How about you actually spend some time learning the language first before commenting any more about it here or on reddit. Because it really wastes my time and raises my stress level having to correct your - probably unintentional - FUD. It's clear that you don't know Ceylon, so please stop telling everyone else stuff that you're just guessing at. OTOH, if you want to get answers to any questions you might have you are extremely welcome to come on our Gitter channel and ask them, and I promise we're always very patient about explaining stuff there. I make that offer in complete sincerity.
- pron 11y agoCan you make a contribution besides booing from the sidelines? It just so happens that gavinking misunderstood my statements, and then it turned out that we were in agreement all along (at least about the facts), and NONE of my statements about Ceylon turned out to be wrong in that discussion. If you believe I'm wrong about something -- please state what it is that you think I got wrong (preferably without being rude). Because you have never done so, and when gavinking did, it turned out he had simply misinterpreted my comments, so you're second-hand quoting from argument that was nothing more than a misunderstanding. Your personal attacks on me are ridiculous and unfounded and have no place here on HN. I'll ask again, have I done anything to offend you that you feel the need to so blatantly violate HN's code-of-conduct?
- dang 11y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10493049 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10493049 and marked it off-topic.