3 ms·
The theory of multiple intelligence you link to is in strong disagreement with the mainstream position of academia. > Intelligence tests and psychometrics have
by jessriedel 11y ago
The theory of multiple intelligence you link to is in strong disagreement with the mainstream position of academia.
> Intelligence tests and psychometrics have generally found high correlations between different aspects of intelligence, rather than the low correlations which Gardner's theory predicts, supporting the prevailing theory of general intelligence rather than multiple intelligences (MI).[19] The theory has been widely criticized by mainstream psychology for its lack of empirical evidence, and its dependence on subjective judgement.[20]
- drumdance 11y agoHas anyone looked at how these studies correlate with the Big Five personality traits? It seems to me that intelligent people are more conscientious but that could just be my bias.
- moyix 11y agoSome quick Googling turns up: http://www.drtomascp.com/uploads/PersonalityIntelligence_IJSA_2005.pdf http://www.drtomascp.com/uploads/PersonalityIntelligence_IJS... Which seems to provide some (weak) evidence against that: "The hypothesis of a significant correlation between various Big Five personality traits and intelligence test scores was only partially supported. Only Conscientiousness was significantly related to psychometric intelligence, correlating with BRT scores. It is worth noting that the correlation was negative, indicating that higher conscientious participants tended to have lower gf." I'm far from an expert though, so I can't say how good that study is.
- DonaldFisk 11y agoIQ tests only measure a few factors, which may well be quite closely correlated. But I don't think everyone who does well in IQ tests has good social skills, is good at painting, playing a musical instrument, speaking a foreign language, playing football, or juggling (or could become good at them with sufficient practice). You could argue that these have nothing to do with intelligence, but they're clearly cognitive skills.
- jessriedel 11y agoPlaying a musical instrument, speaking a foreign language, and social skills, are definitely strongly correlated with IQ-loaded tests like the SAT. Yep. I have no idea how football fairs, but you can debate the usefulness of that as an objection to the validity of IQ with someone else.