3 ms·
Your extreme example is only going to be backwards for a few months, then the surgeon's proper net worth is going to pull ahead. So I'm not sure that's really w
by mikeash 11y ago
Your extreme example is only going to be backwards for a few months, then the surgeon's proper net worth is going to pull ahead. So I'm not sure that's really worth considering too much.
The fact that not everybody can go get an $800,000 mortgage is pretty much accounted for by the fact that you have to put down some sort of down payment, which translates into equity in the house. If you have an $800,000 mortgage then the purchase price for the house was probably $1 million or more, and if the value has held then that's at least $200,000 in net worth.
It's true that the owner stands to profit from any gains the price sees in the real estate market, but they also stand to suffer from any losses.
It really just makes no sense to count a house's value but not the (negative) value of the mortgage on it. For an extreme case in the other direction, someone with a $1 million house that has a $1 million mortgage on it (because, for example, they bought at a higher price and then prices fell) and who can barely afford their payments (perhaps because they took part in mortgage fraud, or just lost their job) should not be counted as wealthier than somebody with a $100,000 house and no debt.
Fortunately, it looks like the actual study does count debt and the wording in the article was just horrible.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]