3 ms·
Wealth means power. Let's take an extreme case: every person in the world has their wealth increased by 10% over what they have today, except for one person wh
by mikeash 11y ago
Wealth means power.
Let's take an extreme case: every person in the world has their wealth increased by 10% over what they have today, except for one person who has his wealth increased by $1 quadrillion.
Everybody is better off, right? Except that wealthy person is going to rule the world, and stack the deck to help himself, and there's nothing that says he's only going to do it in such a way that everybody else keeps increasing their wealth too, or even keeps their wealth at all.
We can see this at work in the US where the political process has become pretty corrupted, to the point that half the politicians act like wealthy people in the US suffer under a tremendously high tax burden when they actually pay less as a percentage than the average person, and the other half pays lip service to getting the wealthy to pay more but only proposes weak measures that never go anywhere, and where systematic lawbreaking in the financial sector that led to a gigantic financial crises went completely unpunished, except for the one guy who made the mistake of ripping off wealthy people.
- dollar 11y agoI agree, wealth and power are closely related right now. But why? We could focus our energies on the distribution of power instead of the distribution of wealth. We could create a world where power and wealth were not so closely correlated. Arguably, our original constitutional government was a lot closer to that than we are today. That was when we had apportionment of 1:100000 in the U.S. House. That was when State governments elected their senators. That was when it was assumed that any State could withdraw from the Union, that any county could withdraw from a State. It was before a massive, centralized federal government.
- mikeash 11y agoWealth is ultimately the codification of power. A dollar is the representation of the power to get somebody else to give you a dollar's worth of value, or do a dollar's worth of stuff for you. They are not perfectly linked, but I think they tend to come together. If someone has a lot of economic power, which they can use to get a bunch of people to give them things or do things for them, that's an avenue to political power. If someone has a lot of political power, they can leverage that to get economic power. Your statement about how the original US government was closer to this than today doesn't sound right to me. Weren't only people^H^H^H^H^H^men^H^H^Hwhite men who owned land allowed to vote?
- icefox 11y agoOf course you have also have many billionaires that contribute to the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.
- mikeash 11y agoMany powerful people use their power for good, but that doesn't make me want them to rule the world.