3 ms·
> The report defines wealth as the value of assets including property and stock market investments, but excludes debt. How does this make the slightest bit of
by mikeash 11y ago
> The report defines wealth as the value of assets including property and stock market investments, but excludes debt.
How does this make the slightest bit of sense? Counting property but ignoring debt is going to exaggerate the wealth of many Americans by an order of magnitude, for example. Beyond that, one person's debt is another person's investment, so you're double counting all that money.
- refurb 11y agoGood catch. So if I "own" a $1M house, but have a $800K mortgage, they ignore the debt and say that I have $1M in wealth? Ridiculous.
- nilkn 11y agoEven if that's their methodology, I don't think it's that ridiculous. It's not like just anyone can go get an $800k mortgage. On top of that, you would stand to personally profit on any gains the home might see in the real estate market. To offer a slightly extreme example, I'd consider a recently minted surgeon with $300k in loans, a mortgage, and a $500k base salary to be considerably wealthier than the debt-free small-town auto mechanic making $35k.
- mikeash 11y agoYour extreme example is only going to be backwards for a few months, then the surgeon's proper net worth is going to pull ahead. So I'm not sure that's really worth considering too much. The fact that not everybody can go get an $800,000 mortgage is pretty much accounted for by the fact that you have to put down some sort of down payment, which translates into equity in the house. If you have an $800,000 mortgage then the purchase price for the house was probably $1 million or more, and if the value has held then that's at least $200,000 in net worth. It's true that the owner stands to profit from any gains the price sees in the real estate market, but they also stand to suffer from any losses. It really just makes no sense to count a house's value but not the (negative) value of the mortgage on it. For an extreme case in the other direction, someone with a $1 million house that has a $1 million mortgage on it (because, for example, they bought at a higher price and then prices fell) and who can barely afford their payments (perhaps because they took part in mortgage fraud, or just lost their job) should not be counted as wealthier than somebody with a $100,000 house and no debt. Fortunately, it looks like the actual study does count debt and the wording in the article was just horrible.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- alextgordon 11y ago> To offer a slightly extreme example, I'd consider a recently minted surgeon with $300k in loans, a mortgage, and a $500k base salary to be considerably wealthier than the debt-free small-town auto mechanic making $35k. Is this your perception or is it reality? If your hypothetical surgeon overleverages himself to the point where he has less on paper than the auto mechanic, his financial position sounds very brittle. What if there is a large unexpected expense? Like $50k to clean up a mercury spill...
- nilkn 11y agoIt's reality. The surgeon's monthly gross paychecks will exceed the entire gross annual income of the auto mechanic. I actually crunched some numbers so you can see exactly what I mean. The surgeon's going to make about $26,000 per month after taxes in Texas (picked somewhat arbitrarily as that's where I live). They're going to pay about $3400/month in loans. And if they got an $800k mortgage, their mortgage payment is going to be something like $4800/month. Net income: $17800 (i.e., almost 4x their mortgage payment). Now for the mechanic. Net income: $2400/month. Let's say he gets a $100k home. His payment is about $540/month. So he's got $1860/month left over (i.e., about 3.4 times his mortgage payment). He's actually less equipped to handle any sort of financial duress than the surgeon, all while living a much more constrained and frugal lifestyle and occupying a house with literally one tenth of the value. The mechanic's situation is actually vastly more brittle than the surgeon's, as on top of all of this the surgeon also has drastically better job security. Now, sure, you can cook up an example where the surgeon is stretched too thin (e.g., $3-4M home instead of a $1M home, or a collection of exotic sports cars, etc.). However, the fact that the surgeon was even capable of making those unwise purchases in the first place means that they cannot be lumped into the same financial category as the mechanic.
- gphil 11y agoI think they mean they are subtracting debt, though I agree that isn't clear.
- breischl 11y agoI think the Guardian article meant that they had subtracted debt from assets, but they stated it in a confusing way. The original report states: Once debts have been subtracted, a person needs only USD 3,210 to be among the wealthiest half of world citizens in mid-2015. However, USD 68,800 is required to be a member of the top 10% of global wealth holders, and USD 759,900 to belong to the top 1%. Which is more clearly stated and uses the same numbers as the Guardian article. See page 11 from: https://publications.credit-suisse.com/tasks/render/file/?fileID=F2425415-DCA7-80B8-EAD989AF9341D47E https://publications.credit-suisse.com/tasks/render/file/?fi...
- mikeash 11y agoYes, I believe you're correct. Holy crap is that a terrible way to put it. I wouldn't call "excluding debt" confusing, but just outright wrong. Unless this is one of those dialect things that means something different to the Brits?
- gjm11 11y agoBrit here. I wouldn't read "... but excludes debt" as meaning "... but subtracts debt from people's wealth when doing statistics", no. I'd guess I'm about as surprised to see it being used that way as an otherwise-similar non-Brit.
- gozo 11y agoMore of an accounting/finance thing, similar to how net price is price excluding tax, net wealth is wealth (assets) excluding debt (loans/liabilities).
- mikeash 11y agoI'm not sure if that helps, because here in the US "price" is by default listed before taxes! I would read "net price is price excluding tax" as "net price is price, ignoring taxes," and thus "net wealth is wealth, ignoring debt."
- lumberjack 11y agoIt makes a lot of sense actually. Poor people are not allowed to go into all that much debt. If you have somebody who is $2M in debt, chances are they are wealthy and were only allowed to accumulate all that much debt because of their influence and reputation or some other kind of leverage. The average graduate who is $40K to $50K is not actually poorer than the homeless beggar who is in the green. They don't live as poor of a life and they have the potential to earn for more.
- mikeash 11y agoI'd say that's an argument for counting (discounted) future earnings as part of current wealth, but not for ignoring debt. Sure, that student isn't poorer than a beggar. But they are poorer than their classmate who has the same degree, same skills, and same financial situation in all other respects, but has no debt. Somebody with a $500,000 house and a $400,000 mortgage and no savings isn't five times wealthier than somebody living an apartment with $100,000 in savings.