3 ms·
I understand where the author is coming from - high speed serial transceivers really have undermined our traditional concept of a "machine". And in the uniform
by mindslight 11y ago
I understand where the author is coming from - high speed serial transceivers really have undermined our traditional concept of a "machine". And in the uniform administrative domain of a data center, hardware refactorings are straightforward. So it's pretty nifty to think about these changes to fundamental constants (although the continual rewriting of software systems because they're not abstracted enough to treat it all as one cache hierarchy is disheartening).
But when moving across administrative boundaries, especially to a more ad-hoc environment, serious problems crop up. Some assumptions the author is handwaving away:
1. That 2ms to Youtube is to a single specific Youtube cache. If you're about to get on a plane, are you supposed to inform Google so that they can move your files across the country?
2. "The network is reliable" - what do you do while you're on that plane? DSL is still our national infrastructure policy so in many places that is the best that is available, especially if you want a choice of providers to avoid anti-consumer behavior.
2a. Or wifi. What is the latency of modern best-of-class consumer gear? I'm getting 16ms with a simple TL-WR703N. Never mind mobile...
3. Access patterns being so long-tail points to the continuing utility of end-user SSDs as non-volatile cache. The devices that would be most likely to drop them (cost, space, power) are generally on the worst network links.
4. The datacenter containing the notion of what data is authoritative (otherwise you wouldn't need to hit it for every access as outlined). What is the need for this?
5. The overhead of implementing oblivious transfer (or the alternative of being surveilled and having decreased economic power and freedom).
When you think in terms of datacenters, it's tempting to think that the next advancement is end-user computers becoming part of that system, but that is a skewed perspective. The pendulum swings back and forth, and I think we're pretty close to Peak Butt. The next deluge will be user-centric software that utilizes the butt for its strengths, but respects privacy and tracks the authoritative copy on user owned machines.