4 ms·
> Minimum parking requirements On the flipside, if you have friends who aren't right next door (or perhaps who once were and you don't want to write them off b
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
> Minimum parking requirements
On the flipside, if you have friends who aren't right next door (or perhaps who once were and you don't want to write them off because they moved), it helps to have the ability to drive to their place. I'm not arguing for "car first", but I don't think "pedestrian first" makes sense either. Most of my friends are scattered around a 20-minute radius.
(And quite frankly, you can choose your friends but you can't really choose your neighbors.)
> anti-density zoning laws
I'd have less problem with dense housing (especially since I don't actually care about the stereotypical "yard and a white picket fence") if said housing started including -90dB or better soundproofing.
- krasin 11y ago>I'd have less problem with dense housing (especially since I don't actually care about the stereotypical "yard and a white picket fence") if said housing started including -90dB or better soundproofing. Yep. Instead of having a thousand of single-family houses, I would rather have a beautiful 30+ stories castle surrounded by a park of ~1 km radius. Cars are expected to live underground and reach the surface outside of the park. Saying that as I have lived a few years in a very similar setting, while being at a university: http://cdn.absolutevisit.com/blog/photo-of-the-day/100075/Moscow-State-University-Reflection-Moscow-Russia.jpg http://cdn.absolutevisit.com/blog/photo-of-the-day/100075/Mo...
- zyxley 11y ago> a beautiful 30+ stories castle surrounded by a park of ~1 km radius The problem with this is that you're basically getting the worst of both worlds. You lose many of the real benefits of dense development because there's no space for jobs and shopping, and you lose the benefits of privately kept land like customized yards and broken-up sightlines and so on. The "giant building separated from everything else by a giant moat of grass" style also has a long, ugly history in public housing developments, with it meant as idealistic but ultimately turning to crap.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoExactly. One of the things that urban planning sometimes gets right and sometimes gets wrong, and that suburban planning is just barely starting to figure out in experiments, is that residential and commercial should be relatively closely interspersed, not separated.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- krasin 11y agoSome basic services and shopping are included into the first few floors. For something more fancy, it's ok to drive. As for being disconnected, it's usually quite opposite, if your friends live in the same building: you're 5-10 minutes away from them. Again, speaking from the personal experience, not dreams. Map: https://goo.gl/maps/g7bEBsoqwkL2 https://goo.gl/maps/g7bEBsoqwkL2
- ido 11y agoYes, as a college student it is possible all your friends (or a lot of them) will live in that one huge building. But as time passes people move around (even within the same city) for jobs, family, and lots of other reasons & suddenly all your friends don't all live in the same huge building.
- krasin 11y agoIn this case, these friends are not farther than in usual case of a low-density suburban. You will have to drive, but not longer than if you lived in a single family house, as the building + park in the proposal above takes about the same space as 1000 single-family houses. So, it makes the friends more accessible, if they are in the same neighborhood, and not less accessible otherwise. Also, living in the same building actually helps to find new friends, especially if there's enough shared space indoors/outdoors, such as cafes, gyms, hacker spaces, etc.
- meric 11y agoLike this? http://owner.estate/realestate/view/70967 http://owner.estate/realestate/view/70967 Or this? http://owner.estate/realestate/view/101203 http://owner.estate/realestate/view/101203
- krasin 11y agoMy proposal already includes a photo; I am not sure how are the human apiaries with no living outdoor space related to it.
- TulliusCicero 11y ago> On the flipside, if you have friends who aren't right next door (or perhaps who once were and you don't want to write them off because they moved), it helps to have the ability to drive to their place. I'm not arguing for "car first", but I don't think "pedestrian first" makes sense either. Most of my friends are scattered around a 20-minute radius. A good transportation policy takes all major modes seriously. If you look at a biketopia like the Netherlands, they still drive as much as they bike. Nobody wants to completely get rid of cars, transportation nerds like myself just want the different modes to be on an even playing field, rather than cars being always hyper-dominant like they usually have been in the US. I expect to continue to own a car for a long time. Also note that, assuming everything transformed overnight into an urbanist's paradise, that 20 minute radius would shrink considerably, and many of your friends would be reachable by bike. I'm paraphrasing a quote I heard before: "Car-first planning creates distance that only cars can solve." > I'd have less problem with dense housing (especially since I don't actually care about the stereotypical "yard and a white picket fence") if said housing started including -90dB or better soundproofing. Agreed. This is one regulation that I am all for.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> Nobody wants to completely get rid of cars, I've seen far too many people argue viciously for exactly that. > transportation nerds like myself just want the different modes to be on an even playing field, rather than cars being always hyper-dominant like they usually have been in the US. Agreed.
- TulliusCicero 11y ago> I've seen far too many people argue viciously for exactly that. Even on an aggressively pro-bike blog like BikePortland, this kind of opinion is an extreme minority. There are urbanists who really despise cars, or at least despise cars in urban areas, but they're just a vocal fringe. Most want more equalized resources and care for walking, biking, and transit, and they want each mode prioritized for an area in a way that makes sense based on each mode's attributes (e.g. cars should be prioritized for freeways between cities, denser modes prioritized in expensive urban cores).