5 ms·
The smugness I see almost always comes from the skeptic/denier crowd, who just love to talk about how stupid people who believe in global warming are and how ob
by mikeash 11y ago
The smugness I see almost always comes from the skeptic/denier crowd, who just love to talk about how stupid people who believe in global warming are and how obvious it is that the whole thing is a hoax because of the global warming hiatus, or volcanoes, or because it snowed on Tuesday, or whatever.
If objectivity is lacking, it is lacking almost exclusively because certain right-wing groups took a scientific issue, turned it into a political issue, and set their politics to oppose the science.
Certainly, there exist fanatic, non-objective people on both sides. But they're not exactly common, and it gets tedious to see comments like yours in every discussion about this issue, and almost always directed at the reasonable people who actually look at the facts, and not at the the people who think climate change isn't science, who think that increased ice mass must be evidence against global warming regardless of the reason for it, or who think global temperatures stopped rising in 1998.
- merpnderp 11y agoWe have different experiences. I usually see the skeptic crowd talking about the science and the believer crowd talking about how fanatical the skeptics are. But you seem a reasonable person. Maybe you could help me understand the last 20 years of the UAH 6.0 data and the RSS data which matches it within +-.2C?
- mikeash 11y agoI'm not terribly familiar with these things, but they look like fairly straightforward temperature data. What is there to understand?
- merpnderp 11y agoBetween the two of them, they are the entirety of the satellite global atmospheric temperature data sets. If you run a linear regression on the TLT (total lower tropospheric) data from 1997 to current, you'll get a zero trend. If you allow for their level of confidence, you get a zero trend from 1994. These are two separate organizations, who's data (with UAH's 6.0 update) is within .2C of each other. UAH is University of Alabama in Huntsville in partnership with NASA. RSS is a private atmospheric research company. Both their data sets start in 1979. Without discounting their data, what theory of anthropogenic global warming accounts for this length of no warming during the period where 1/3rd of all man made CO2 was released into the atmosphere? I'm extremely curious and have had no luck getting an answer anywhere. The data is easy to find, but I can link it if you want to run it yourself. The UAH 6.0 data is still in Beta, but NASA started accounting for loss of orbit and are working on an updated record.
- mikeash 11y agoI'm not familiar enough with the data to say what the explanation might be. These folks are, though: http://www.le-telegraphe.ch/docus/warming.pdf http://www.le-telegraphe.ch/docus/warming.pdf So if you're interested in the latest, reading that is probably a good start. It looks to me like there's a lot more than just satellite data to examine.
- merpnderp 11y agoThat study has not been well received in the climate change community. HADCRUT4 is already the de facto standard for land/sea based climate stations/buoys, and this does some questionable things with sea water and the land stations. And the HADCRUT4 people wave off the satellite data with "they don't adjust for satellite drift or sensor degradation", but that's all NASA/UAH and RSS do with the data. But even so, their data shows a pause going back 13 years. And this is exactly what I find everywhere when looking for info about the satellite data. Not an explanation of what it means, but attacks on its veracity. Which goes back to my original point or attacking the questioner instead of explaining what the satellite data means. Personally I find it hard to believe that a mishmash of thousands of types of land based weather stations, in thousands of different microclimates and variable conditions, could possible be superior to simply measuring the total energy released by a slice of 75% of the atmosphere.
- mikeash 11y agoI sure hope you're not referring to my posts when you talk about "attacks," because "I don't really know but here's a paper that looks good" is about as far from that as you can get.
- merpnderp 11y agoAbsolutely not. Sorry for the confusion. I just can't find any papers on why the satellite data is wrong other than hand waving about how peer reviewed research into bias correction is wrong. And I also can't find anything explaining what the satellite data means. That NOAA paper you linked has some interesting issues. But even if it is correct (it's probably not), it shows a low sensitivity to CO2.