4 ms·
> it was known by the British navy that lime juice prescribed to sailors on long voyages prevented scurvy. Lemon juice. They switched to limes in the 1860s.
by EdwardDiego 11y ago
> it was known by the British navy that lime juice prescribed to sailors on long voyages prevented scurvy.
Lemon juice. They switched to limes in the 1860s.
http://idlewords.com/2010/03/scott_and_scurvy.htm http://idlewords.com/2010/03/scott_and_scurvy.htm
> So when the Admiralty began to replace lemon juice with an ineffective substitute in 1860, it took a long time for anyone to notice. In that year, naval authorities switched procurement from Mediterranean lemons to West Indian limes. The motives for this were mainly colonial - it was better to buy from British plantations than to continue importing lemons from Europe. Confusion in naming didn't help matters. Both "lemon" and "lime" were in use as a collective term for citrus, and though European lemons and sour limes are quite different fruits, their Latin names (citrus medica, var. limonica and citrus medica, var. acida) suggested that they were as closely related as green and red apples. Moreover, as there was a widespread belief that the antiscorbutic properties of lemons were due to their acidity, it made sense that the more acidic Caribbean limes would be even better at fighting the disease.
- wtallis 11y agoSo in actuality, they never failed to correctly determine the scurvy-preventing capability of a given fruit when they tested it, they just spent a lot of time working under the un-tested and incorrect assumption that lemons and limes would work similarly, based on an un-tested hypothesis for the mechanism of scurvy prevention.
- Twisell 11y agoWell actually it's more that they fail to take account of a missing parameter. And there is quite a lot of missing parameters in actual climatology. It's not like we are in Back to the Future's 2015 where they can accurately forecast weather.