2 ms·
Right, but "they are more successful because they made better decisions" is tautological.
by gaius 11y ago
Right, but "they are more successful because they made better decisions" is tautological.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoA kind of troll-like remark that offers no counter-points or further information. I'll reply to it anyway. Here's the specifics I gave that they could've applied at the start or later on: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10486120 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10486120 Note the quote from the head of the project who confessed to the specific mistake. That's not tautological at all: it's what 5-10 seconds of Google would've earned you. It also matched the first idea that came to my head about where I would've started at the time. Linus and Tannenbaum both started with Minix codebase, one indirectly and one directly, to achieve success. So, Hurd was just Doing It Wrong. Further, that starting with a poor architecture or not building off a good codebase often leads to failure are proven heuristics.
- gaius 11y agoYes I suppose you could consider better decisions leading to better outcomes to be "problematic". Much more convenient to ascribe it to more funding i.e. privilege. Now who's trolling?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoHard to imagine a better outcome when Hurd still hasn't achieved original goals, is worse than small monoliths, is behind many microkernels, and its own author said doing BSD instead would've been "ideal." More like worst outcome one can get.