4 ms·
I have one word. Technology. Think about technology as outsourcing and you realize what the problem is because you are realizing the trend; Technology will com
by ThomPete 11y ago
I have one word. Technology.
Think about technology as outsourcing and you realize what the problem is because you are realizing the trend; Technology will compete with higher and higher levels of abstraction and so you either have to be really skilled in an increasingly competitive space or you need to accept taking jobs at wages that are as low as they are because of the increased competition from technology.
And until economist stop treating technology as an externality they wont understand whats going on and we will keep debating this as if its a political problem. In my opinion its not.
http://www.technologyreview.com/sites/default/files/images/destroying.jobs_.chart1x910_0.jpg http://www.technologyreview.com/sites/default/files/images/d...
- collyw 11y agoWe have had continous improveents in technology up to the recession.
- ThomPete 11y agoJob creation in the US have gone down decade after decade since WWII. https://plot.ly/~BethS/8/job-growth-by-decade-in-the-united-states/ https://plot.ly/~BethS/8/job-growth-by-decade-in-the-united-... There comes a point where technology starts to compete not just with our muscle but with our brains. And even though there of course are going to be some jobs you can make a living off. Digitalization and automation is disrupting at an ever increasing speed. You need to look at the trend not the current scenario to understand this.
- msellout 11y agoNot sure why you think economists treat technology as externality. I've seen many macroeconomic models that specifically are attempting to model change in technology.
- ThomPete 11y agoBecause they mostly do. Especially the economist that advice countries. And you can see it on the way they basically forecast and use various tools to stimulate the economy. You would see far more politicians propose a Unconditional Basic Income solution if technology were factored into the models regardless of whether you think UBI works or not. Problem is that technology is now moving at a pace where it will eat up most attempt to stimulate the economy whether it's Keyness philosophy or Austerity philosophy.
- gaius 11y agoYes but there's no evidence that links higher technology to greater productivity. All the accountants who were automated out of existence by COBOL programs, simply became COBOL programmers, and the net amount of accounting done per person involved didn't change!
- ThomPete 11y agoThats the wrong way of looking at it. The point isn't just whether it leads to higher productivity the point is that it removes the need for certain industries almost completely. Just think about the amount of areas that digitalization have completely removed. Those are jobs lost that aren't created somewhere else in the same phase as it's destroying them. And most of those jobs are being outsourced. With regards to your cobol example I would like to see where you get that idea from. There is a huge demand of cobol programmers today because of all the old financial/banking systems which no one really dares touching. So that's an unlikely claim.
- gaius 11y agoSuch as what? Things are done because they need doing, i.e. there is demand for them to be done, whether they are digital or analogue won't change that. Outsourcing is a better explanation of what's happening. The demand for COBOL programmers proves my point. Computers didn't eliminate those jobs. They just transformed them. So where a company might have employed 100 accountants to do their accounting, now they employ 50 accountants and 50 programmers or 10 accountants and 90 programmers... Anyone who could do one job could probably pick up the other.
- ThomPete 11y agoOutsourcing is just the step before automation. The US lost 4 million jobs to China between 98-2004 in the same period the Chinese lost 18 million jobs to the robots. This trend isn't stopping, instead it will only continue faster and faster. The tings that digitalization kills are things like the camera, the walkman, the video-recorder, the video-camera, the post-processing machines, instruments, the studio musician and I could go on. These aren't jobs that then are created somewhere else. In most of the cases where new industries or new areas are made they either require extremely highly specialized education or they are very hard for most people to make any money in. The app store being a good example. Your Cobol example isn't proving anything at all and your claim was wrong to begin with. You claimed accountants just became cobol developers which is simply a false claim. And the reason why there is a need for cobol isn't because of a new demand but because of a dwindling availability of an existing demand which is also going down until a new technology makes that completely redundant.