30 ms·
Those are all valid reasons, but they are not the reason I first started to block ads: • They impose a surprisingly huge cognitive load. Even if you (like mos
by teddyh 11y ago
Those are all valid reasons, but they are not the reason I first started to block ads:
• They impose a surprisingly huge cognitive load.
Even if you (like most people nowadays) are used to them and hence “do not notice them”, that very habit of ignoring them actually takes more brain power than you’d think.
- johnchristopher 11y agoI'd be okay with ads on the web if it looked like newspaper or magazine ads (and with the associated cognitive load). But not auto-play videos that pops up in the middle of the article or blinking GIFs on the side.
- xorcist 11y agoThat's true! I stopped watching TV somewhere around the high school age, which means I react to it just like small children do: if I'm trying to have a meeting where there's a TV running I turn into almost a drooling idiot. My brain is simply not conditioned to flashing colors and quick cuts that aren't important. It requires practice to read a text bylined with blinking animations, and I simply don't have the cognitive power to do that. Most people that cope with it probably doesn't realize how much practice they've had.
- yomism 11y agoAnd everybody knows that if you deplete your brain power before going to sleep your brain explodes... On a serious note, your brain will be ok, it is a fine pattern matching machines with adaptative filters to discard uninteresting data (did you notice that sound of blood heartbeating in your ears?... that's filtering doing its work). And also visually our brain is very good at ignoring data, search for the gorilla suit experiment.
- teddyh 11y agoStraw man. I did not say that using brain power is inherently bad. What I maybe should have said is that I prefer to use all my brain power on reading the article and pondering its implications rather than (unconsciously) wasting much of it on ignoring distracting ads.
- enimodas 11y agoIt doesn't explode, but it does get tired. http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/tough-choices-how-making/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/tough-choices-how-...
- BogusIKnow 11y agoNot reading them is the same as blocking them. To gain moral high ground people who compare adblocking to theft are required to read every ad on every website they encounter. The moral distinction between "I do not read ads" and "I block ads" is an illusion.
- BogusIKnow 11y agoI wish people would vote down stuff that is not relevant instead of stuff they disagree with.
- JupiterMoon 11y agoThis does not take into account the security aspect. With the modern world being what it is one should be careful the code running on one's systems is from trusted sources. Adverts on the modern web violate this principle.
- cpeterso 11y ago> The moral distinction between "I do not read ads" and "I block ads" is an illusion. Do not some ad networks pay content providers for "impressions", regardless of whether the ads are clicked? In that case, loading the ads without reading them is not the same as not loading them.
- BogusIKnow 11y agoMy prediction for the future: Ad blockers will load ads but not display them as more and more websites will block visitors who block them.
- jordanpg 11y agoI would take this a step further. I perceive the effects of advertising in most cases to be toxic and nefarious. Trying to convince me to buy or do something that I didn't already want or need is an unfortunate byproduct of capitalism. I avoid ads because I absolutely do not want their influence looming over me. We -- the technologists behind it -- should be anxious to help humanity get past this embarrassing chapter in our development and find another way to make the economic wheels turn.