4 ms·
To be poor - to really be poor - is to live under the constant stress of unexpected payments and unexpected interruptions in your ability to pay the bills you s
by whatshisface 11y ago
To be poor - to really be poor - is to live under the constant stress of unexpected payments and unexpected interruptions in your ability to pay the bills you see comming. To be poor is to have to really think about every small purchase, every half mile driven. Living from paycheck to three days before the next paycheck is not a pain that can be pacified with distraction. (Those people buried in their smartphones aren't reading the Wikipedia page on Haskell...)
Have you ever seen the interest on a payday loan? What situation would someone have to be in to make that a good idea? Surely, if the internet could help people that much, nobody would go for it.
I've seen both - you are confusing poor with idle.
- vinceguidry 11y agoThe calculated interest rate on payday loans is misleading. Poor people don't think of it that way. When they borrow $300 for a short-term loan and have to pay $30 for the privilege, they're making a rational decision that the $30 later isn't worth as much as the $300 now. There's a recent article on the payday loan industry that confirmed my hunch that the people using them aren't total imbeciles and know what they're doing. I use credit as a management tool, it gives me options I wouldn't have otherwise. Payday loans are the same, they're just more expensive. I would still use credit if it were more expensive, up to a point where it would be more advantageous to just change the way I perceive money. Also payday loans are only available to a certain class of the working poor. People with temp jobs or other kinds of inconsistent income can't avail themselves of this kind of credit. They get a lot of press but are really just a niche in the vast constellation of services, both legal and illegal, legible and illegible, that sustain the poor. I used to use a payday loan business to cash my paychecks when I couldn't get a bank account. The experience struck me as benignly capitalistic, you don't really want to be in the position of having to use these services, but having access to them is way better than the alternative. > every half mile driven Poor people here aren't that constrained, mostly because gas is and will probably forever be really cheap. In other countries that aren't oil-states gas is an order of magnitude more expensive. Keeping gas costs down is a priority, but not as big of one as meeting housing costs. Housing is the biggest expense most Americans, not just the poor ones, have to contend with. Transportation in comparison is treated as a cost of doing business. > Living from paycheck to three days before the next paycheck is not a pain that can be pacified with distraction. What poor people do on their phones constantly is cultivate the relationships that sustain them. It is not a distraction the way we think of playing silly games. They are texting, facebooking, even their game playing is done with their friends / family. Poor people are way more social than the middle / upper class could ever be, because they have to.
- SolaceQuantum 11y agoBeing poor is actually not something that can be coped with through consistent social behavior. The chronic stress that defines the experience of poverty have lasting effects on a brain.
- vinceguidry 11y agoDepends on what you mean by coping. I was poor, I managed to escape it. The brain effects studied, in my experience, aren't a life sentence fundamentally destroying your ability to survive and be happy. It's absolutely relative, having a $60K a year salary is going to be much better than $30K inconsistent. But it's not like you can't carve out a fulfilling existence with limited resources. I believe that's a way more damaging belief about the poor than the (wrong) belief that the poor are only poor because they are inherently incapable of being rich. Which is how I see people interpreting those recent research results.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoThe poor are poor at least in part because they're prevented from being rich by a combination of poor education, media distraction, and lack of access to working capital. A few individuals can always break out of the ghetto. But the ghetto is a human trash heap - the graveyard of much raw talent and potential collective prosperity. It really shouldn't exist in the first place.
- drumdance 11y ago$30k is not poor. Most definitions of poverty are $28k for a family of four.
- enraged_camel 11y agoPoverty also has significant negative effects on the physical, mental and social development of children.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>Poor people don't think of it that way. When they borrow $300 for a short-term loan and have to pay $30 for the privilege, they're making a rational decision that the $30 later isn't worth as much as the $300 now. They're not making a rational decision. It's an amygdala based decision. The same part of your brain that deals with panic, fight / flight, etc. The resource constraints they are under make it impossible to think long term the same way that you stop thinking about your pension plan when you're running away from a bear. This is why it's such a profitable business (non-rational decisions -> profit), and why, when you take payday loans away, poor people actually end up better off (there have been studies on this that I know for a fact you will not attempt to research).