2 ms·
This is about the case that Scott Aaronson mentioned in this Democritus lecture on Free Will: The misconception committed by the free will camp is the one I
by weinzierl 11y ago
This is about the case that Scott Aaronson mentioned in this Democritus lecture on Free Will:
The misconception committed by the free will camp is the one I alluded to before:
if there's no free will, then none of us are responsible for our actions, and
hence (for example) the legal system would collapse. Well, I know of only one
trial where the determinism of the laws of physics was actually invoked as a legal
defense. It's the Leopold and Loeb trial in 1926. Have you heard of this? It was
one of the most famous trials in American history, next to the OJ trial. So,
Leopold and Loeb were these brilliant students at the University of Chicago (one
of them had just finished his undergrad at 18), and they wanted to prove that they
were Nietzschean supermen who were so smart that they could commit the perfect
murder and get away with it. So they kidnapped this 14-year-old boy and bludgeoned
him to death. And they got caught---Leopold dropped his glasses at the crime scene.
They were defended by Clarence Darrow---the same defense lawyer from the Scopes
monkey trial, considered by some to be the greatest defense lawyer in American
history. In his famous closing address, he actually made an argument appealing to
the determinism of the universe. "Who are we to say what could have influenced
these boys to do this? What kind of genetic or environmental influences could've
caused them to commit the crime?" (Maybe Darrow thought he had nothing to lose.)
Anyway, they got life in prison instead of the death penalty, but apparently it
was because of their age, and not because of the determinism of the laws of
physics. [1]
[1] http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec18.html http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec18.html