4 ms·
It's been shown that price signals work only in the environment with perfect information and rational actors, but then the price is superfluous! That's a nonse
by mike_hearn 11y ago
It's been shown that price signals work only in the environment with perfect information and rational actors, but then the price is superfluous!
That's a nonsensical argument so I doubt it's been "shown" by anyone. Price signals work better as the rationality and level of informedness of participants goes up, this should be obvious. But it isn't true that you must have perfect information or else prices are entirely useless.
What's more, even if you do have ideal and perfectly informed actors, you still need prices. The perfect information is spread out amongst many peoples heads, thus requiring some sort of highly scalable gathering and spreading mechanism (like prices), and even perfectly informed people can still reach different judgements about the relative importance of things. The phenomenon of two people who are clearly experts in a subject vigorously disagreeing with each other is commonplace. So even if you could genetically engineer an economy of telepaths, you'd still need prices to resolve differences in personal perceptions of importance.
Ballot-box style voting is not a replacement for markets. You can't literally hold a nationwide vote every time someone wants to buy a loaf of bread, it's too inefficient and anyway, what would the vote say? A much more effective voting mechanism is that you get some "votes" and then can cast them in a kind of auction to get what you want ..... oh, seems we ended up back at prices. Which are in a sense highly democratic.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoActually, in this day and age, its pretty simple to do (take a vote on the price of bread) - just an app. The time for modeling economies around middle-ages village markets is past. We do have good (not perfect) information; we can act rationally.
- scottlocklin 11y agoYou've obviously never done this in anything more than toy examples.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoWhatever can you mean? Nothing concrete to offer? Just felt like a personal attack today?
- asgard1024 11y ago> Price signals work better as the rationality and level of informedness of participants goes up, this should be obvious. It actually isn't obvious. Optimal strategy is not a continuous function of game parameters (ultimatum game is a good example). You can find situations where prices are entirely useless no matter how close to rationality or well informed you happen to be. > you still need prices I agree you can use prices as a substitute for preferences, but I disagree that you can use them as a substitute for information about the product. > Ballot-box style voting is not a replacement for markets. I actually wasn't suggesting it as a practical alternative, I was only saying that the same moral arguments OP had for the free markets work in that case too. > Which are in a sense highly democratic. If we were all only consumers, it would be true. But market participants also invest or save, and that's a problem - these are ways to gain votes over other actors. That's the reason why I find democratic voting morally superior to free markets.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoBut there is a difference between what people say and what they do. Spending is closer to "do". If social interaction rewarded honesty it would be different, but social interaction does not reward honesty.
- asgard1024 11y ago> But there is a difference between what people say and what they do. I am not sure what is your argument. Voting (if that's what you're alluding to) can have the same real consequences as spending money. Both are a limited resource. Anyway, I wanted to remark something that perhaps wasn't obvious. When I say "distribute resources democratically", it doesn't necessarily mean to vote about every resource. It can also mean to democratically establish rules that go against the market in specific cases, or choose market in some other cases. Pretty much what I am saying is that free markets can fail and it should be democratic decision on whether they failed in specific case and how to remedy it. > but social interaction does not reward honesty Interesting. Not sure what you mean by social interaction, but it seems that this contradicts the idea that free markets can work in human societies. In particular, it implies that people are rewarded for dishonesty, which breaks down the free flow of information assumption needed for proper market function.