6 ms·
The Word “Million” Didn’t Exist Until We Needed It
- shakadak 11y agoWould the concept of thousand be a mistake since it does not represent a hundred hundreds ? Or it did not really appear with the same needs as million ?
- swang 11y agoThere is no actual "word" for million in Chinese. 百 is a hundred, 萬 is ten-thousand. A million is 百萬. But also I'm guessing 400萬 could be understood as the same as 4百萬/四百萬.
- tomkwok 11y ago> There is no actual "word" for million in Chinese. > 百 is a hundred, 萬 is ten-thousand. A million is 百萬. But also I'm guessing 400萬 could be understood as the same as 4百萬/四百萬. But there is 億 in Chinese which means a hundred million. 十 10 ten 百 100 hundred 千 1,000 thousand 萬 10,000 ten-thousand 十萬 100,000 hundred-thousand 百萬 1,000,000 million 千萬 10,000,000 ten-million 億 100,000,000 hundred-million 十億 1,000,000,000 billion 百億 10,000,000,000 ten-billion 千億 100,000,000,000 hundred-billion 萬億 or 兆 1,000,000,000,000 trillion 萬 and 億 are traditional Chinese characters. The simplified characters are 万 and 亿 respectively. 兆 is usually avoided because it does not only mean trillion but also 百萬 (million) in mainland China's translation of "mega-byte" or "mega-pixel" for example.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- escherplex 11y agoInteresting that 兆 is sometimes used in Hanzi for a trillion. Core meanings 兆 include 'portent' or 'omen' which could cause a central banker to lament 'maybe we've printed too much currency'. English used to have a simple system for naming large numbers using the French suffix 'illion' for 'million' and adding prefixes for powers of a million (see OED). So a billion was (10 ^ 6) ^ 2 and by extension trillion was (10 ^6) ^ 3. A billion today was called a thousand million then. However the US pushed for the value of 10 ^ 9 as a billion (with trillion as 10 ^ 12) and back in 1975 that became the 'world' standard.
- telotortium 11y agoThe world standard for English -- the long scale is standard in many other languages.
- escherplex 11y agoThat's why 'world' was in quotes. Hubris is tedious, nationalist or otherwise. I remember visiting someone's oversized digs who had an old Sony 3/4 inch videocassette archives of Charles Kuralt's 'On the Road' series. In one, Kuralt was whining about Jimmy Carter's attempts to impose the metric system as US standard and ended his rant with 'there's nothing romantic about a centimeter worm' [from some 'inch worm measuring a marigold' pop song]. That general sentiment held and subsequent attempts at metrification fizzled out. And we know what impact mixed standards had on construction of the mirror for the Hubble space telescope.
- swang 11y agoI'm not 100% on this, but I am pretty sure 億 was not always "hundred-million" since the numbering system shifted sometime between the historical/modern writing systems.
- hugh4 11y agoOn a similar note, English outside the United States used the long-scale billion (10^12, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_and_short_scales https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_and_short_scales) until the last few decades. When numbers on the order of 10^9 started to become a thing that needed to be discussed regularly, everybody grudgingly switched to the American short-scale "billion" on the grounds of it actually being useful.
- seszett 11y agoHow is it more useful though? It's just different words for the same numbers, and it seems to me like long scale would actually be more useful because it allows representing larger numbers.
- bane 11y agoYou can represent any number in either scale, the short scale simply aligns the names with the comma/dot representation. The short scale offers more precision and is easier to say when dealing with common "large" numbers like GDP, or shipping volume or whatnot. Instead of saying "the trade imbalance this quarter was $58 billion" you'd say "the trade imbalance this quarter was $58 thousand million". Or "The total revenue this quarter was $23 billion, 118 million, 326 thousand, 112" or "$23 thousand million, 118 million, 326 thousand, 112". The later is harder to say, maps poorly between representational spacers (commas/dots depending), and is easy to confuse. Keep in mind, before the 20th century, there wasn't much of a case where anybody would have to deal with figures this large, these days literally everybody does. Getting rid of two syllables and aligning the spoken form with the representational form greatly simplifies day-to-day speech.
- Someone 11y agoThat's why the long scale has milliard, billiard, trilliard, etc. The long scale is slightly more logical with its (Latin number)illion = 10^(6 times Latin number) (whatever)illiard = 1000 times (whatever)illion , compared to the short scale's (Latin number)illion = 10^(3 times Latin number plus 3) that somehow maps even Latin numbers to odd exponents and vice versa. If one could design this from a clean sheet, I think a short form where billion = 10^6, trillion = 10^9 would make the most sense, as it logically names numbers that one might encounter. Scientists who need huge numbers will use scientific notation or phrases such as gigadollars.
- yiyus 11y agoIsn't this the case for every word? I would cut off my right hand if you found, for example, the word banana in old texts from the time before bananas were discovered.
- maxerickson 11y agoIt's fortunate that the presence in the text would be evidence of earlier discovery. (I think I get what you meant, but it's hard to express that meaning succinctly and not fall into the above trap)
- wodenokoto 11y agoI think the word googolplex was invented before anyone really needed it. But I agree with you, that it would generally be silly to invent words for concepts that have not yet been met by any speakers.
- yiyus 11y agoIndeed, there are some exceptions. In the book "La Colmena" (I guess it is called "The Hive" in English), by Camilo Jose Cela, there is a man who invents words. He meets with writers in a café, and all of them listen to him with much expectation: "did you invent any new word, master?" and he says something like "Bizcotur" and everybody acclaims him: "Wonderful!", "Sublime!".
- petercooper 11y agoNew words can have significant impacts on how we perceive the world, down to not even noticing certain things unless we have a word for them (Radiolab did an episode on this called 'Words' - the idea of the green/blue distinction not being represented in other languages is another common issue). Even in the tech world, I see how having a word to hang myriad ideas off of can have a big impact. 'Logical' types howl and whine at things like 'cloud', 'Ajax', or 'HTML5' meaning things they don't technically mean, but nonetheless each brought numerous things together and in some cases (such as 'cloud') formed the cornerstone of a new sector. (See also the recent use of the word 'unicorn' around here.)
- bboreham 11y agoOn my first visit to India I was confused to find that big numbers were expressed in 'lakh', which is 100,000. So a million could be "ten lakh". This unit would be useful for discussing house prices where I live, but doesn't seem to have caught on.
- DanBC 11y agoLakh is controversial on Stack Exchange. A bunch of people use it, and few other people want to crush anything that's not US English and edit it out.
- bane 11y agoOther than India, is Lakh used in any other English speaking countries or dialects?
- kissickas 11y agoNRIs have spread it around, I hear it all of the time here in the GCC but usually only from Pakistanis or Indians. Most people are familiar with it and understand it though.
- partisan 11y agoNRI: Non-resident Indian GCC: (Persian) Gulf Cooperation Council (Countries) Had to look them up just like many people have to look up lakh after seeing it on Stack Overflow.
- DanBC 11y agoI have no idea. It's used a lot in India, and on any site that has many users from India, so my attitude is "suck it up cultural fascists". There's a bunch of loan words in English from India, and a few more aren't going to hurt. (Edit: this sounds a bit grumpy, it's not meant to be.)
- 11y ago
- shrewduser 11y agodid any word exist before we needed it?
- shalmanese 11y agoGoogolplex
- jkot 11y agoHow about 'decies centena milia'? Latin was cultural language back than. Ancient Rome city had population a few millions and they often did census which involved hundreds of millions people.
- jinushaun 11y agoThough they don't mention it explicitly, Latin would have used "milia milia" to represent million. The term "one thousand squared" (mili-one) was invented later.
- logicallee 11y agoI find this odd. Ancient Egyptian had a character for a million - someone sitting/kneeling with one leg (like they just dropped to the ground) and throwing their hands up in the air, (seeming to me) very very impressed, like "whoa!" Here it is - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egyptian_numerals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egyptian_numerals maybe I'm reading too much into it. But anyway a million doesn't seem that large of a number - if the ancient egyptians had it, why shouldn't societies thousands of years later? So it's a bit odd...
- jinushaun 11y agoThe article explicitly mentions Egyptian. I think this story highlights the recurring theme of medieval culture rediscovering ancient knowledge.
- tacos 11y agoConsider Tagalog, which commonly uses native small numbers, Spanish for mid-sized numbers, and English for larger, financial quantities.
- kichuku 11y agoMy first language is Tamil which is spoken in South India. Tamil is known to be a very ancient language. The interesting fact is that Tamil has had distinct names for wide range of numbers[1] ranging from 10^21 to fractions as small as 1/2,323,824,530,227,200,000,000 [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tamil_numerals#Sanskrit-System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tamil_numerals#Sanskrit-System There are people who debate that Tamil is as old/older than Sanskrit. But there is no proof for that claim. But there is more than conclusive proof that these distinct names for these large and small numbers existed in written texts since very long time. Edit: Grammar, fixed link
- chrisdevereux 11y ago> there was no word for “million” in Old English, a medieval predecessor of the language you’re currently reading This sentence is a fantastic example of why translation is so hard!