5 ms·
What a defense of nonsense. The marking punishes a student for achieving a correct answer in an appropriate way, regardless of pedagogical justification.
by tomrod 11y ago
What a defense of nonsense. The marking punishes a student for achieving a correct answer in an appropriate way, regardless of pedagogical justification.
- tfigueroa 11y agoAgreed. Few children are going to get to the point where the commutative property is a concern, anyway. If we're going to be pedantic, use this as a learning opportunity. "Actually, 5x3 is slightly different than 3x5. Multiplication has this property..." Some of the kids won't care, but some will be intrigued. Teaching it this way is a gotcha.
- signal11 11y agoI found this link interesting. Under this "Common Core" curriculum, apparently, students are trained to read 5x3 as "five groups of three" which is why 3+3+3+3+3 is right and 5+5+5 is wrong. http://www.businessinsider.com/why-55515-is-wrong-under-the-common-core-2015-10?IR=T http://www.businessinsider.com/why-55515-is-wrong-under-the-... It's hilarious because I read 5x3 as "5, 3 times". Anyhow, just goes to show Maths teachers have now been replaced by box tickers who refuse to apply their brain. In my book, the kid demonstrated repeated addition and should have got the mark.
- pbreit 11y agoHow do you not read it "5 times 3"? Why would you re-arrange where the "times" is?
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYou're joking, right? GP read it as: "5 x3", like he would read "copy x3", or "copy, three times". It's a natural way of reading "5x3", though I personally read it as "5x 3".
- Retric 11y ago(5, times 3) or (5 times, 3) both work.
- netheril96 11y agoI just consider "times" the name of the multiplication operator.
- signal11 11y agoBecause where I come from, we use the English equivalent of "into" rather than "times". "5 into 3" roughly translates to "5, 3 times". The meta-point here is that English (or any other language) is crap for math, which is why we use mathematical notation. And this bullcrap syllabus is trying to redefine the "x" operator, which gets my goat.
- chris_wot 11y agoThe syllabus does nothing of the sort. The addition technique is a way of teaching very young children in a way they can grasp. However, it relies on using concrete objects and so far as I can see, should be used as a technique to aid understanding, and only then should the multiplication notation be introduced.
- xworld21 11y agoFunnily enough, the traditional formal definition of product is due to Peano and it would say 5x3=5+5+5: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peano_axioms#Multiplication https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peano_axioms#Multiplication
- chris_wot 11y agoPaeno axioms do not define multiplication. Multiplication is considered to be part of second-order arithmetic, which includes Paeno arithmetic (which is a first order system) and augments it to form a stronger set of axioms, of which multiplication is one of them. The definition of multiplication is indeed in the Wikipedia article, but if you reread it then you'll see it doesn't claim to be a Paeno axiom. A better article to read (after reading about Paeno axioms!) is here: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second-order_arithmetic#Basic https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second-order_arithmetic#Basi...
- NathanKP 11y agoPersonally the way I learned to think of it was to read it in the order that organizes it into the fewest number of "groups". Afterall it is easier (and faster) to visualize three groups of five items, than it is to visualize five groups of three items. For example what if it was 11 x 3. It would make no sense to try to think of it as eleven groups of three, when you can easily derive the answer far quicker as 11 + 11 = 22 + 11 = 33.
- pohl 11y ago"Use the repeated addition strategy..." Critics of this are missing that the teacher is not asking the student to find the correct result. Instead, the teacher is asking the student to apply a specific algorithm. If the teacher asks to apply Merge Sort to a list, but the student applies Insertion Sort, both strategies will result in the same sorted list. But only one will demonstrate what the teacher asked the student to demonstrate.
- Al-Khwarizmi 11y agoThe student wrote 5+5+5, isn't that a repeated addition strategy?
- pohl 11y agoIt certainly is a repeated addition strategy, but is it the repeated addition strategy given to the students? The definition of the algorithm given to the student may involve language like "take the first number and..." The steps are the steps.
- ryandrake 11y ago"The steps are the steps". Great advice if the purpose of school is to train people for rote factory work (we have robots for that). Not such a great way to prepare future leaders or creative problem solvers.
- jmilloy 11y agoWhen are practising skills in school, sometimes we practice creativity and sometimes we practice techniques. Both are useful, and it's clear which is which. Secondly, a student that knows the difference between different techniques and can call them up at will (such as the difference between 5 sets of 3 and 3 sets of 5) is better off than a student that only knows how to produce a particular answer for a particular question.
- 11y ago