3 ms·
What about having juries composed of actual peers? That is, randomly selected experts, half from industry and half from academia? The lack of prolonged engage
by nitrogen 11y ago
What about having juries composed of actual peers? That is, randomly selected experts, half from industry and half from academia? The lack of prolonged engagement and predictable assignment to cases should make it harder to end up with another CAFC.
- JupiterMoon 11y agoThe point is that this leads to corruption. A jury-of-peers reflects and represents wider society. A jury-of-some-selected-close-peers as you are suggesting would not reflect the needs of wider society. Other other hand the broadly selected jury won't be able to understand technical cases. Its 6 one half-a-dozen the other. (UK English expression that means both ways have major flaws and neither is ideal.)
- ownagefool 11y agoScottish here. I'd say that saying actually means both are ultimatly the same, as in they might be difference but they're both equally negative. In this case, it would indeed be refering your assessment that both ways have major flaws and neither is ideal. But the point is, it has a wider meaning that could be invoked when comparing two good outcomes, for example.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ksenzee 11y agoSix of one, half a dozen of the other is also widely used in the US, to mean it doesn't really matter which one you pick because they're pretty much the same.
- nitrogen 11y agoCurrent juries aren't meeting the needs of society, either, so there's not much loss there. We also have the counterbalance of elected representatives, and in the US, sometimes judges are elected, too. Maybe it'd be enough for them to represent society, with juries in technical cases representing accurate justice for the case at hand.
- bshanks 11y agoHow about having half of the jury be randomly chosen individuals (as in the current system), and the other half be randomly chosen experts?