3 ms·
tl;dr, because it looks like I rambled: I agree, here are some possible underlying causes, people have different perceptions of the material world, people respo
by uhhyeahdude 11y ago
tl;dr, because it looks like I rambled: I agree, here are some possible underlying causes, people have different perceptions of the material world, people respond poorly to certain types of criticism, and the aging population suffers from this x10000. I am a poor editor, but I mean well.
I'm not sure if that is a generally interesting factoid so much as it is interesting as an anecdote; that said, I happen to have a lot of similarly anecdotal support for your observations.
Let's say I take medication for "ADHD-PI". If I am being 100% honest, I might change the diagnosis to "easily bored; requires interesting work and regular novelty; try meditation prior to stimulant exposure" . In any case, the meds work, at least they keep me focused for the duration of a particularly tedious task, and allows me to function in normal society with a modicum of normalcy. However, most of the medications Rx'd for ADHD are stimulants, and they are the real deal. Dexedrine and Adderall/Vyvanse are both chemically equivalent to amphetamine sulphate that one might purchase illicitly; they just come in measured doses, from a pharmacy, are legal, and have different fillers/binders and ratio of levo vs dextro isomers contained. Technically, Vyvanse is a pro-drug of dextroamphetamine, converted in vivo at a roughly constant rate. So it's just a new way of doing an XR formulation of speed. Also a new patent to feed off of a drug that's been around forever. The other stimulants commonly prescribed are not amphetamines, but the end result (elevated dopamine and norepinephrine, primarily)- amps are potent DA/NE agonists, while the -phenidate family (Ritalin/Concerta, etc) blocks the reuptake of those catecholamines. There are other drug classes, but they are not in the same ballpark, efficacy-wise. (And this applies to just about any healthy individual fed a mild dose of a powerful stimulant, no diagnosis or disorder required).
Reeling myself back in, sorry - (not on meds, tend to get parenthetical and non-linear as they wear off).
So, I noticed the same thing you write about with regard to a sudden change in atmospheric sensitivity. I cannot stand to be in an overheated room, or a room without at least a hint of movement in the air. I have also noticed that other people don't seem to care quite as much, or even notice. This makes a lot of sense when you consider the effects of stimulants that flood your brain with chemicals with such intimate ties to one's alertness, attentiveness, and other such qualities of vigilance. They also tend to increase your heart rate, BP (usually minor), sweat production (sweaty skin is hyper-sensitive to air flow), and body temp. On meds, I literally (in the traditional sense) run a little hotter than unmedicated co-workers.
And, yeah, people can get defensive about the air quality of their space, whether it's the house or whatever. I try to be sensitive, maybe ask if I could crack a window (hint, hint), but some individuals take these things personally; as if you were commmenting on their breath, BO, or child-rearing capability. It's just human nature, I think.
I have spent extensive time working with dementia sufferers, and some of them were NOT OK with any open/unlocked doors or windows. And the houses/rooms they life in are filled with this thick, gluey, slimy "air". I would call it unlivable. They would (if still verbally and cognitively able) call it "normal" or "pleasant". I used to do food drops for meals on wheels in downtown Portland, and I saw the same scene in SRO's throughout the city center and Old Town. For some, who were still mentally intact, the closed windows were an issue of hypervigilance due to past experiences in the past, or because they can cut down on street noise by minimizing sound transmission.
I hope this at least supports your assertion re: "habitual tic" vs. materialist/physiological explanations. It is usually a bit of both. For some, it's a deeply rooted habitual behavior, for others it is a manifestation of psychological/neurological/physiological changes associated with aging in general, whether or not the individual is healthy.
Context for my observations include caring for dementia patients in close quarters, at length, exhaustive research, regular meetings with the Alzheimer's Association (donate! please! I guarantee someone close to you is burdened with incipient senescence, or caring for a family member who has symptoms), weekly conversations with a respected gerontologist, and, as mentioned, the ADHD experience, and the pharmacological element that can accompany it.
As mentioned earlier, it might just be a human trait to take offense at lifestyle criticism, or the perception thereof. I think it is one of those things that transcends cultural, national, racial, gender, whatever differences we have from one another. I am supposed to be really sensitive to this stuff, to have an above average self-awareness when it comes to these issues... But I still get a little pissed when I feel slighted or looked down upon, like someone just farted in the general direction of my ancestors. Alas.
Sorry for the rambling post, but nice to look at quirk I don't hear much about. updated because I don't post, and my formatting was way off.
- derefr 11y agoI do wonder about the possibility of some sort of causation (in either direction) with the dementia sufferers. I could well see an experiment that says "chronic low-grade hypoxia causes brain damage that looks like dementia." I could also easily imagine an experiment proving something like "dementia sufferers' brains run in a 'battery-saver mode'; have lower resource demands on their bodies", where the "resources" are nutrients and, surprise surprise, oxygen. Dementia patients would then be comfortable in regular- or low-oxygen environments, while the rest of us are only comfortable in the regular-oxygen environments—making it look like the dementia-sufferers prefer the low-oxygen environments. (Such an experimental result would also suggest that dementia would tend to make you gradually become fatter or darken your urine, because you're consuming the same nutrients but using fewer of them.) One thing I heard a while back was that dementia happens almost inevitably in the elderly if they lose their teeth and end up on a liquid/parenteral diet, rather than using dentures. I've always wondered if this implied that regular jaw pressure was necessary either to drive (g)lymphatic clearance from the brain, or oxygen to the brain, or both. It seems like another associative data-point in the "chronic hypoxia <=> dementia" correlation, at least.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- uhhyeahdude 11y agoYou bring up some interesting ideas, and I am well aware of the current research on dementia (first hand exposure for prolonged periods will either turn you into an expert on the etiology of dementia, or make you run for the hills). If you're like me, you also notice the utter lack of progress we've made in this area. Pharma has hit or miss symptom management approaches that many cannot afford; once symptoms are noticed, intervention is unlikely to have much of an impact, except to further degrade the quality of life of the patient. We should be aggressive when it comes to new approaches, and I have been closely following studies and the experiences of those who self-experiment. I did trials of vinpocetine, among other nootropics, follow the community, and if a promising compound is released, procure a sample prior to someone patenting it. When my Grandmother was showing signs, I took a course of memantine to help stall with growing ineffectiveness of medication that I relied upn, and also to let the family know about what to expect if they decided to go that route. That was several years ago; they chose not to use meds, and it was too late at that point anyway, as I came to realize upon arrival. BTW, after a week of acclimating, I was pleasantly surprised at the effects offered by that compound. I'm currently obsessed with certain types of inflammation, and am using a dietary approach, augmented by certain supplements, yoga (oxygen!), socializing, challenging myself (SICP, why not), and meditation (more oxygen! and meta-cognitive benefits to boot - observing changes in cognition is not easy without it, and observations regarding mental status decline from others is hard to accept). I'm not young enough anymore to believe hype on longecity, e.g., but I'm not going to discount personal experiences either. One thing to remember about the O2 hypothesis you propose,is that dementia sufferers often do not get sufficient nutrients. The forget how cooking works, what food is, that water should be consumed on a regular basis, develop phobias around food, security, paranoia, and in my case as a temporary (but almost full time) caregiver is showing me the limits of care. In the morning, I systematically walk through the house, open all windows, blinds, remove barricades, turn on all fans, and prepare meals (was a chef in a past life, luckily), ensure the food is labeled, with a note to enjoy, and we cook a meal (I cook, and give out busy-work assignments while the meal is prepared. It is important to do an evening meal and do what you can to make it "fun"; oftentimes that is the best part of the day for someone experiencing cognitive decline. Food is intimately tied to memory, and I notice the effects, especially when incorporating ingredients from her childhood. Ah, I don't know... If you are young (I'm early thirties), now is the time to become an expert. Doctors are not equipped or understandably risk-averse when it comes to dealing with our new era of elongated morbidity. I'm getting a tattoo that reads "DNR" somewhere on my torso whe I hit 60. The devastation to family in the case of unclear wishes regarding such matters cannot be overstated. I have been doing this for just under a year, almost burned out twice, and have radically changed my own life to decrease stress, engage in primary prevention, and live as well as I can.