3 ms·
If population continues to grow exponentially, a Malthusian apocalypse is a physical certainty, it's merely a question of when, not if. A 1% growth rate would
by aidenn0 11y ago
If population continues to grow exponentially, a Malthusian apocalypse is a physical certainty, it's merely a question of when, not if. A 1% growth rate would put us at 1 trillion in about 500 years.
Let's say we then invent a new technology that doubles the carrying capacity of Earth; that buys us about 70 years. Now we figure out how to terraform mars to hold about as many people as earth: another 70 years.
So assuming a 2 trillion maximum capacity of earth and a steady 1% growth rate, we have 640 years to figure out how to colonize the moons of the outer planets...
If population sizes do peak in the next 40 years we are a lot better off, but are still stuck with the question of how to grow the economy at an exponential rate indefinitely, or come up with a different macroeconomic plan.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> If population continues to grow exponentially, a Malthusian apocalypse is a physical certainty World population isn't growing exponentially, so it can't continue to do so; growth rate (% of current population added per year) peaked in the mid 1960s, and has declined since, exponential growth would have a constant growth rate. > A 1% growth rate would put us at 1 trillion in about 500 years. Current growth rate is a little above 1%, but its dropping.
- coddingtonbear 11y agoAny positive population growth is necessarily exponential -- the fact that that rate is getting lower is cause for hope, but that doesn't change the mathematical reality.
- dllthomas 11y ago"Any positive population growth is necessarily exponential" That's just false. If the average number of children per person is falling toward replacement fast enough, population growth is not exponential while still being positive (potentially indefinitely).
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Any positive population growth is necessarily exponential No, its not. There are all kinds of growth curves that are not exponential. Exponential growth is has a constant multiple over a fixed time frame. (so, a constant doubling interval.) Positive growth and exponential growth have nothing to do with each other; exponential growth can be positive or negative, and positive (or negative) growth can be non-exponential. > but that doesn't change the mathematical reality. The mathematical reality is that the population isn't growing exponentially, and that positive growth doesn't imply exponential growth.
- aidenn0 11y agoA lot of the "Malthus was wrong" people claim that we can continue a modest exponential rate for essentially indefinitely, as technology will continue to wring more efficient use of land. To me this is obviously false, so we will need to grow sub-exponentially (i.e. per-capita growth rate must go down) at some point. In the context of the article we are discussing, arresting growth rate is part of preventing the Malthusian apocalypse. Obviously besides the green revolution, the other big change since Malthus has been safe reliable contraceptives, so the tools are there to arrest population growth, but most people are uncomfortable with any coercive use of these, so if the U curve of population growth (that TFA discusses) ends up being real (a lot of countries on the right side of the curve are culturally very different from countries in the middle of the curve, so it could be coincidental), cheaper energy could accelerate us towards a situation where we need to consider coercive means of reducing growth rate.
- dragonwriter 11y agoSince we know that caring capacity will drop (eventually to zero; if nothing else, the sun doesn't last forever), there is no long run sustainable population on Earth. So true, no population pattern is sustainable indefinitely on Earth. (Or, for that matter, in the Universe.) So in the end, considering infinite timeline sustainability is pointless.
- aidenn0 11y agoAlmost any exponential growth will exhaust our resources far before the sun burns out.