3 ms·
Something feels "off" about a methodology that basically ranks all of the "top" state schools as poor values. Take the top-3 state schools in Virginia (by most
by alistairSH 11y ago
Something feels "off" about a methodology that basically ranks all of the "top" state schools as poor values.
Take the top-3 state schools in Virginia (by most other rankings, that's UVA, W&M, and VT). All three are nationally recognized. And all three are competitive that you need very good grades and a solid set of extra-curricular activities to be accepted.
UVA ranks the lowest of the three, yet has the highest actual earnings. VT is ranked significantly higher with the middle earnings value.
What does a student do with this? Cost of attendance at the three is similar. Should they attend VT with it's higher ranking, despite lower average earnings?
Similar comments can be made about UNC-CH, UW-Seattle, UT-Austin.
Also lacking from this analysis seems to be the loan burden borne by students. Georgetown and Villanova both rank very high in this list. But, both are insanely expensive to attend. Even with high actual earnings, it could take a decade or more for many students to pay off a potential six-figure loan.
- tpudlik 11y agoI don't think the Economist's ranking can be used for choosing which school to attend. It tells you how good a job schools do at boosting the earnings of the people who attend there---conditioned on who attends. In other words, they tell you how much the school does for a typical member of its student body. But if you're not representative of that student body (and you certainly won't be representative at many of the schools, especially the outliers!), this will not tell you how much the school would do for you.
- alistairSH 11y agoI guess I just find it extremely hard to believe almost all of the nations "top" state schools have a negative impact (actual earnings less than expected) on the students that attend. Maybe I need to dig into the source of the expected earning figures. I'm definitely biased to some degree, being a graduate of one of the state schools with a poor ranking - I'm sitting here wondering where else I could have gone to get a better value.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoThe methodology is trying to remove the admissions department's effect on student success, leaving behind everything else (faculty, peers, course structure, university prestige, money vs prestige focus, etc).