4 ms·
> it doesn't hurt Apple They addressed this right in the article. It does hurt Apple, because the best people won't go work there. That's why they are so far
by jedberg 11y ago
> it doesn't hurt Apple
They addressed this right in the article. It does hurt Apple, because the best people won't go work there. That's why they are so far behind on every AI thing they do. Siri and maps are both way worse than Google's offering, as is the predictive typing. Probably because they can't get the best people working on the problem.
I use an iPhone but it's this lack of AI that makes me seriously consider Android every time it's time to upgrade.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI think it is a fair point that you find Android's AI features more compelling (although you haven't? switched). So from Apple's perspective its probably hard to measure how many customers they "lose". They did just announce another record breaking quarter and it looks like they had more profit than Google had in revenue for the same period (hard to pin it precisely given the way quarters overlap). However, while the article claims the "best people" won't go to work there, that is a bit hard to substantiate isn't it? It's seems apparent that the best people who insist on publishing their results won't go there, but are the "best people in AI research" and "people who insist on publishing" the same set of people? Or is it possible that some members of the set "best people in AI" are completely happy to work in a dark lab with no papers published but an essentially unlimited budget? There is another organization which operates on the same principle, the NSA. They hire some fraction of the world's best mathematicians. Those mathematicians never publish their work, and yet still work there. And every now and then when we get to see behind the curtain, or long after the fact, we discover some really great work has gone on behind that veil of secrecy. Has it hurt them? The author asserts that it hurts Apple, but I don't find their argument compelling. And there is the sticky issue of defining "hurt". Clearly it isn't hurting them financially, they are killing it. And clearly the feature set parity is close enough that you're still carrying around an iPhone. So how do we define hurt here? As compared to what? I'm not convinced Apple is hurt by this strategy yet, perhaps when you post here "I really wanted to replace my iPhone with another iPhone but the features of Google's AI or Microsoft's Cortana compelled me to buy a different phone." Then we can start talking about hurt. But so far I'm not seeing it.
- TTPrograms 11y agoIs current profit really the best metric to measure the success of an AI department? I doubt many people bought iPhones because of Siri. AI development's biggest impact on bottom line is still probably 5-15 years away.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoNo it isn't. However profit is the standard by which we measure companies in many cases and so I think it is fair to use it to measure Apple overall. Measuring the impact of the AI group will be harder to do, at the "C" level you evaluate your R&D budget against your ability to stay ahead of your competitors, lower down at the SVP level you're probably balancing near term improvement over game changing innovation. Going further down the the director level you're no doubt measuring your department by its rate of progress against it's own goals, the progress of external organizations with a similar mission. Given the secrecy we can't really know how effective Apple's AI group has been at meeting its goals, nor can we tell how quickly they are moving with respect to the state of the art in the industry. That leaves us with profit from the outside looking in. I'll go out on a limb and suggest that if Google's margins continue to erode over the next five years as they have the previous five, it will will become that much harder to sustain their AI efforts. So at one level company profits can be a way to estimate a company's future ability to compete in the space.
- jedberg 11y agoYou're right, the difference isn't good enough to convince me to switch yet, but that is in part because I can still use the Google products (with poor integration) on my iPhone. So honestly if they allowed Google to better integrate on the iPhone, it may not hurt them at all since I'd keep buying their hardware. Having actually been involved in the AI scene, I can tell you anecdotally that all the very best people refuse to work at Apple (or the NSA, to your point), because they know they can get the same budget and data access at Google, but still be part of the community. Most of them in fact do work at Google, or at other startups nearby that work closely with Google.
- 11y ago
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoApple know who the best people are. They will search them out. If they haven't already, then maybe Apple's priorities lie elsewhere and this is all moot.
- eridius 11y agoI'm not convinced that Apple's secrecy has anything to do with Siri and Maps lagging behind Google's offerings. I suspect a large part of it has to do with the fact that Apple is not willing to compromise user privacy in order to do this stuff. Siri does require the internet[1] to parse your spoken words, but all of the data that Siri actually operates on is only local to your device and is not known to Apple. Similarly, Apple doesn't know anything pertaining to your mapping[2], that's all device-local too. Meanwhile Google aggregates everything it can, and AFAIK all of its email-related capabilities (e.g. finding invitations in email and whatnot) actually require you to be using Google email too, so they already have all of that. Because Google has such comprehensive knowledge about the user's personal information, they can do more intelligent things. But this comes at the cost of the user having given up any semblance of privacy. Also, I imagine that Google can run more powerful algorithms if it's all happening in the cloud, instead of being restricted by what can reasonably run on a mobile phone. [1] Although I'm not sure if it does everything over the internet or if it's moved any of that to the device now that we have more powerful devices. I'm guessing they haven't, but it wouldn't surprise me if they've changed aspects of this. [2] IIRC Apple said that they take routes, chop off the beginning and end (so you can't identify the addresses), and upload those using a unique anonymous identifier (i.e. UUID) and no device-specific info, possibly with information on the actual driving (e.g. traffic) but I'm not sure, and they use that info to help improve the product. But that sounds like pretty thorough anonymizing (no way to associate routes with each other or with a device, and the routes don't include the potentially private source/destination) so I'm happy to give them that, and even then I assume it only uploads this if the user has already opted in to sending Apple data to improve their products (which it asks about during initial device setup, and there's a switch in System Preferences for this).
- petra 11y ago>> chop off the beginning and end (so you can't identify the addresses), and upload those using a unique anonymous identifier (i.e. UUID) and no device-specific info, Actually since they know your IP address ,it's not anonymous - it's easy to connect to your identity. Also , in general the way they gather location(from another post) [1] , is they gather list of cellular and wifi hotspots around you(and i wonder about whether they gather signal strength).And since for example , wifi signals are heavily blocked by walls, they are very space limited in many situations. So maybe(IDK, the field of anonymization is tricky) combining this data with the data sent when asking for a route is enough get pretty close location ? altough sure, some data is definetly is lost in this process and that's a good thing. [1]http://thenextweb.com/apple/2011/04/27/finally-apple-speaks-out-about-iphone-location-data/ http://thenextweb.com/apple/2011/04/27/finally-apple-speaks-...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]