4 ms·
I'm a grant writer and have worked for numerous Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs) and a smaller number of hospitals. From their perspective, EMR and re
by jseliger 11y ago
I'm a grant writer and have worked for numerous Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs) and a smaller number of hospitals. From their perspective, EMR and related systems have tended to cost at least as much as they've saved. Some of them have seen the vendor jousting Sung describes and have experienced all sorts of vendor fatigue and vendor lock-in.
At the same time, FQHCs and hospitals are facing CMS requirements that dictate increasing EMR usage. This effort has had... some setbacks, let's just say. And what Executive Directors are willing to say off the record is not pretty: http://seliger.com/2015/10/25/meaningful-use-regulations-cms-hrsa-fqhcs-and-the-stalled-push-to-electronic-medical-records-emrs http://seliger.com/2015/10/25/meaningful-use-regulations-cms....
- toomuchtodo 11y agoWhy doesn't the federal government build an EMR system and require its use as a condition of accepting Medicare payments? Sure, I'd expect a terrible process and result previously (such as the mess healthcare.gov was when rolled out), but I have a lot more faith with the USDS and 18F in place.
- samstave 11y agoThey did. VA pioneered emr... OpenVista by medsphere is based on Vista, the gov emr... All emr companies are walled gardens. In 2009 I built the first mobile HL7 compliant client for the iPhone which was emr agnostic and could work with any emr -across an esb... But all emr companies shunned us because they wanted to protect their walled gardens. At the time hospitals shunned us because they didn't believe the iPhone was a good enough device (big enough screen) to be usable... We built integrations into a number of systems... But couldn't get traction at that early stage. So we open sourced it through medsphere... Dr chrono came along and took different tack which was to make an actual emr... After working with so many hospitals and these systems I basically gave up... The system is pretty broken and the artificial barriers to entry are pretty lame.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- sachinag 11y agoYup. We need data at rest standards tied to Medicare reimbursement.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoIf you can't win with the carrot, switch to the stick.
- lbhnact 11y agoExactly. Vista has pretty lousy UX, but it's implementation across most of the VA it a central part of the VA's much greater efficiency that other systems with similar populations. Of course, being written in MUMPS (just like some of the other biggies) doesn't help, but the failure of Vista to be implemented commercially has to do with market and human reasons that could have been engineered around. Missed opportunity for the US, really.
- floatrock 11y ago> HL7 compliant client... which was emr agnostic In my experience, there's no such thing. HL7 is a spec in only the loosest sense of the word. Half the time you had an 80-character console output dumped into the "freetext" fields. Then there's all the codes used for different drugs, tests, admission/discharge (plus differentiating when they're standardized or user-entered with appropriate typos). Point is, all the costs were really in the integration. Getting access to the HL7 streams wasn't bad once you got far enough in the sales cycle. Once you had it, it was a one-off project to parse the specifics of the messages. And that was just for a read-only analytics system... trying to generate compatible messages to feed back to the EHR is a whole other beast. That's the challenge getting into this space if you're a web or cloud engineer... you come in with the mindset that "oh, HL7 is a messaging standard, I'll just read the spec and use it." In practice, there's an infinite amount of variability. You really need to treat each hospital as it's own one-off integration, plus all the politics needed to get access to the messages in the first place.