7 ms·
I think the article misses the point, while its secrecy may hurt other people from benefiting from the investment they have made in AI, it doesn't hurt Apple. I
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
I think the article misses the point, while its secrecy may hurt other people from benefiting from the investment they have made in AI, it doesn't hurt Apple. Its almost the perfect prisoner's dilemma right? Apple defected and everyone else co-operated so they got the most benefit?
As a strategy I have observed that people with too much secrecy lose out on innovations that people outside the process could illuminate, but as a strategy it has a history of helping the company employing it stay ahead of the game. Look at Google's secrecy about its data centers, had it gone public with that stuff when it was done, perhaps 2 trillion kwH of power could have been used to do something else if other people had adopted those things. But instead it just helped Google grow faster and do more with their stuff. Is it bad for Google? No. Bad for the rest of us? Perhaps but we don't know one way or the other.
So when Apple's efforts fail to produce a competitive product, then I think you can say its hurting itself, but until then I'm sure they see it as a competitive advantage.
- schwabacher 11y agoI think apple has failed miserably to create a competitive product w/ siri, and I expect them to be far far behind google in other areas like cars.
- monksy 11y agoThis is pretty much Apple's MO since early on. They're a business heavy company that has a different twist on marketing. They have done some "somewhat" good things. (I.e. webkit) However, at the end they haven't followed through with it. (I.e. parts of Webkit were broken, they've refused to work with the community etc) At least with Google you're getting the benefits of the Google services and libraries that may not be their own products. (I.e. Guava, Dager, Guice, GWT, Angular, etc)
- jedberg 11y ago> it doesn't hurt Apple They addressed this right in the article. It does hurt Apple, because the best people won't go work there. That's why they are so far behind on every AI thing they do. Siri and maps are both way worse than Google's offering, as is the predictive typing. Probably because they can't get the best people working on the problem. I use an iPhone but it's this lack of AI that makes me seriously consider Android every time it's time to upgrade.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI think it is a fair point that you find Android's AI features more compelling (although you haven't? switched). So from Apple's perspective its probably hard to measure how many customers they "lose". They did just announce another record breaking quarter and it looks like they had more profit than Google had in revenue for the same period (hard to pin it precisely given the way quarters overlap). However, while the article claims the "best people" won't go to work there, that is a bit hard to substantiate isn't it? It's seems apparent that the best people who insist on publishing their results won't go there, but are the "best people in AI research" and "people who insist on publishing" the same set of people? Or is it possible that some members of the set "best people in AI" are completely happy to work in a dark lab with no papers published but an essentially unlimited budget? There is another organization which operates on the same principle, the NSA. They hire some fraction of the world's best mathematicians. Those mathematicians never publish their work, and yet still work there. And every now and then when we get to see behind the curtain, or long after the fact, we discover some really great work has gone on behind that veil of secrecy. Has it hurt them? The author asserts that it hurts Apple, but I don't find their argument compelling. And there is the sticky issue of defining "hurt". Clearly it isn't hurting them financially, they are killing it. And clearly the feature set parity is close enough that you're still carrying around an iPhone. So how do we define hurt here? As compared to what? I'm not convinced Apple is hurt by this strategy yet, perhaps when you post here "I really wanted to replace my iPhone with another iPhone but the features of Google's AI or Microsoft's Cortana compelled me to buy a different phone." Then we can start talking about hurt. But so far I'm not seeing it.
- 11y ago
- jmount 11y agoThose working on a secret project don't benefit from public evaluation and extension.