5 ms·
Nah, you just don't see the big picture. You're coming at it from the tech side. It's better to look at the business side. Microsoft has 89% desktop market shar
by melling 11y ago
Nah, you just don't see the big picture. You're coming at it from the tech side. It's better to look at the business side. Microsoft has 89% desktop market share, so they basically own the desktop. Apple will never be a real threat because of price. Chrome/Android has an excellent chance to be a real alternative on the desktop. if it gets a large enough market share, perhaps we'll see Adobe's apps, for instance, along with all other major apps.
- bphogan 11y agoIs Apple really that much more expensive? Or is that just something that people believe because it used to be true? I keep hearing this repeated, but I bought my dad a $499 Mac Mini. With Microsoft producing a laptop of their own that starts at $1499, I think all we can really say is "Apple doesn't produce bargain laptops".
- acdha 11y agoIt was true to varying extents before Apple switched to Intel processors. Since then it's never been true by more than ± few percent for equivalent hardware. The complicating factor, and why it's such an enduring belief, is that Apple doesn't ship adware and has minimal hardware standards which are higher than the lowest-end PC market. You see this over and over again where someone is either unable to back up claims or, when pressed, has to admit that the $400 notebook they said was “just like” the MacBook Air had a previous generation processor, magnetic hard drive instead of SSD, low-contrast/dim display, mushy keyboard or unusable trackpad, etc. The same manufacturer probably even makes something fairly competitive, too, but it costs about as much.
- scholia 11y agoDoesn't really matter. Apple makes a very narrow range of products for high-end consumers, and that's a small portion of the market. Apple has nothing for the average home user who wants a $199-$399 laptop. Or even for the geek or gamer who wants a reasonably-priced tower.
- acdha 11y ago> Doesn't really matter. Apple makes a very narrow range of products for high-end consumers, and that's a small portion of the market. It's about half the market as far as profit goes – the low-end stuff is absurdly low margin and customers have very little brand loyalty. More importantly, the netbook and other low-end market has been fading as people buy tablets and large smartphones. It's not at crossover yet but there's a growing percentage of people who don't have a traditional computer at all and that's going to eat into the low-end market most heavily because the difference in utility between a $200 netbook and a $200 tablet is the smallest and hardware quality is often better on the tablet side. The demographic shift is somewhat fascinating, with PC ownership declining by 10% for people under 30 in the last 5 years: “Today, 78% of adults under 30 own a laptop or desktop computer, compared with 88% who did so in 2010. Smartphone ownership, on the other hand, has surpassed both of these devices, with 86% of 18- to 29-year-olds owning one in 2015.” http://www.pewinternet.org/2015/10/29/technology-device-ownership-2015/ http://www.pewinternet.org/2015/10/29/technology-device-owne...
- scholia 11y agoIt's about half the market as far as profit goes – the low-end stuff is absurdly low margin and customers have very little brand loyalty. Yes, that's true. But Apple needs to have a high profit margin because it only makes $1 billion a week (after tax) and has only $200 billion in the bank. It would obviously be a waste of money to serve more people, or even pay its Chinese workers a living wage. More importantly, the netbook and other low-end market has been fading as people buy tablets and large smartphones. The netbook market hasn't existed for a very long time, but sales of $199 laptops like the HP Stream 11 seem to be pretty good. Obviously they don't include the ability to overcharge users by $100 a shot for small increases in RAM or storage. However, the tablet market -- including iPads -- is declining faster than the PC market. Nowadays even Apple has followed Samsung etc in making phablets.
- s73v3r 11y ago" It would obviously be a waste of money to serve more people, or even pay its Chinese workers a living wage." They do. Compare the workers at Foxconn Apple factories to other factory workers. And remember that just about every other tech company also makes their stuff in China.
- legulere 11y agoDon't forget the battery, which often gets ignored when comparing MacBooks to other highend notebooks.
- danieldk 11y agoIs Apple really that much more expensive? Typically not in the segment where they compete (high-end laptops). However, the cheapest MacBook (in Germany) is 999 Euro. A large chunk of the market cannot afford or does not want to spend 999 Euro on a laptop. If you only want to e-mail, upload/view some photos, make a spreadsheet, a 999 Euro MacBook is expensive compared to a 200 Euro Chromebook or 300 Euro Windows laptop.
- pjmlp 11y agoMac mini in Portugal - 571 € Minimum wage before taxes - 505 € Average PC price at a retail store - 400 €
- emptyfile 11y agoIn Europe just take any American price for an Apple product and increase it by 30%-40%
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- s73v3r 11y agoIt's not. As you said, Apple just doesn't produce cheap laptops. If you compare like for like, the PC laptops cost about the same as the Apple ones.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Is Apple really that much more expensive? I think for directly comparable hardware its not much more expensive, but: 1) the entry price is higher -- to get a minimally functional Apple laptop or desktop you're paying more than any of the alternatives. 2) the smaller number of Apple models compared to any major PC maker (much less the union of all PC makers) means that, unless your hardware preferences happen to match perfectly to an Apple model, you're often able to find a PC that matches your preferences less expensively simply because you are unlikely to have to overshoot your target as far as with Apple.
- acdha 11y agoApple has a significant, growing share of the computers which people buy for themselves. If you go to a conference, coffee shop, etc. notice that more than half of the laptops are Macs. Windows has a huge lock-in for the business world due to compatibility, and a few other niches like high-end gaming for similar reasons. Without API compatibility that's a really tough space to get into. It's quite believable that Android/ChromeOS will take over the netbook market by being cheaper than Windows, and the premium personal market – which is where most of the profit is – if they can get quality hardware shipping at prices competitive enough to make up for the lack of applications (almost all Android apps will need some sort of UI modifications) but it really doesn't seem like they'll get anywhere in the business world. Cracking that means either convincing everyone to drop legacy apps for web apps or remote clients (how many more decades?) or offering API compatibility (invest heavily in WINE?) — otherwise, the cost of a Windows license isn't that much (especially with 10) and certainly not enough to push someone towards the most limited option.
- iofj 11y ago> It's quite believable that Android/ChromeOS will take over the netbook market by being cheaper than Windows Every store I visit the cheapest laptop-like devices are windows 10 devices, 20-30$ cheaper than chrome os devices. Android ones certainly exist, but only start at roughly double the price of cheap windows 10 machines. Those windows 10 machines aren't even bad. If you need office + browser they work pretty well. Just checking today on Amazon: Cheapest chromebook: 161.99 (and that's the Asus C201, as in STAY AWAY). Cheapest vaguely reasonable chromebook ~210 Cheapest windows 10 laptop: 164.89. This one is actually usable. Screen resolution being the biggest minus point. Cheapest android "laptop": 165, and this is not something you want. Cheapest one you do want: ~$300. There are cheaper android laptops, but they're chinese duplicates you do not want. Outside of the US, windows 10 laptops win by a mug bigger margin.
- acdha 11y agoAgreed. Right now, I think much of that would be explained by existing contracts and volume – the Windows devices are shipping in much larger quantities whereas the Android faux-laptops have tended to be curiosities rather than serious ventures. I think if Google continues to be willing to subsidize Android development at a loss to maintain marketshare, that could change if Microsoft isn't willing to lower the price for a consumer copy of Windows to zero. Anyone who remembers the 90s knows that Microsoft is unlikely to make it that easy.