4 ms·
Facebook have some really horrible policies. A woman has some photos of her and her partner on her profile. He then murders her, is arrested and sent to priso
by DanBC 11y ago
Facebook have some really horrible policies.
A woman has some photos of her and her partner on her profile. He then murders her, is arrested and sent to prison. Her profile is memorialised. This means all those images of him are still on her wall. Nice memorial.
The family have asked FB to remove those images. FB have declined.
https://www.change.org/p/facebook-remove-the-pictures-of-hollie-gazzards-killer-from-her-facebook-page https://www.change.org/p/facebook-remove-the-pictures-of-hol...
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoHmm, tricky one. In this specific case, maybe it's a reasonable request. But people who don't have benevolent families would definitely not want to hand control of their online identity to them after death.
- bad_user 11y agoI don't think there's any doubt in this specific case, there's really no room for "maybe". We're humans, can understand language, surely we can understand why a family would want pictures of their daughter's killer off her wall. How many people don't have benevolent families? In my opinion, if you're going to err on one side, that's not a good side to err on. And many people aren't even aware that their account will get "memorialized" after they're dead. That's a very strange default.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoI believe the legal principle of inheritance is that the heir is the same person as the deceased. So barring a provision in the person's will saying "nobody gets my facebook profile", Facebook would be legally in the wrong here?
- onewaystreet 11y agoThat story could easily read like this: A trans woman has some photos of her and her partner on her profile. Her partner then murders her, is arrested and sent to prison. Her profile is memorialised. Her family gets access to her account from Facebook and replaces all of her photos with photos of her before her transition. Facebook has no way of knowing the motives of people so they don't try to.
- tellarin 11y agoThe family doesn't need access to the account. It can still be "memorialized". Facebook could very well deal with a list of images to remove and the reason for it. In this case, the reason is cristal clear.
- onewaystreet 11y agoA trans woman has some photos of her and her partner on her profile. She and her partner die in a car crash. Her profile is memorialized. Her family gets Facebook to remove all of the photos with her and her partner.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThat's why I think that accounts shouldn't be "memorialized" but "frozen in time". Once the person dies, all that data should become a matter of public history record. No alterations.
- pmoriarty 11y agoBetter yet, their account should just be closed and the content be taken down permanently. If someone else wants to "memorialize" them, they should just do so on their own active account, using whatever content they deem fit.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI disagree. The default should be to preserve the record of a person, not trying to erase them from history and pretend they never existed.
- pmoriarty 11y agoWhat happened before Facebook? Did dying people get "erased from history" and did everyone just pretend they never existed? You don't need a Facebook page for people to know you existed.
- rhizome 11y agoThis means FB is reserving for itself some form of proof of kinship that does not yet exist and which is not the government's.