4 ms·
I am not claiming it more mysterious than relativity not sure why you keep talking about that. I say that they are both proven to any extent anything can be. I
by ThomPete 11y ago
I am not claiming it more mysterious than relativity not sure why you keep talking about that. I say that they are both proven to any extent anything can be.
I am saying that they can't be reconciled philosophically and so we have different interpretations none of them fully adequate to create a unified theory.
I am guessing that you are one of those who don't care about that part and thats fine. But to claim that there is no conflict and no disagreement and that other physicists doesn't is wrong.
The evolution and climate change remark is just arrogant and uncalled for not sure whats up with the attitude.
- lisper 11y ago> I am saying that they can't be reconciled philosophically I know that's what you're saying. I'm saying you're wrong about that. They can be and have been reconciled both mathematically and philosophically. > The evolution and climate change remark is just arrogant and uncalled for not sure whats up with the attitude. It's because your argument has the same form as their arguments. You have made a bald assertion of impossibility with no supporting evidence ("They can't be reconciled philosophically", c.f. "Evolution can't explain X" for some value of X.) Moreover, you have apparently not even bothered to look at the references I provided to support my position because you have made no substantive comments regarding them. You are arguing from manifest ignorance. > I have read enough and followed enough discussions to know that not everyone agrees with your memo characterization Sure. You can also find extensive literature supporting the creationist and climate-change-denialist positions too. They are all demonstrably wrong, notwithstanding that many people remain in denial about it.
- ThomPete 11y ago"They can't be reconciled philosophically" So in other words taking things out of context is how you came to that conclusion. Well done. Thats not the meaning of what I said. I was talking about the CURRENT state as most talk about it. I made no claims about universal impossibility simply that this is the current positions. Which is funny enough why the Rons talk tries to debunk some of that mysticism ironically only to turn into one himself. A quick search on Rons name show plenty of debunking I can't even be bothered as I have seen this before whether this or electrical universe theory etc. http://motls.blogspot.com/2012/10/evading-quantum-mechanics-again.html http://motls.blogspot.com/2012/10/evading-quantum-mechanics-... In this discussion you are the climate sceptic and the creationist not me.
- lisper 11y agoLubos Motl clearly didn't pay attention to the actual content of the talk. The evidence for this is: "At the end, he says lots of correct things" Well, there's a reason that the correct things are at the end and the beginning of the talk contains seemingly incorrect things. That's because the first half of the talk is a reductio-ad-absurdum argument against the Copenhagen interpretation, i.e. it deliberately assumes a false premise and reasons from there to a false conclusion (a violation of relativity) in order to show that the premise is false. And I take great pains to point this out. (Yes, I am "the Ron" as you put it.) Start at the 4:50 mark and watch for about two minutes.
- ThomPete 11y agoYou have a funny way of finding proof by inflating small fragments to become the entire story. I now understand how you theorize. So in other words. Your interpretation. Which is exactly what I asked you in the beginning. You believe you found a way to interpret it. Great now line up with all the others who also have their interpretation. You are the climate sceptic here you are the creationist. You know what you have to do to prove you theory and you know what awaits if you do and I am sure "the press" will get that memo. Until then. Despite my laymans understanding of QM, I think I will stick with my original TL;DR which tries to stay away from any specific interpretation.
- lisper 11y ago> inflating small fragments HN comments don't lend themselves well to long-form writing. But in this case it wasn't really necessary to go past that one small fragment to see that Motl had not in fact paid attention to the details because he's attacking a straw man. > Your interpretation No, not mine. Nicolas Cerf and Chris Adami's 9http://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/9605002v2.pdf http://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/9605002v2.pdf). And W.H. Zurek's (http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0306072 http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0306072). And David Mermin's (http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9609013 http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9609013). And Hugh Everett's (http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-everett/#3 http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-everett/#3, though I do put a slightly different spin on it -- no pun intended.) Arguably even John von Neuman's, and there is some evidence that Heisenberg actually understood the connection between measurement and entanglement as well. To be clear: I am not claiming to have discovered anything new. My only contribution is a pedagogical one: a reductio-ad-absurdum argument showing how Copenhagen, if it were true, would lead to faster-than-light communication. > You are the climate sceptic here you are the creationist Another characteristic of creationists is that they, like you, adamantly refuse to actually look at the evidence presented to them.